Lesson 11 of 18
The Mill · stone 11Intermediate5 minute read

Triage: what to fix first

Sorting a long list of revision notes before fixing any: finding the roots that cause other problems, weighing each note by how much of the book it touches, and putting every note on a pile (now, later, or not this draft) with a reason.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-14

The Mill: a stone water mill with a big turning wheel on a river bend.
The Mill · Revision and self-editing, stone 11 of 18

Too many notes to start

After a read-through and a round of feedback, the list of things to fix can run to dozens of items. Two orders tempt. One is the order you found them in, which means starting with chapter one. The other is easiest first, to feel some progress. Both spend effort on pages that may not survive.

Ask all three of every note before you fix any of them.

Triage is sorting the list before you do any of it. Ask three questions of each note.

Does fixing this settle others? Some notes are causes, and some are effects of a cause written down elsewhere on the list.

How much of the book does it touch? A problem in one paragraph and a problem that runs through ten chapters are not the same size, however they are worded.

What will it cost? A cut, a scene rewritten, a third of the book reworked. Cost does not decide the order, but it tells you how to plan the weeks.

Roots and symptoms

Many notes on a long list are one problem seen from different chapters. “The middle drags.” “She seems a passenger.” “The two interviews end the same way.” Read together, they may come from a single root: after the midpoint, the lead wants nothing, so she can only react.

A reader’s note is often the last link in a chain, and the fix belongs at the first.

To find a root, group the notes by the stretch of the book they point at, then ask why of each one until the answers start to agree. Readers report symptoms; the root is usually something they could not see, because it is in what is missing.

Fix the root first. Then reread the symptoms. Many go away by themselves, and the ones that remain become ordinary notes for later passes. Fixing the symptoms one at a time leaves the root in place, and it grows new ones.

Three piles

With the roots found, every note goes on one of three piles.

Every note goes somewhere, and only the first pile is worked on now.

Now: the roots and the problems that run through the book, in order of reach. These are your first weeks.

Later: scene notes, line notes and errors, each filed under the pass where it belongs. Filing a note is not ignoring it. A misspelt name goes on the continuity list today and gets fixed in the polish pass, after the chapters around it have stopped moving.

Not this draft: notes you have decided against, and notes that ask for a different book. Write one line saying why. A note with a reason beside it stops nagging; a note left floating comes back every time you open the file.

Example

A triage note

A romance writer has forty-one notes from her own read-through and two beta readers. This is how she sorts them.

The Orchard Year: triageromance

Forty-one notes, from my read-through and two beta readers. Three questions for each: does fixing it settle others, how much of the book does it touch, and what will it cost?1

Root: after the midpoint, Hal wants nothing.2 For ten chapters he reacts to Nora. Touches 15 to 25. Cost: a new goal for him and four scenes rewritten.

Symptoms of that root, to reread after the fix and not before3: “the middle drags” (both readers); “Hal is a bit of a doormat”; the two picnics that end the same way; Nora carrying every conversation in part two.

Wide but separate: the wedding is in June in chapter 4 and in August in chapter 22. Six chapters, ten minutes. It goes in the continuity pass.4

Now: Hal’s goal, then the four scenes.

Later, each in its own pass: the stiff dialogue in the market scenes, my habit of “just”, the baker’s name spelt two ways.

Not this draft: one reader wants a second timeline, set in the 1970s. That is a different book. Noted, with thanks.5

  1. “does fixing it settle others, how much of the book does it touch,…”The three questions, asked of every note before any is acted on.
  2. “Root: after the midpoint, Hal wants nothing.”The root is something missing, which is why neither reader could name it.
  3. “to reread after the fix and not before”Symptoms are held, not fixed. Several will go when Hal has a goal again.
  4. “Six chapters, ten minutes. It goes in the continuity pass.”Wide but cheap, and caused by nothing else on the list, so it waits for its pass.
  5. “That is a different book. Noted, with thanks.”A declined note with its reason, so it stops coming back.

Before and after

Easiest first, or root first

The one faultThe list is ordered by how easy each fix is, not by what each fix changes.

Weaker versionThe Ember Crown: order of work (first version)

Order of work, easiest first, to build momentum.

1. Fix the river’s name, which is spelt two ways.

2. Cut the tavern scene in chapter 6, which repeats chapter 3.

3. Rewrite the stiff dialogue in the sword lesson.

4. Give the queen a reason to trust Kell in chapter 12. At present she just does.

5. At the climax, the prophecy makes Kell’s choice for him. Make it his own, which changes chapters 18 to 24 and the queen’s trust with them.

Showing the weaker version.

The two lists hold the same five items, word for word. Only the order differs.

The first starts with the river’s name and works up to Kell’s choice. By the time the writer reaches item 5, she has rewritten the queen’s trust in chapter 12, and item 5 says the new climax changes that trust again. The momentum she built was spent on work she now has to redo.

The second starts with the root. Once Kell’s choice is his own, the writer can see what the queen needs to believe in chapter 12, and write it once. The small fixes come last, when the chapters around them have stopped moving.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

A small fix can jump the queue when it would trip you up on every page: a character renamed halfway, or a date that makes your own outline confusing. Do it in minutes and go back to the list.

A deadline changes triage. If the root cannot be fixed in the time you have, choose what can be made to work, and write down what you are leaving and why. That is still triage; it is triage with a clock.

And if the list has no root at all, only a scatter of separate small problems, that is good news. File them under their passes and start the scene pass.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Which note first?

Four notes from the read-through of a thriller draft. Which one should the writer work on first?

Key takeaway

Sort the list before you fix anything. Ask of each note whether fixing it settles others, how much of the book it touches and what it will cost. Fix the roots first and reread their symptoms after, file the smaller notes under the passes where they belong, and give every declined note a one-line reason.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Triage your own notes

Gather all your notes on the draft, find the roots, and put every note on a pile with a reason.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.