The words you cannot see
Every writer has habits: words and moves the hand reaches for when the mind is busy with something else. They come in three kinds.
- Filler wordsJust, really, very, suddenly, seemed to
- Stock gesturesNodding, sighing, shrugging, a deep breath
- Pet constructionsOpening with “As she…”, things in threes
Filler words add nothing to the sentence they sit in: just, really, very, suddenly, a bit, seemed to.
Stock gestures are the small actions characters fall back on: nodding, sighing, shrugging, smiling, looking, taking a deep breath.
Pet constructions are favourite sentence shapes: opening with “As she…”, describing things in threes, closing a paragraph on a short question.
None of these is wrong. One nod is a nod. The trouble is how often. By the third shrug on a page the habit is easy to notice, and a reader who has noticed it may start to count.
You cannot see your own habits by reading, because they are how your sentences come out. So look for them on purpose. Use the search box and write down the totals. Read a chapter aloud and listen for echoes. Ask a reader one question: what do my characters do too much?
Three things to do with each one
Go through the uses one at a time. There are three choices.
Three choices for each use
Delete it. Most filler words leave no hole. If the sentence means the same without the word, the word was doing nothing.
Replace it with something that belongs to this character at this moment. A synonym will not do. Changing “nodded” to “inclined his head” keeps the habit and adds strain, and now the reader notices the effort as well. Often the best replacement is nothing, because the line of dialogue was clear on its own.
Keep it, when it is doing a job. A nod can be a character’s whole answer. “Just” can mean “only”, as in “just one”. A filler word inside speech can be how that person talks.
The aim is fewer, not none.
Example
Habits in a short scene
About eighty words of first draft. “Just” appears three times and “looked” four times.
Uzoma just wanted the bag out of his hands. He looked at the man across the table, and the man looked back.
“It’s all there?” the man said.
Uzoma nodded.1 “Count it if you like.”
The man just smiled2 and unzipped the bag. He looked inside for a long moment. Then he looked up.3
“You’re short.”
“I’m not short.” Uzoma took a deep breath.4 He just needed to stay calm. “Count it again.”
The man tipped the bag out onto the table.
- “Uzoma nodded.”A gesture worth keeping. It is his answer to the question, and it is the only nod in the scene.
- “The man just smiled”A filler word. Take “just” out and the sentence is unchanged. The same is true of the other two.
- “He looked inside for a long moment. Then he looked up.”Two of the four looks, side by side. Each is harmless alone. Together they show the writer steering the camera with one verb.
- “Uzoma took a deep breath.”A stock gesture standing in for nerves. Ask what this man, with this bag, would do with his hands. That is the replacement.
Before and after
Thinned, not scrubbed
The one faultTwo habits repeat until they are noticeable: “really” four times and a shrug three times.
Zuzana found Winslow behind the bike sheds, which was really the last place she had expected.
“You didn’t come to the hearing,” she said.
He shrugged. “Didn’t think it would help.”
“It would really have helped. They asked who else was there and I had to say nobody.”
He shrugged again and picked at the paint on the railing. A flake came off, green on one side, rust on the other.
“They’ve given me two weeks,” she said. “Out of school. It’ll be on my record.”
“I’m really sorry.”
“Are you?”
He shrugged, and that was when she really understood that he had never meant to come.
The revision uses all three choices.
Three of the four “really”s were deleted, and nothing was lost. The one that stays is in Winslow’s mouth. “I’m really sorry” is how a boy his age says it, and the word makes the apology sound thinner, which suits the scene.
The first shrug stays, because it is his first answer. The second was deleted. He is already picking at the paint, and that says the same thing better. The third was replaced with something only this scene could supply: he pockets the flake of paint.
Every other word is as it was.
The exception
When to break it
Repetition you chose is a device. A refrain, a phrase that returns with a new meaning, three sentences built alike for emphasis: all are deliberate, and deliberate is the test. If you did not know the word was there, it is a habit.
Habit or device?
In a first-person voice or in dialogue, a habit can be character. A narrator who says “honestly” before every lie is a person. But give the habit to that one character. If everyone in the book says it, the habit is yours.
“Said” is not on this list. It is close to invisible on the page, and a high total is normal.
Totals need context. A word that appears two hundred times in a long novel may be fine if it is spread out. Six on one page is a cluster, and clusters are what show.
And leave this alone while you are drafting. Habits are the cost of writing fluently. The time to thin them is the sentence pass.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Five nods on one page
A search shows that a character nods five times on one page of dialogue. Which is the best way to deal with it?
Key takeaway
Your habits are invisible to you and plain to a reader, so find them with a search and a total. Then take each use in turn: delete it, replace it with something particular to the moment, or keep it because it is doing a job. Aim for fewer, and do not reach for the thesaurus.
