Lesson 6 of 18
The Mill · stone 6Intermediate6 minute read

Cutting

Removing scenes, characters and lines that do not serve the story.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Mill: a stone water mill with a big turning wheel on a river bend.
The Mill · Revision and self-editing, stone 6 of 18

What does this do?

Cutting is taking out what the story does not need. It applies at every size: a storyline, a character, a scene, a paragraph, a line.

A darling now is anything kept for love and not for use, and the paragraph you are proudest of is one place to look.

The test is one question, asked of each part in turn: what does this do? Try to finish the sentence “Without this, the reader would not…”. Would not know something, or feel something, or expect something. If the only honest ending is “…get to read it”, you have found a candidate.

Material that fails the test tends to gather in the same places:

the warm-up at the start of a scene, before anything is at stake;

the explanation that follows something already shown;

the second example of a point the first example made;

the history that arrives the moment a place or a person is mentioned;

the paragraph you are proudest of.

That last one has a name. “Murder your darlings” comes from Arthur Quiller-Couch, in On the Art of Writing (1916), where he was warning students against showy fine writing. The phrase has widened since. A darling now is anything kept for love and not for use.

How to cut cleanly

Keep a cuts file. Paste into it everything you take out. Nothing is destroyed, which makes it far easier to be honest, and a darling sometimes finds a home three chapters later.

Take out whole parts before you shave words, and remember the test is the question, not the percentage.

Cut whole parts before you shave words. Removing one paragraph that does nothing is better than removing a word from each of twenty sentences that were doing their job. Shaving can leave prose clipped, and the voice is often the first thing to go.

Then check the seams. Read the lines on either side of the gap. Search the rest of the draft for orphans: later mentions of something that is no longer there.

How much should go? Stephen King, in On Writing, passes on a formula he says an editor scribbled on one of his early rejection slips: the second draft is the first draft less ten per cent. It is a rule of thumb for writers who draft long, and a useful nudge. The test is still the question, not the percentage.

Example

Asking the question, paragraph by paragraph

A short scene from a novel about a failing orchard. Two parts fail the test. One part looks as if it might, and passes.

The letter from the bankliterary

The letter from the bank came on the Tuesday, and Barnaby read it standing at the kitchen window.

Letters had always been read at that window. His grandmother had read her telegrams there in the war, holding them up to the light as though the paper might say more than the words. She had kept every one in a biscuit tin with a spaniel on the lid.1

The bank would extend the loan until October. After that it would take the orchard.

He read it again to be sure. It said what it had said the first time: October, and then the bank would take the orchard.2

Outside, the pickers’ ladders were still leaning in the apple trees3 where he had left them. He counted the weeks on his fingers. Seven.4

  1. “She had kept every one in a biscuit tin with a spaniel on the lid.”A darling. The grandmother’s paragraph has the best detail on the page, and it has nothing to do with the bank, the loan or October. Without it the reader would not get to read it. Into the cuts file.
  2. “It said what it had said the first time: October, and then the ban…”A repeat. The reader took this in one paragraph ago. If his disbelief matters, “He read it again” carries it alone.
  3. “Outside, the pickers’ ladders were still leaning in the apple trees”This could pass for scenery, but it has a job. There is a crop still on the trees, and that crop is what the weeks are for. It stays.
  4. “Seven.”What the scene is for: a deadline. Each surviving line should help the reader arrive here.

Before and after

The same scene, one paragraph lighter

The one faultA paragraph of history interrupts the scene and gives it nothing it uses.

Weaker versionThe envoy (first version)

The envoy’s horse had gone lame at the border, so Tatiana walked the last mile to the keep and arrived with the hem of her coat stiff with mud.

The steward met her under the gate. “The duke is at table.”

“Then I will speak to him at table.”

The keep had been built by the duke’s great-grandfather, who quarried the stone from the hill it stood on, so that the hill grew smaller as the walls grew taller, and the masons joked that one day the keep would stand in a pit. He died before the roof was on. His widow finished it in half the time and for a third of the money, and was not thanked.

“He does not hear petitions at table,” the steward said.

“It is not a petition.” She took the folded treaty from inside her coat and held it where he could see the seal. “It is a date. He has until the new moon. I would not let his soup go cold over it, but I have been told to watch him read.”

Showing the weaker version.

The only difference is the fourth paragraph of the first version: the great-grandfather, the shrinking hill, the widow who was not thanked.

It may be the best paragraph of the six. But look where it falls. Tatiana has just said she will speak to the duke at table, and the steward is about to answer. The reader is made to wait through three generations of masonry for that answer, and nothing in the scene depends on who built the keep.

In the second version the steward answers at once and the exchange keeps its edge. The widow is in the cuts file. If the book ever needs a reason for the duke’s family to resent its women, she is ready.

The exception

When to break it

Not every draft is too long. Some writers draft lean: scenes sketched in summary, reactions missing, rooms with no furniture. For them revision mostly means adding, and cutting a tenth of a thin draft only makes it thinner.

“What does this do?” has more than one good answer, so be honest about how often you reach for that defence.

“What does this do?” has more than one good answer. After a hard scene, a slower passage gives the reader room to recover, and that is a job. In a comic novel the digressions may be the main thing on offer. A line that only sounds like the narrator can be earning its place by making the reader want that voice in their ear for three hundred pages. Be honest, though, about how often you reach for that defence.

Length also depends on the kind of book. A long fantasy can carry more setting than a short thriller.

And leave cutting alone while you are drafting. You do not yet know what the story needs, and the paragraph that looks idle in chapter two may turn out to be holding up chapter thirty.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

A reason to keep it

A writer is deciding whether a paragraph in chapter six stays in the book. Which of these is the soundest reason to keep it?

Key takeaway

Ask of every part: what does this do for the reader that nothing else here does? Take out what has no answer, starting with whole paragraphs and not single words. Paste the cuts into a file, then check the joins and search for anything left pointing at what is gone.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Your favourite paragraph the story does not need

Open a cuts file, find one darling in a chapter of your draft, cut it, and check the seams.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.