Lesson 2 of 18
The Mill · stone 2Foundation5 minute read

Part of: Creative Writing for Beginners, module 10 (Revising)

Reading as a reader

Gaining distance from your own draft: rest, a change of format, reading aloud.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Mill: a stone water mill with a big turning wheel on a river bend.
The Mill · Revision and self-editing, stone 2 of 18

You know too much

When you reread your own page you do not read what is there. You read what you meant. Your memory fills every gap: you know who is speaking, why she is angry, what the room looks like. A reader has only the words.

When you reread your own page you read what you meant, and these three ways work best together.

Reading as a reader means finding ways to have only the words yourself. There are three common ones, and they work best together.

Rest. Put the draft away long enough to forget your own sentences. Stephen King, in On Writing, advises a rest of some weeks at the least. For a short piece a few days can do it. The test is whether a line can surprise you.

Change the format. Print it, or send it to an e-reader or a phone, or change the font and the width of the column. The lines break in new places and the eye stops gliding over them.

Read it aloud, or have your computer read it to you. The ear catches what the eye forgives: a sentence with no room to breathe, a word used three times in a paragraph, a line of dialogue nobody could say.

Marks, not fixes

On this read you have one job, which is to notice what happens to you. Bored. Lost. Did not believe it. Wanted to skip. Laughed. Each of those is a fact about the page. Write it beside the line in a few words, or use a code: a wavy line for drifting, a question mark for confusion, a tick for anything that works.

On this read, notice what happens to you and mark it, because the moment you repair a sentence you stop being a reader.

Do not fix anything yet. There are two reasons.

The moment you start repairing a sentence you have stopped being a reader, and you will read the next page as its writer.

And a reaction is more reliable than the fix that comes to mind with it. “I drifted here” will still be true next week. “Cut this paragraph” is a guess about the cause, and the real cause may be three pages back, where the reader was not given a reason to care.

Example

What a reader’s marks look like

A draft page, read after a month away. The notes are what the writer wrote in the margin, and each one reports an experience.

The cellarhorror

Bashir had not been down to the cellar since his uncle’s funeral. The stairs were steeper than he remembered. He found the switch, and a bulb came on above the workbench.

Everything was where the old man had left it. Jars of screws sorted by length. A vice. Three handsaws on nails, largest to smallest. A radio with its back off. Tins of varnish, a tin of putty, a tin of brown boot polish with a coin for opening it.1 A calendar turned to the wrong March.

His cousin had said the freezer was at the far end, behind the boiler, and that he should not open it until he had called him2. Bashir stood in front of it for some time. Then, from inside, the handle moved.3

  1. “Tins of varnish, a tin of putty, a tin of brown boot polish with a…”Margin: “eye sliding”. By the fifth item of the list the reader in you has begun to skim. That is all the note says. Whether the list is too long, or the reader needed a reason to look closely, is a question for later.
  2. “until he had called him”Margin: “who calls whom?” You know which “he” is which. After a month away you had to stop and work it out, and a stranger would too.
  3. “Then, from inside, the handle moved.”Margin: a tick, and “sat up”. Mark what works. It tells you what the page is for, and it stops you cutting the good line by accident in a later pass.

Before and after

Two sets of notes on the same chapter

The one faultThe notes tell the writer what to do instead of recording what the reader went through.

Weaker versionNotes on chapter four (first set)

Page 31, the arrival at the wedding. Cut the paragraph about the marquee.

Page 32, where Fenella sees Leopold by the cake. Add a line about how she feels.

Page 33, their conversation. Tighten. Lose half the small talk.

Page 35, the speech. Change the best man’s joke.

Page 36, the last line. Needs to be stronger.

Showing the weaker version.

Both sets point at the same five places. The first gives orders, and every order is a guess. “Add a line about how she feels” might be right. The better answer might be in what Fenella does with her glass, or the reader might be meant to wonder. The note has closed the question before it was asked.

The second set records what happened, and that stays true whichever repair you choose. It also holds something the first set cannot: “came back when he mentioned Naples” tells you where the scene is alive.

The exception

When to break it

Rest is not always possible. With a deadline a week away, lean harder on the other two: change the format and use your voice. Reading the chapters out of order can help as well, because it stops the story carrying you past the sentences.

If you see a typing mistake, ring it, because a ring is a mark and takes a second.

Reading aloud does not suit every text. Some prose is made for the eye, such as a story told in letters, lists or footnotes, and a stumble in the voice is not a fault there. For a long novel, reading every word aloud may cost more days than you have. Read the opening, the ending and the scenes you are unsure of, and let the computer read the rest.

If you see a typing mistake, ring it. A ring is a mark and takes a second.

And there is a limit. After many drafts no amount of rest will make the book new to you. That is the point at which you need other readers.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Which is a reader’s note?

A writer is reading her own chapter on paper after three weeks away. Which of these margin notes records what happened to her as a reader?

Key takeaway

To read your own draft as a stranger would, make it unfamiliar: let it rest, change how it looks, hear it aloud. Then read it straight through and write down only what happens to you and where. Reactions are the evidence. The fixes come afterwards.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

One chapter, read as a stranger

Read one chapter of your own draft in a new format, from start to finish, and mark only your reactions. No fixing.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.