Three questions for every scene
Once the structure is settled you know which scenes the book is made of. The scene pass takes them one at a time and asks three questions.
The scene pass
- PurposeWhat is different by the last line?
- ConflictWhat pushes back against the want?
- ChangeCan you put a finger on the turn?
Purpose. What is different by the last line: in the situation, in a relationship, or in what the reader knows?
Conflict. What pushes back against what the viewpoint character wants here? It can be a person, a circumstance, a clock, or the character’s own doubt, as long as the doubt is on the page.
Change. Can you put a finger on the line where things turn? Is the reader present for it, or told about it afterwards?
Answer from the page. What you intended the scene to do is not evidence.
Four decisions
Each scene then gets one of four decisions, with a reason.
One of four, with a reason
Keep. It passes all three. Leave it for the sentence pass.
Rewrite. The book needs what the scene delivers, but a test fails: nothing resists, or the turn is reported in a line of summary. Rewriting here means changing what happens in the scene. Polishing its sentences is a different job and will not help.
Merge. The scene does half a job, or the same job as its neighbour. Two thin scenes often make one good one. The price is logistics: everyone has to be in one place at one time.
Cut. The scene has no purpose, and nothing in it is needed.
Before you cut or merge, list the scene’s cargo: every fact, first appearance or setup that later pages rely on. A scene with no purpose may still be the only place the reader learns that the victim kept a dog. Find each item a home in a scene that is staying.
When a scene you love fails, ask which of the three questions it fails. Do not let the quality of its sentences answer for it.
Example
A scene that passes
A brother and sister in their late mother’s house. Follow the three questions through it.
Theodora had come for the piano.1 She had measured the hall of her flat twice, and it would fit if the door came off.
Her brother was sitting on the stool with his back to the keys. “The movers are booked for Friday,” she said.
“Then unbook them.”2 Barnabas did not get up. “Mother left it to the house.”
“Mother left the house to both of us, and you are selling it.”
“I am selling my half.” He lifted the lid and played one note, low, and let it ring. “The buyers have a daughter. Eight years old. They asked whether the piano came with it, and I said yes3.”
She had thought it would be about money. She found she had nothing ready for an eight-year-old. She picked up her tape measure from the lid, and for the first time in her life she left that room without having the last word4.
- “Theodora had come for the piano.”What she wants, in the first sentence. A scene that states the want early is easy to test, because you know what an outcome would look like.
- ““Then unbook them.””Conflict, by the third paragraph. Her brother has a reason too, and gives it.
- “and I said yes”The turn, and the reader is in the room for it. The piano has been promised to someone she cannot argue with.
- “she left that room without having the last word”Purpose. She came in certain of taking the piano and goes out without it and without a reply. Decision: keep, because all three questions have answers on the page.
Before and after
The same errand, with and without resistance
The one faultNothing pushes back: she asks for the crates and is given them.
Ilinca reached the customs shed as the noon gun went. Her father’s crates were stacked against the far wall, forty of them, each stencilled with the name of the ship.
“I need these released today,” she told the officer. “The buyer sails on the evening tide.”
He found the entry in his book and ran a finger along it. “Duty was paid in March. Sign here.”
She signed. He stamped the page, tore off the lower half and gave it to her.
By four o’clock the crates were at the quay.
The first version has a clear want and clean sentences. It fails the conflict question, and so it fails the other two as well. Ilinca asks, signs and leaves. A line of summary (“She collected the crates that afternoon”) would do the same work.
The second version is identical up to the officer’s reply. Then the book shows thirty crates, not forty, and the signature is her father’s. Now something resists, there is a line where the scene turns, and the ending is different: she has most of her cargo and a question about her father.
That is the meaning of rewrite as a decision. No sentence was polished. What happens was changed.
The exception
When to break it
The conflict question is the easiest of the three to overuse. Applied by rote it puts a quarrel in every scene, and the book starts to bicker. Resistance can be a locked door, the weather, a silence. A scene of two people being kind to each other passes if one of them is finding it hard.
Beyond the three questions
Scenes of aftermath run on different fuel. After a disaster, a character may do nothing but take in what happened and decide what to do next. Test that kind of scene on its decision, not on outer conflict.
Some scenes are kept for what they give the reader directly: a comic set piece, or an hour in good company in a book that promises such hours. Keep them knowingly, and watch how many sit side by side.
And these three questions look at one scene at a time. Four scenes in a row can each pass and still wear the reader out, because every one of them is a confrontation. Rhythm across scenes is a structure question, and your reverse outline is the place to see it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which job is scene-level?
A writer has four jobs on her list for the chapter in which her heroine is evicted. Which one is a scene-level revision?
Key takeaway
Ask of each scene what is different by the end, what pushes back, and where the turn can be seen. Then decide: keep, rewrite, merge or cut, with a reason that names the question it passed or failed. Before anything goes, list what later pages need from it.
