The building, not the rooms
Structural editing is the first and largest revision pass. It looks at the book as a building and leaves the rooms for later. The lesson on the order of passes explains why it comes first. This lesson is about what to look for, and how to make a structural change without rewriting a page before you know what the book needs.
Five questions for the whole book
- Whose story?Who changes most, and who chooses at the climax
- Question and answerDoes the ending answer what the opening asked?
- The big turnsWhere they fall, and who causes them
- Storylines that touchEach one changes something for the lead
- Missing or doubledA promised scene that never comes, or one job done twice
Work from a reverse outline, one line per scene or chapter, and ask five questions of the whole.
Whose story is it? Usually the person who changes most and who makes the choice at the climax. If that is not the person the book spends its time with, you have found something.
What question does the opening ask, and does the ending answer it? A book can open on a missing child and end on a wedding, and the reader will feel short-changed without quite knowing why.
Where do the big turns fall, and who causes them? The commitment, the midpoint and the climax work best when they come from the lead’s choices, not from luck or from someone else.
Does every storyline touch the main one? A subplot that never changes anything for the lead is a second book sharing the binding.
What is promised and missing, or there twice? A confrontation the book has leaned towards for two hundred pages, or two chapters doing one job.
Change the outline, then the draft
A structural change is cheap on the outline and dear in the prose. Moving a line on a page takes a minute. Moving a chapter means rewriting the chapters on either side, the clues planted for it and every reference back to it.
Outline first
- Reverse outlineOne line per scene, from the draft as written
- Ask the five questionsOf the whole book at once
- Change the outlineUntil it reads as the book you want
- Write the knock-on listScenes to write, cut, move; details to plant
- Then the draftDown the list, in order
So make the change on the outline first. Rewrite the lines it touches until the outline reads as the book you now want. Then write a knock-on list: every scene to write new, cut, move or rewrite, and every detail that has to be planted earlier or taken out later. Number the items by chapter.
Only then open the draft, and work down the knock-on list in order. You will find more as you go; add it to the list. Leave the sentences alone for now. A paragraph polished this week may sit in a chapter the list has already cut.
Example
A structural note
A historical novelist has finished her reverse outline. This is the note she writes from it, before she touches a sentence.
Written after the reverse outline, 31 chapters. No sentences touched yet.
Whose story: Agnes. She changes most, and the last choice is hers.1 Her brother Tom has eight chapters of his own, and none of them changes anything for her2.
The opening question: will Agnes keep the salt works out of her uncle’s hands? Chapter 1 asks it on the first page.
The ending: Agnes marries the surveyor and leaves the coast. The salt works are not mentioned after chapter 27.3
The turns: she commits in chapter 9, late but workable. The midpoint is a fire she does not cause. The climax is her uncle’s fall from the jetty, which settles everything for her.4
Missing: from chapter 2 the book promises a reckoning between Agnes and her uncle. It never comes.5
The change, on the outline: the reckoning becomes the climax. Agnes forces the sale at the town auction and loses the surveyor by doing it. Tom’s story folds into hers.
Knock-on list:6 cut six of Tom’s chapters and turn two into Agnes scenes; plant the auction in 12; cut the fall; write the auction; rewrite 28 to 31.
- “Whose story: Agnes. She changes most, and the last choice is hers.”The first question, answered from the outline: the lead is the one who changes and who chooses.
- “none of them changes anything for her”A storyline that never touches the main one. Tom’s chapters may be good; structurally they are a second book.
- “The salt works are not mentioned after chapter 27.”The opening asked about the salt works. The ending answers a different question, about marriage.
- “The climax is her uncle’s fall from the jetty, which settles every…”The biggest turn is caused by an accident. Agnes is let off her own climax.
- “from chapter 2 the book promises a reckoning between Agnes and her…”A promised scene that is missing. Here it turns out to be the cure for two other problems.
- “Knock-on list:”The change is made on the outline, then listed as work in chapter order, before any prose is opened.
Before and after
Which question does the ending answer?
The one faultThe last chapter answers a question the first chapter never asked.
Chapter 1. On the relay station Kessick, the engineer Dara Onwu finds that the air plant is failing and the company will not send parts before the next supply ship, nine weeks away. Forty people live on the station. Dara decides to build the parts herself.
Chapter 30. On the observation deck, as the supply ship docks, Dara and the station doctor, Ilse, admit at last what they feel for each other. They will take the ship home together.
Both openings are the same: an air plant failing, forty people, nine weeks, and an engineer who decides to build the parts herself. That is the question the book asks: can Dara keep them breathing?
The first ending is warm, and it may be a good scene. But it answers a different question, whether Dara and Ilse will find each other, and the air plant has gone. A reader who has spent thirty chapters on those parts closes the book still holding them.
The second ending answers the question the opening asked, and keeps Ilse by giving her a place in that answer. The love story can stay; it just cannot be the last word on a book that promised something else. Sometimes the better fix is the other way round: change the opening so that it asks the question your ending answers.
The exception
When to break it
Some books are built to resist a single spine. An ensemble novel may have no one lead, and a linked collection may share a town rather than a question. Test them on their own terms: each strand should still open a question and close it, and the strands should meet somewhere.
An ending can also answer the opening question in a way nobody expected, or answer a deeper question underneath it. A search for a missing brother that ends with the sister choosing to stop searching is still an answer, as long as the reader can feel the connection.
And not every draft needs a structural change. If the five questions come back clean, write that down in a line and move on to the scene pass. Structural editing is a check, not a demolition.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which question fails?
A mystery writer’s reverse outline shows this. The detective, Ruth, investigates a death at a quarry across twenty-eight chapters, and she unmasks the killer herself in the last act. Her sister Lou has five chapters about her divorce. Nothing in them touches the case or changes anything Ruth does. Which of the five structural questions does the outline fail most plainly?
Key takeaway
Before you change a sentence, test the whole book on its reverse outline: whose story it is, whether the ending answers the opening, who causes the big turns, whether every storyline touches the main one, and what is missing or doubled. Make the change on the outline, write a knock-on list, and only then open the draft.
