What a line edit looks for
A line edit goes through the prose one sentence at a time. It comes after the structure and the scenes are settled, and it leaves events alone. It asks of each sentence: is this clear, does it sound right, and is each word the exact one?
Three of the five groups
She nodded her head2 and began to walk1 down to the river in order to1 see some kind of bird3.
- Padding“Walked”; “to”
- Saying it twice“Nodded”
- A vague wordYou know it was a heron
Most of what it finds falls into five groups.
Padding. “In order to” for “to”. “Due to the fact that” for “because”. “Was in the process of mending” for “was mending”. “Began to walk” for “walked”, when nothing interrupts the walking.
Saying it twice. “Nodded her head.” “Shrugged his shoulders.” “Whispered quietly.” “Thought to herself.”
A vague word where you know the exact one. “Some kind of bird”, when you know it was a heron. “Went”, when she limped.
Tangles. A sentence that makes the reader hold a clause in the air while waiting for the verb. Bring the subject and the verb together, and let the sentence end on the word that matters.
Monotony. A run of sentences of the same length and build. You will hear it sooner than you see it, so read aloud.
What an edit should not cost
Shorter is the usual result of a line edit, but it is not the aim. Three things are worth more than brevity.
Worth more than brevity
Meaning. Every fact and action has to survive. “He appeared to be asleep” and “he was asleep” are different statements, and only one of them leaves room for a surprise.
Voice. A narrator’s way of putting things is often the reason to stay with her. An edit that makes every book sound like the same book has failed. Before you strike a phrase, ask whether it is padding or personality.
Time. A long sentence can be there to slow the reader down at a moment that deserves it. Trimmed, the moment goes by too fast.
So the question to put to each phrase is “what would be lost?” and not “can this be shorter?”. When the answer is “nothing”, cut.
Example
A paragraph before its line edit
Eighty-odd words of draft. Nothing here is a mistake, and every note is a small improvement.
Lowell made his way slowly up the stairs1 to the coroner’s office, which was located on the second floor of the building2. He knocked on the door with his knuckles3. There was no answer. He tried the handle, and the door, which was not locked, opened.
The room was empty. On the desk there was a cup of tea that was still warm, and next to the cup there was some kind of paper4. He thought to himself5 that the coroner could not have gone far.
- “made his way slowly up the stairs”A vague verb propped up by an adverb. “Climbed the stairs” is exact, and if the slowness matters, “toiled up” or “took the stairs one at a time” says why.
- “which was located on the second floor of the building”Padding. “On the second floor” does all of it. Offices are located, and floors are in buildings.
- “with his knuckles”Said twice. Knocking is done with the knuckles unless we are told otherwise.
- “some kind of paper”Vague, at the one point where the reader wants to lean in. The writer knows what the paper is. “A death certificate, unsigned” would change the scene.
- “He thought to himself”Said twice. There is nobody else he could think to.
The explainer
Trim the airlock
Shirin’s airlock, and the first version of the passage, one sentence at a time. Press a sentence to cut its padding. Each clue lights up as the sentence gets to the thing in the room sooner.

Changes left
10 of 10
Words
99 (was 99)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
The same paragraph, with the padding out
The one faultPadding: phrases that take up room without adding meaning.
Shirin was in the process of checking the seals on the airlock when she noticed the fact that the outer gauge was reading zero. She tapped on it with her finger. It still continued to read zero. In order to be certain, she crossed over to the inner gauge, which was on the opposite side of the lock, and read that one too. It read normal pressure. One of the two gauges was wrong, and due to the fact that she was standing in between them without a suit on, she very much hoped it was the outer one.
The first version is about a hundred words and the second about seventy-five. Nothing happens in one that does not happen in the other.
What went: “in the process of”, “the fact that”, “on it with her finger”, “continued to”, “in order”, “over”, “which was”, “due to the fact that”, “in”, “on”. Each could be lifted out, or swapped for a single word, with no change to the sense.
What stayed is as instructive. “She very much hoped it was the outer one” could lose “very much”, and a stricter edit would take it. But the dry understatement is the narrator’s voice, and it is the best thing in the paragraph. That phrase is personality, not padding.
The exception
When to break it
Edit narration harder than speech. People pad when they talk, and a character who says “at this moment in time” is being drawn by it. Tidy her and you lose her.
Where to edit lightly
“Began to” is right when the action is interrupted: “She began to raise her hand, then stopped.” A doubled statement can be right for emphasis, and a repeated word can be a drumbeat.
Some voices are long on purpose. A historical novel that borrows the manner of its period, or a narrator who cannot come to the point, needs its extra clauses. Cut what the voice would not miss and leave the rest.
And know when to stop. If an edited passage has started to read like a telegram, with every sentence the same clipped length, you have gone past clear and into bare. Put some of it back.
Last, do not line edit a scene that has not been through the scene pass. You may be polishing something that is about to go.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
The best edit
Here is a sentence from a draft: “She nodded her head in agreement and started to walk in the direction of the door.” Which is the best line edit?
Key takeaway
A line edit takes each sentence and removes what does no work: padding, things said twice, vague words standing in for exact ones. It leaves the events, the meaning and the voice as they were. Ask of each phrase what would be lost without it, and cut only when the answer is nothing.
