Lesson 3 of 18
The Mill · stone 3Foundation5 minute read

Reverse outlining

Outlining the draft as it is, to see what is really there.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Mill: a stone water mill with a big turning wheel on a river bend.
The Mill · Revision and self-editing, stone 3 of 18

An outline of what is there

A plan made before you write says what you intend. A reverse outline is made afterwards, from the finished draft, and says what you did. The two are seldom the same. Scenes were added on the way. The kiss did not happen. A minor character took over three chapters.

A plan says what you intended, and a reverse outline, made from the finished draft, says what you did.

To revise the book you have, and not the one you planned, you need a map of it. Here is how to draw one.

Go through the draft scene by scene. For each scene write one line with two parts: what happens, and what changes. “Osgar asks the miller for seed on credit and is refused. Now he has to choose between planting and his sister’s dowry.”

If nothing changes, write “Nothing changes”. Do not soften it.

Keep each line to what a stranger could check against the page. Leave out opinions (“my favourite”) and intentions (“meant to set up the ending”). If you want to keep those, give them a column of their own. Other columns some writers add: whose point of view, where and when, how many words.

What the outline shows you

A whole novel is too much to hold in your head at once, but a few pages of one-line entries can be read in minutes. Read that way, the draft shows patterns that cannot be seen from inside a page.

These patterns live in the gaps between chapters, which is why rereading chapter twelve will not find them.

Several “nothing changes” lines in a row mark the place where the book stands still.

Two lines that end the same way are a repeat: the reader is being given something twice.

A name that stops appearing is a dropped thread.

A change with no cause in any earlier line is a missing step.

None of these is a fault you could have found by rereading chapter twelve. They live in the gaps between chapters. That is why reading your reverse outline makes such a quick structure pass.

Example

From a scene to a line

One scene, and the parts of it that go into its line. The line is: “Osgar asks the miller for seed on credit and is refused. The miller will lend only against the upper pasture, which is his sister’s dowry. Now Osgar has to choose.”

Seed on creditfantasy

The miller would not come out, so Osgar went in. Flour hung in the air and settled on his sleeves.1 The great stone was turning with nothing under it.

“I need seed on credit,” he said.2 “Until the barley’s in.”

“You had credit last year.” The miller did not stop sweeping. “And the year before, your father had it. I am still owed for both.”

“The river took the lower field. You saw it.”

“I saw it.” He leaned the broom against the hopper. “I’ll not lend seed against a field that floods.3 Bring me the deed to the upper pasture and we’ll talk about barley.”4

Osgar looked at the stone going round. The upper pasture was his sister’s dowry. He said he would think about it, and they both knew what that meant.

  1. “Flour hung in the air and settled on his sleeves.”Left out of the line. It is a good detail, and an outline has no room for it. The outline records events and changes, and is blind to everything else.
  2. ““I need seed on credit,” he said.”What happens, first half: he asks. The line opens with this.
  3. ““I’ll not lend seed against a field that floods.”What happens, second half: he is refused.
  4. “Bring me the deed to the upper pasture and we’ll talk about barley.””What changes. A price has been named that was not there when the scene began. This is the part of the line that starts with “Now”.

Before and after

Five scenes, outlined twice

The one faultEach line names what the scene is about, and does not say what happens or what changes.

Weaker versionOutline of the first five scenes (first version)

1. The harbour at dawn. Introduces Sergeant Thandeka.

2. The fish market. Atmosphere, local colour.

3. Thandeka and the harbourmaster. Tension between them.

4. The boat. Clues.

5. Thandeka at home with her father. Backstory.

Showing the weaker version.

The first outline is tidy, and it would do as a set of labels on folders. As a tool for revision it tells you nothing. “The boat. Clues.” Which clues? Does the detective know more afterwards than she did before?

The second outline answers that for every scene. It also owns up to something the first one hides. Scene two is put down as “Nothing changes”. In the first outline that scene sits behind “Atmosphere, local colour” and looks as healthy as the others.

Now the writer can make a real decision about the fish market: cut it, or let somebody there say one true thing.

The exception

When to break it

A reverse outline is a blunt tool, and it helps to know what it cannot see.

A reverse outline is a blunt tool, so do not write “Nothing changes” because nothing exploded.

It is blind to voice, humour and the quality of the sentences. A scene marked “Nothing changes” may be the funniest in the book. The outline cannot tell you to cut it. It can only tell you what keeping it costs.

In a quiet novel the changes are small, and a line such as “She decides not to telephone” is a real entry. Do not inflate it, and do not write “Nothing changes” because nothing exploded.

A story of a few pages seldom needs one. For a very long book you may outline by chapter to save time, but chapter lines can hide a repeated scene inside a chapter.

And if you outlined before drafting, you still gain from doing it again in reverse. Laying the two outlines side by side shows where the book left the plan, and those are often the places where it came alive.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Which line belongs?

Four writers have each written a line for chapter seven of their draft. Which line is a reverse-outline entry: what happens and what changes, as a stranger could check it against the page?

Key takeaway

Outline the draft you wrote, one line to a scene: what happens, and what changes. Record only what is on the page, and write “Nothing changes” where that is the truth. Then read the lines together and look for repeats, still stretches and threads that vanish.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Five chapters, one line a scene

Write one line for every scene in five chapters of your draft, saying what happens and what changes. Then read the lines as a set and name one pattern.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.