Why write it down
A revision without a plan tends to turn into rereading. You open chapter one, improve it, feel the book getting better, and two months later you are improving chapter one again.
With and without a plan
A written plan settles three things in advance: what you are doing, in what order, and when you have finished. It also holds the decisions you have already made, in the structural note and the triage, so you do not argue them again every morning.
It need not be long. A page or two is enough, and a page you will read is worth more than ten you will not.
Five parts
The aim. What the book is for, in a sentence or two: what happens to whom, and the reader it is meant for. Every later decision gets tested against this.
A revision plan
- The aimWhat the book is for, and for whom
- The big changesFrom the structural note and triage
- The passes, in orderOne question each, and the chapters it touches
- The parked listWhat this revision will not do
- The finish lineWhat done means, and a date that fits your week
The big changes. The structural decisions and the roots from your triage, in a few lines each.
The passes, in order. Largest to smallest, each with one question and the chapters it touches. Structure, then arcs, scenes and pacing, then voice and dialogue, then lines, then polish. Some passes cover every page; others cover a stretch.
The parked list. What you have decided not to do in this revision: the notes declined in triage, the map, the sequel.
The finish line. What counts as done for this draft, which is not the same as perfect. The draft with readers, or with an editor, or put away for a second rest. Then a date or a number of sessions that fits your real week.
A plan that changes
The plan will change, because each pass shows you something. That is the plan working, not failing.
Pass by pass
- Do the passOne question, the chapters listed
- Note what it foundIncluding anything bigger
- Update the planDated, with the new item placed
- Start the next passFrom the plan as it now stands
Until the finish line
When a pass turns up something bigger than the pass you are in, a subplot that has to go in the middle of the dialogue pass, say, write it on the plan with the date and decide where it belongs in the order. Then finish the pass you are in, unless the new change would undo the work.
At the end of each pass, reread the plan. Tick off what is done, adjust what is next, and check the finish line still fits your weeks.
Example
A revision plan
A fantasy novelist’s plan, written after her structural note and triage, and changed once since.
Started 3 March.
What the book is for: a gatekeeper learns that keeping people out has cost her more than it saved.1 For readers who like a slow quest with a hard choice at the end.
The big changes, from the structural note and triage:2 Wren’s choice at the gate becomes her own, not the oracle’s. Her brother’s storyline joins hers at the ford. Chapters 6 and 9 merge.
The passes, in order, one question each:
1. Structure: does the outline now read as the book above? Chapters 6, 9, 18 to 24.
2. Arcs: does Wren change in steps the reader can see? Her chapters.3
3. Scenes: does each scene change something? Every chapter.
4. Pacing: where would a reader put it down? 10 to 17 first.
5. Voice and dialogue: does it sound like this book? 1 to 4 especially.
6. Line: is every sentence clear and doing work?
7. Polish: is it consistent and correct? Style sheet first.
Parked: the map, the glossary, book two.4
Done means: all seven passes finished and the draft with three readers.5 One pass a fortnight, Saturdays and two evenings. Readers by the end of June.
Changes: 20 April, pacing moved ahead of arcs.6 The middle was worse than I thought.
- “What the book is for: a gatekeeper learns that keeping people out…”The aim comes first, so every later decision can be tested against it.
- “The big changes, from the structural note and triage:”Decisions already made are carried in, not reopened.
- “2. Arcs: does Wren change in steps the reader can see? Her chapters.”One question per pass, and the chapters it touches. Not every pass covers every page.
- “Parked: the map, the glossary, book two.”What this revision will not do, written down so it stops pulling.
- “Done means: all seven passes finished and the draft with three rea…”A finish line that is not “perfect”, with a pace that fits the writer’s real week.
- “Changes: 20 April, pacing moved ahead of arcs.”The plan changed when a pass showed something. The change is dated, with its reason.
Before and after
Where does it end?
The one faultThe plan has no finish line.
What the book is for: a diver finds that her drowned village was flooded to hide a crime, and has to decide who to tell. For readers who like their thrillers cold and close.
The passes, in order: 1. Structure: the climax becomes Nell’s choice. Chapters 28 to 31. 2. Scenes: does each one change something? 3. Pacing: where would a reader stop? 12 to 20 first. 4. Dialogue: does each voice sound like its owner? The police scenes first. 5. Line, then polish.
The two plans are the same down to the last pass: an aim, a structural change, and passes from large to small, each with its question.
The first stops there. It says what to do and never says when the doing is over, so the line pass can run on for ever, and the writer may circle back to chapter one when the last pass ends.
The second adds three lines. Done means the draft is with two readers, not that it is perfect. The pace is set by the writer’s actual week. And the date has a consequence attached: no new book until it is met. Those lines are what turn a list of passes into a plan.
The exception
When to break it
A short revision needs a short plan. If the structural note came back clean and the triage found only line notes, three lines will do: the aim, the passes, the date.
Some writers revise in one long immersion, reading and fixing at every level together, and plan only the order of chapters. If that has worked for you before, keep doing it. A finish line still helps.
And a plan is not a contract. If a pass shows that the book is a different book, stop and write a new structural note. The old plan has done its job by getting you far enough to see that.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Something bigger, mid-pass
Halfway through her dialogue pass, a writer realises that a whole subplot, the neighbour’s feud, has to go. What should she do with her revision plan?
Key takeaway
Write the revision down on a page or two: the aim, the big changes, the passes in order with one question each, the parked list and a finish line that fits your week. Update the plan, with dates, at the end of every pass, so it always describes the revision you are actually doing.
