Big darlings
The lesson on cutting gives the test for every size of cut and the habit of a cuts file. This lesson is about the hardest case: a darling big enough to have a shape of its own. A whole scene, a chapter, a character, a storyline, loved and not needed.
Where big darlings hide
- The first chapter writtenFrom before the book found where it starts
- The set pieceThe scene the story has outgrown
- The research chapterHard won, and only interesting to you here
- The favourite with no jobThe character you most enjoyed writing
Big darlings gather in a few places. The first chapter you wrote, from before the book found where it starts. The set piece the book was built around, which the story has since outgrown. The chapter of research you worked hard for. The minor character you most enjoyed writing, who has no job in the plot.
You can often tell a darling by the way you defend it. The reasons are about you (it was the first thing I wrote, it took a month, it really happened) and not about the reader at that point in the book. Readers’ notes give another sign: they skim it, or they stop there and do not say why.
Read the book without it
You cannot judge a darling by rereading it. It will be as good as ever, and that is the trouble. Judge it by its absence.
Judge it by its absence
- Copy the draftSo nothing is lost
- Take the darling outThe whole of it
- Read across the gapAs a reader, at reading speed
- List what is missingA fact, a setup, a first meeting, or nothing
Make a copy of the draft and take the darling out. Then read across the gap, from a chapter or two before to a chapter or two after, as a reader, at reading speed. Do not fill the hole from memory.
Write down what the reader now lacks. Usually it is short: a fact a later scene needs, a first meeting, one setup. Sometimes it is nothing. Now and then it is a great deal, because the darling is doing the book’s real work, and then it is not a darling at all, only a scene you are lucky enough to love.
Move the job, not the scene
Whatever the reader lacks goes into a scene that is staying, in the fewest words that carry it. A fact can ride in a line of dialogue. A skill can show in a gesture. A first meeting can happen in a chapter where both people are already present.
Two ways to deal with a darling
Then the darling goes out whole, into a darlings file, with its title and the date. Resist the shorter version. A chapter cut to a page, or a storyline cut to a paragraph of memory, still does nothing, and now it does nothing in summary, which is duller. The urge to keep a little of it is the darling talking.
Last, close the seam. Read the join once more, and search the draft for names and places that only the darling used.
Example
A darling, tested
A novelist tests the chapter she loves most. Here is her note.
Chapter 14, the lido. I love it. It is the best writing in the book, and it was the first thing I wrote.1
Read without it: I made a copy, took chapter 14 out, and read 12 to 16 straight through, as a reader.2
What the reader now lacks: that Maya can swim, which she needs in chapter 27, and that Sol has a brother, mentioned once in 19. Nothing else.3 The light on the water and the old men playing cards are lovely, and nothing later leans on them.
Move the jobs: Maya’s swimming goes into chapter 3, one line, in the row about the holiday.4 Sol’s brother goes into 15, where Sol is on the phone anyway.
Cut whole: the chapter goes to the darlings file, titled and dated. Not a shorter version.5 A shorter lido chapter would still be a chapter where nothing happens.
Seams: 13 now ends on the cancelled train and 15 opens on the Monday. Read across: it holds. Searched for “lido”: two mentions in 22. Both cut.6
- “It is the best writing in the book, and it was the first thing I w…”Both reasons for keeping it are about the writer. That is the sign of a darling.
- “I made a copy, took chapter 14 out, and read 12 to 16 straight thr…”She judges it by its absence, reading across the gap at reading speed.
- “Nothing else.”Two jobs, both small. Everything else in the chapter is mood that no later page depends on.
- “Maya’s swimming goes into chapter 3, one line, in the row about th…”The job moves into a scene that is staying, in the fewest words that carry it.
- “Not a shorter version.”She refuses the shrunk darling, and says why.
- “Searched for “lido”: two mentions in 22. Both cut.”The seam is closed, including the orphans later in the book.
Before and after
A chapter shrunk, or a job moved
The one faultThe cut chapter survives as a shrunk summary that stops the scene.
The carriage left Walter at the mill gate a little after six. The noise reached him before the yard did.
He had been nine when he first went into a place like this, small enough to crawl under the frames and clear the fluff. He remembered the overlooker’s strap, the cold porridge at noon, and the girl from Pike Lane who sang to keep awake and lost two fingers to a shuttle in his second winter. He remembered his mother counting his pennies on the table. He had not thought of any of it in thirty years.
The manager met him in the yard, wiping his hands. “Dr Hale. The boy’s in the counting house. We’ve not moved him.”
The writer had a whole chapter about Walter’s childhood in the mills, and loved it. Reading the book without it, she found the reader needed one thing from it: that Walter knows mill machinery, which matters when he treats the boy.
In the first version she has kept the chapter in miniature. The overlooker, the porridge, the girl from Pike Lane, his mother’s pennies: a paragraph of memory dropped between the gate and the manager, with a boy waiting to be treated. It reads well, and the scene stands still while it does.
In the second, the one job the reader needed rides in a clause, in the body of the man walking into the yard. The childhood is in the darlings file, whole. The boy in the counting house is reached three sentences sooner.
The exception
When to break it
Some darlings turn out to be the book. If reading without it leaves the ending without a reason, or removes the place where the lead changes, keep it, and look instead at what is crowding it.
In some books the digression is what the reader came for. A comic novel’s detours, a literary novel’s long look at one afternoon, a cosy mystery’s hour in the bakery: these do a job, and the job is pleasure. Keep them on purpose, and watch how many sit side by side.
And a darling cut from this book is not destroyed. Writers sometimes find that a chapter which never fitted becomes the start of the next book, or a short story of its own. That is a reason to file it carefully, not a reason to keep it here.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
What next?
A writer reads her draft without the chapter she loves most, a long scene at a horse fair. She finds the reader now lacks one thing: that the heroine can ride, which saves her life in chapter 30. Everything else in the fair chapter is missed by nobody. What should she do next?
Key takeaway
Judge a darling by reading the book without it, and list what the reader then lacks. Move that job into a scene that stays, in the fewest words that carry it. Then take the darling out whole, not shrunk, file it with its date, and close the seam.
