Four kinds of edit
Editing is several jobs done at different scales, and they are often sold separately.
Largest first
- StructuralPlot, pace, character, the ending
- LineClarity, rhythm and voice, sentence by sentence
- CopyeditCorrectness, and the facts of your own story
- ProofreadThe last errors, on the finished pages
A developmental or structural edit looks at the whole book: plot, pace, character, whether the ending pays off what came before. A line edit works sentence by sentence on clarity, rhythm and voice. A copyedit checks correctness and consistency: grammar, spelling, punctuation, and the facts of your own story, such as names, ages and dates. A proofread is the last look, at the finished pages, for the errors that are left.
They go in that order, largest first. A proofread bought before a structural change pays for checking sentences that may be cut. And the names are not used the same way by everyone, so when you talk to an editor, ask what their edit covers rather than trusting the label.
Spend where you cannot see
You do not need to buy every kind of edit, and few first books can. The question is where your blind spots are.
Who checks what
- You, with methodReverse outline, reading aloud, crutch words, a fact record
- Free readersWhere they were bored, lost or unconvinced
- Paid, where you are blindThe one edit your own checks cannot replace
Some checks you can make yourself, with time and method: a reverse outline, reading aloud, a pass for your own crutch words, a written record of names and dates. BlurbBio’s Repetition Library and its Scene Purpose analysis can point you to places worth a second look. Other help costs nothing but goodwill. Beta readers and critique partners are good at telling you where they were bored, lost or unconvinced.
What is hardest to do alone is the thing you cannot see because you wrote it: whether a first book’s structure holds, and the small errors your eye corrects as it reads. If you can pay for one edit, put it where your own checks are weakest. Your beta readers’ notes are the best guide. If they agree about a problem in the shape of the book, pay for a structural edit. If they enjoyed it from start to finish, a careful copyedit may be the better buy.
Choosing and briefing an editor
Before you hire anyone, ask what exactly their edit covers and what it leaves out, whether they will do a sample edit of a few pages of your own book, whether they have edited books like yours, and what you will receive and by when. Get the answers and the price in writing before work starts. Prices vary a great deal between editors and between kinds of edit, so compare like with like: a quote for a proofread and a quote for a structural edit are quotes for different jobs.
Before you say yes
- What does it cover?And what it leaves out
- A sample editA few pages of your own book
- Books like yours?Experience of your genre
- In writingWhat you receive, when, and the price
Then brief the editor well. Say what kind of edit you want, the genre and length, what has been done to the book so far, and what worries you. An editor told that the middle may sag and the heroine may seem cold can look hard at both.
Example
An enquiry an editor can answer
A historical novelist writes to a copyeditor. Notice how much the editor learns in a few short paragraphs.
Subject: Copyedit enquiry, historical novel, 96,000 words
Dear Ms Okafor,
I am looking for a copyedit of my novel1, The Weaver’s Daughter, a historical novel of about 96,000 words set in a mill town in the 1840s. It has had a structural pass after notes from four beta readers, and I have done my own line edit.2
What worries me most is consistency.3 There are thirty named characters, two timelines a generation apart, and a good deal of detail about looms and wages that I would like checked against itself. I keep a style sheet and can send it.
Could you tell me what your copyedit covers, whether you would do a sample edit of the first few pages4, and when you might have space? I would like the terms in writing before we begin.5
With thanks,
Ruth Calloway
- “I am looking for a copyedit of my novel”The kind of edit, named in the first line.
- “It has had a structural pass after notes from four beta readers, a…”Where the book stands. The editor knows they are not being asked to fix the plot.
- “What worries me most is consistency.”The worry, then the reasons for it: a large cast, two timelines, a lot of period detail.
- “whether you would do a sample edit of the first few pages”A sample shows her how this editor works before she commits.
- “I would like the terms in writing before we begin.”Polite and plain. Both sides know what was agreed.
Before and after
One edit, two places to spend it
The one faultThe one paid edit goes on the smallest job while readers have flagged a problem in the structure.
Budget: enough for one paid edit.
My three beta readers all said the same thing: they stopped being frightened halfway through, once the thing in the well is explained. Two of them put the book down for a week at that point.
Plan: pay for a professional proofread now, so that the text is clean, and look at the middle myself later if I have time.
Both plans start from the same budget and the same notes, and the notes are clear: three readers lost their fear at the same point, and two stopped reading there. That is a problem in the shape of the book.
The first plan spends its one edit on a proofread, the job that comes last, and leaves the real problem for later, if there is time. If the middle is then rewritten, much of the proofread is wasted.
The second plan spends the money where the readers pointed, tells the editor where to look, and fills in the smaller jobs with free help and the writer’s own passes, in order from large to small.
The exception
When to break it
The order is a default. A writer who has had a structural edit on a series’ first book may know their shape well enough to skip it for the second. A writer with a strong ear may line-edit their own work and pay only for a copyedit and a proofread. And if beta readers report nothing but typos, a structural edit would be money spent looking for a problem nobody has found.
What holds in every case: find out what the book needs before you choose what to buy, and do not pay for the small jobs before the large ones are settled.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Where to spend
A romance writer can afford one paid edit. Her four beta readers all enjoyed the book, finished it quickly and had no notes about the story. Two of them sent long lists of typos, a heroine whose sister has two different names, and a wedding that happens on a Tuesday and then a Saturday. Which edit should she buy?
Key takeaway
There are four kinds of edit, from the whole book down to the last error, and they go in that order. Do the checks you can do yourself, ask free readers what they notice, and spend on the one thing neither can see. Before you hire an editor, ask what the edit covers, get a sample and the terms in writing, and brief them on your worries.
