Three things in every note
A reader’s note is usually a mixture of three things, and they are worth different amounts.
- A reaction“I got lost.” Evidence
- A prescription“Cut the brother.” A guess at a cure
- A preference“I do not enjoy present tense.”
A reaction says what happened to the reader. “I got lost.” “I cried.” “I put it down for a week.” This is evidence. A reader cannot be wrong about their own experience.
A prescription says what the reader thinks you should do. “Cut the brother.” “Start with the fire.” This is a guess at a cure, made by someone who has been through the book once and may not know what you are trying to do. Neil Gaiman made the point in a list of rules for writers that The Guardian published in 2010. Roughly: when people tell you something is not working for them, they are right far more often than not, and when they tell you exactly how to fix it, they are wrong far more often than not.
A preference says what the reader likes in books generally. “I do not enjoy present tense.” It is true, and it is about them.
The first job is to separate the three. Then take each prescription and work backwards. What did this reader feel, and where, that made them reach for this cure? “Add a second ghost” may mean “by the halfway point I wanted something new to happen”. That second sentence is the note.
Patterns first, then purpose
Do not act on notes one at a time as they arrive. Collect them all. Then group them by the place and the problem they point at, whatever words they use.
Patterns first, then purpose
- Write the aim downBefore you open any feedback
- Group the notesBy the place and the problem
- Decide for each groupAct, look into it, or set aside
Three readers who offer three different cures for chapters nine to twelve have given you one note three times, and it outranks anything said once. Cures that contradict each other count as agreement too. If one reader finds a chapter too slow and another finds it rushed, they agree about where the trouble is.
Next, test each group against what the book is for. Write that aim down in a sentence or two before you open any feedback. Each group then gets one of three decisions.
Act: several readers, and the symptom matters to the aim.
Look into it: one reader, but the note strikes at the aim, or it nags at you.
Set aside: a preference, or a cure for a different book.
The aim cuts both ways. It lets you decline “make it a thriller”. It also obliges you to take seriously a single reader who says the central effect did not work.
Pay attention to the note you most want to dismiss. Strong resistance is information. Ask what the note would be pointing at if it were right.
Example
One letter, taken apart
A first reader writes to the author of a fantasy novel. Each note says which of the three kinds the sentence is.
Dear Radhika,
I read the first twelve chapters over the weekend. I loved Kwabena from the moment he lies to the toll clerk1, and I read the river crossing twice because I did not want it to end.
I got lost in the council chapter.2 There were so many names that I stopped trying to tell the lords apart, and by the vote I did not know who was on whose side.
I think you should cut the council down to three lords.3 You could also put a family tree at the front.
I confess I have not liked a prologue yet, in any book4, and I skipped yours.
One last thing. When the queen pardons him in chapter eleven, I did not believe it.5 She had no reason to that I could see.
Yours, Oren
- “I loved Kwabena from the moment he lies to the toll clerk”A reaction, with a place. Praise is evidence too. It tells Radhika what to protect when she starts changing things.
- “I got lost in the council chapter.”A reaction, and the most useful sentence in the letter. The next sentence says where he was lost and why.
- “I think you should cut the council down to three lords.”A prescription. It is one cure for the confusion. Others: introduce the lords earlier, give each a different want, seat them by faction. Keep the symptom and hold the cure loosely.
- “I confess I have not liked a prologue yet, in any book”A preference, and he says so himself. It tells her about Oren. If three other readers also skip the prologue, that will be a pattern, and worth a different kind of attention.
- “I did not believe it.”A reaction with its cause attached: he could see no reason for the pardon. He does not say what to do. He says what is missing, which is more use.
Before and after
The same three notes, used two ways
The one faultEach prescription is carried out as an order, and nobody asks what the three have in common.
Three readers. Their notes on the hospital chapters, and what I will do.
Njeri says to cut the second hospital visit. I will cut it.
Peregrine says the father should die earlier. I will move his death to chapter eight.
Folasade says to add a scene with the sister. I will write one.
The writer of the first list is being conscientious. Every note gets a response. But look at what the three changes would do together. A visit is cut, a death is moved forward and a new scene is added, all in the same four chapters, each for a separate reason. The chapters will be different. Nothing says they will be better.
The second list notices that three cures aimed at one place are one symptom. It names the symptom: nothing changes in those chapters. Then it declines all three cures for the moment and goes to look.
The second writer may still end up cutting the visit. If so, it will be because the cut answers the problem, and not because Njeri said to.
The exception
When to break it
Patterns outrank one-offs, with exceptions.
When one note is enough
A matter of fact needs no pattern. If one reader who is a nurse tells you a drip does not work that way, one is enough.
A single reader can be right against five. This is likeliest when the one is the kind of reader the book is for and the five are not. A note from outside your genre is strong evidence about clarity and weak evidence about convention.
An editor you are working with is in a different position from one beta reader among several. Their prescriptions come from experience of many books, and deserve more weight. It is still fair to ask what they felt, and where.
Sometimes a real pattern asks for a different book, and you decline it with open eyes. Then check that your opening is promising the book you mean to write, because several readers expected another.
And do not go looking for more readers in the hope of outvoting a pattern you dislike.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Three notes, one message
Three readers have commented on the same novel. The first: “Cut the prologue.” The second: “Why not start with chapter two?” The third: “I did not really get into it until the storm in chapter two.” What do the three notes tell the writer?
Key takeaway
Take every note apart: the reaction is evidence, the prescription is a guess, the preference is about the reader. Group the reactions by where they point, deal first with the places several readers stumbled, and decide each one against what your book is for.
