Four sizes of problem
A finished draft has problems of four sizes, and it helps to know which size you are looking at.
Largest size first
- StructureThe whole book
- ScenesDoes each one earn its place?
- SentencesClear, and sounding right
- ErrorsMistakes with a right answer
Structure is the whole book: where the story starts and ends, the order of events, whose story it is, which characters and storylines belong.
Scenes are the units the book is built from. Does each one earn its place? Does something change in it?
Sentences are the words on the page: whether they are clear, whether they sound right, whether there are too many.
Errors are mistakes with a right answer: spelling, punctuation, a missing word, a name spelt two ways.
Revision goes most smoothly when you work from the largest size down to the smallest. The reason is practical. If you spend an evening perfecting the sentences of a scene, and next month decide the book does not need that scene, the evening is gone. Worse, a polished page is harder to throw away than a rough one, so polish applied too early can talk you out of a change the book needs.
Professional editing is usually described in the same order, with a name for each stage: a developmental edit for structure and scenes, a line edit for sentences, a copy edit and then a proofread for errors.
One pass, one question
A pass is one trip through the draft looking for one kind of problem. On the structure pass you ask: is this the right story, in the right order? On the scene pass: does this scene change anything? On the sentence pass: is this clear, and does it sound like me? On the error pass: is this correct?
A small thing, seen in a big pass
Keeping to one question matters because attention is narrow. A mind that is hunting for commas is not in a good position to notice that chapter nine repeats chapter four.
You will see small things during a big pass. Mark them and keep going. A cross in the margin costs a second and keeps you reading. Stopping to rebuild a sentence takes you out of the pass you are in.
Example
One page, four sizes
A page of first draft from a novel set in a gold-rush town. Each note says which pass the problem belongs to.
It had taken Bronagh most of the morning to get to the assay office1, first by the ore cart as far as the junction, then on foot along the creek road, which was mud to the ankle after the rain. The office was a tin-roofed building with a scale in the window.
The clerk was a thin man who was in the process of eating his lunch2. “Claim number?” he said.
“Forty-one. Registered to Alasdair Shea.” She put the the3 pouch on the counter. “I want to know what this is worth, and I want it written down.”
He weighed the dust twice. Then he looked at her over his glasses, wrote a figure, and turned the paper round. It was less than half of what Alasdair had told her in his letters.4
- “It had taken Bronagh most of the morning to get to the assay office”A scene-sized question. The scene opens with the journey, and it might be stronger opening at the counter. That is for the scene pass.
- “who was in the process of eating his lunch”A sentence-sized problem: “who was eating his lunch” says the same in fewer words. Leave it for the sentence pass.
- “the the”An error, and the most tempting thing on the page to fix at once. Mark it. If the scene pass removes this paragraph, the mistake goes with it.
- “It was less than half of what Alasdair had told her in his letters.”A structure-sized question. This is the discovery the chapter turns on. Does it come at the right point in the book? Does the reader know it already? Settle that first, because every line above depends on the answer.
Before and after
The cost of polishing first
The one faultThe sentences were polished before the scene was tested, so the best writing sits in a paragraph the scene does not need.
The shuttle from the ring took forty minutes, and Ravindra spent them watching the station grow from a bright grain to a wheel to a wall. He counted the docking lights as they came up, amber over amber, and thought of harbour buoys he had only seen in films. At the lock a steward checked his pass against a list and waved him into a corridor that smelled of new carpet.
“You’re the replacement.” The quartermaster did not look up from her screen.
“I’m the auditor,” Ravindra said.
“We asked for a pump engineer.” Now she looked up. “Three months we’ve been asking. And they send us a man to count the pumps.”
“I can count how many are broken. That goes in a report people read.”
She considered him. Then she pushed a tablet across the desk, its screen cracked from corner to corner. “Start with that one. It’s the list of what we’ve stopped reporting.”
The two versions are word for word the same from the quartermaster’s first line onwards. The only difference is the opening paragraph.
The writer of the first version polished before asking what the scene was for. The shuttle ride has had real care: the grain, the wheel, the wall, amber over amber. But the business of this scene starts when the quartermaster speaks, and nothing in the ride changes anything. That writer now has to cut the best paragraph on the page, or keep it because it is the best paragraph on the page.
The writer of the second version asked the scene question first, started at the desk, and never spent an evening on the docking lights.
The exception
When to break it
The order is a way of saving effort, not a law, and there are good reasons to step outside it.
Stepping outside the order
If a mistake will confuse your own big pass, fix it now. A character whose name changed halfway through the draft is worth a search-and-replace before you read for structure.
Some writers revise yesterday’s pages before writing today’s and end up with clean first drafts. If that is how you work, keep working that way. The big questions still need asking at the end, and you may have to cut pages you have already polished.
Sometimes the sentences are the structural problem. If you are not sure the narrator’s voice works, rewriting one chapter line by line may be the fastest way to find out what kind of book this is.
And a short story can often take two sizes at once. The order earns its keep on long work, where a wasted pass costs weeks.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
What comes first?
A writer has just finished the first draft of a novel. All four of these jobs need doing. Which should be done first?
Key takeaway
Revise from the largest problem to the smallest: structure, then scenes, then sentences, then errors. Give each pass one question. When you see a small fault during a big pass, mark it and keep reading, because the page it sits on may not survive.
