The Mill: a stone water mill with a big turning wheel on a river bend.

Writing Lessons and Exercises · The Mill

Revision and self-editing: lessons and exercises

Reading your own draft as an editor would, from structure down to the line.

  • 18 lessons
  • about 94 minutes of reading
  • 90 exercises
  • 10 warm-ups

The path · 18 lessons

Eighteen stones to the Mill

  • Foundation 4
  • Intermediate 12
  • Advanced 2
  1. Foundation

    Lesson 1: The order of passes

    Revising from the largest problems down: structure first, then scenes, then sentences, then errors.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  2. Foundation

    Lesson 2: Reading as a reader

    Gaining distance from your own draft: rest, a change of format, reading aloud.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  3. Foundation

    Lesson 3: Reverse outlining

    Outlining the draft as it is, to see what is really there.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  4. Foundation

    Lesson 4: Crutch words and tics

    Finding personal overused words, gestures and constructions.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  5. Intermediate

    Lesson 5: Scene-level revision

    Testing each scene for purpose, conflict and change.

    6 min read · 5 exercises

  6. Intermediate

    Lesson 6: Cutting

    Removing scenes, characters and lines that do not serve the story.

    6 min read · 5 exercises

  7. Intermediate

    Lesson 7: Line editing

    Improving clarity, rhythm and precision sentence by sentence.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  8. Intermediate

    Lesson 8: Continuity

    Keeping facts, timeline and character details consistent.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  9. Advanced

    Lesson 9: Using feedback

    Sorting notes by pattern and by what the story is trying to do.

    6 min read · 5 exercises

  10. Intermediate

    Lesson 10: Structural editing

    Testing a draft’s large shape on its reverse outline (whose story it is, whether the ending answers the opening, who causes the big turns, which storylines belong) and making structural changes on the outline before the prose.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  11. Intermediate

    Lesson 11: Triage: what to fix first

    Sorting a long list of revision notes before fixing any: finding the roots that cause other problems, weighing each note by how much of the book it touches, and putting every note on a pile (now, later, or not this draft) with a reason.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  12. Intermediate

    Lesson 12: Cutting a darling

    Taking out a scene, chapter, character or storyline you love that the book does not need: judging it by reading the book without it, moving the one job it does into a scene that stays, and cutting it whole rather than shrinking it.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  13. Intermediate

    Lesson 13: The revision plan

    Writing a short plan for a whole revision: the book’s aim, the big changes, the passes in order with one question each and the chapters they touch, a parked list and a finish line, updated with dates as each pass shows something new.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  14. Intermediate

    Lesson 14: Revision passes on a calendar

    Turning an ordered list of revision passes into dates: sizing each pass by what it touches and by the writer’s own recorded pace, placing it in the kind of time it needs, giving it a condition that ends it, and building in slack and rest so the revision finishes without a crunch.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  15. Advanced

    Lesson 15: Canon across a series

    Knowing which facts each published book has fixed, writing the world’s hard limits as checkable canon rules, and checking every new book against them at set moments.

    6 min read · 5 exercises

  16. Intermediate

    Lesson 16: The style sheet

    A list of the choices one book makes about how words are written (spellings, hyphens, capitals, numbers, italics, invented words), kept so the same form is used everywhere.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  17. Intermediate

    Lesson 17: Proofreading methods

    The last pass, for errors with a right answer, and the methods that make a familiar page strange enough to show what is on it.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  18. Intermediate

    Lesson 18: Editing you can afford

    Knowing the four kinds of edit, deciding which your book needs most, doing what you can yourself, and choosing and briefing an editor for the rest.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

What you’ll practise

By the last stone

Each lesson is short and ends in exercises. By the last stone you will have practised all of these.

The lessons draw on Browne and King, Quiller-Couch and King.

  • Foundation · 4 lessons
    • The order of passes
    • Reading as a reader
    • Reverse outlining
    • Crutch words and tics
  • Intermediate · 12 lessons
    • Scene-level revision
    • Cutting
    • Line editing
    • Continuity
    • Structural editing
    • Triage: what to fix first
    • Cutting a darling
    • The revision plan
    • Revision passes on a calendar
    • The style sheet
    • Proofreading methods
    • Editing you can afford
  • Advanced · 2 lessons
    • Using feedback
    • Canon across a series

How you’ll practise

Ten kinds of exercise in this craft

  • Multiple choice19 exercises

    A writer copy-editing her mystery notes down four things. Which one belongs on the style sheet?

  • Spot it11 exercises

    One adverb and one gesture are overused in this passage. Select every use of each. There are four of the adverb and three of the gesture.

  • Compare two versions5 exercises

    A crime writer asked two editors about a copyedit. Choose the reply that gives her more to decide on, and pick every reason that holds.

  • Sort14 exercises

    A writer is setting out her style sheet. Put each entry under the heading where it belongs.

  • Label the passage5 exercises

    Six errors in this literary passage are marked. Label each one by its kind.

  • Rewrite11 exercises

    Proofread this passage. It has six errors of the kinds a spellchecker misses. Correct them and change nothing else.

  • Write a scene7 exercises

    Turn a writer’s jumbled reading notes into a revision plan with four passes.

  • Write under a rule1 exercise

    Write a short exchange between two people, one of whom is hiding something. You may not use the commonest filler words, and nobody may nod, sigh, shrug or smile. When you want one of those gestures, find something the character can do with what is in the room.

  • Apply to your book18 exercises

    Write the plan for revising your own draft on one or two pages.

  • Warm-up10 exercises

    Pick a scene you know well from any book or film. Answer in one sentence each: what is different by the end? What pushes back against the main character? Where exactly does it turn?

Bring it together · about 35 min

One page, four passes

Revise a flawed page of draft as you would across the passes of a full revision: the scene first, then the cuts, then the lines, then the facts.

Free with an account

Write the scene, read it beside a model answer and check it against the lessons you have done.