Lesson 8 of 18
The Mill · stone 8Intermediate5 minute read

Continuity

Keeping facts, timeline and character details consistent.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Mill: a stone water mill with a big turning wheel on a river bend.
The Mill · Revision and self-editing, stone 8 of 18

What drifts

Continuity means the story agreeing with itself. A reader told on page ten that the captain has lost two fingers from his left hand will notice on page three hundred if they are missing from his right. It is a small thing. But each slip reminds the reader that the book was made, and after two or three a reader may stop trusting the details.

Each slip reminds the reader that the book was made, so the full check comes late, once the scenes stop moving.

The facts that drift fall into a few groups.

Names and spellings: of people, places, ships, streets.

Time: dates, days of the week, ages, seasons, how long a journey or a pregnancy takes.

Bodies and objects: eye colour, scars, which hand; and things that are lost, broken or given away and then turn up again.

Who knows what: a character acting on news she has not yet been given.

Place: which side of the hall the study is on, how far it is to the station.

A common cause is revision itself. You move a scene, and the Monday it mentions is now a Thursday. You cut a scene, and the introduction it contained goes with it. For that reason the full check comes late, once structure and scenes have stopped moving, and again after any large change.

Write each fact down once

Memory is the wrong tool for this job. You remember deciding that her eyes were grey. You also remember the earlier draft in which they were brown.

Keep a story bible, one line for each fact with the place it is first stated, because memory is the wrong tool.

So keep a record. Copy editors call theirs a style sheet, and novelists often call it a story bible. It needs one line for each fact, with the place where the fact is first stated. Useful sections are: each character (age at the start, appearance, what they own, how they speak), a timeline with a date or a day for every scene, places, and spellings.

When the text and the record disagree, or the text disagrees with itself, take three steps.

Choose which version is true. Ask which one the plot leans on, and which costs less to change.

Change every mention. Use search, and search for the old detail afterwards to be sure none is left.

Then look for knock-on effects. What else was true only because of the old version? If the ship is not due tomorrow after all, the line in which someone looks forward to tomorrow has to change too.

Example

Reading for facts

Two paragraphs from early in a novel set on a merchant ship. Each note is a line for the record.

The captain comes aboardhistorical

Captain Havilland came aboard at Porto on the ninth of June1, a tall man of fifty with a Devon accent and the two smallest fingers missing from his left hand2. He brought one sea chest, a caged finch3, and a wife nobody had been told about.

Mrs Havilland was perhaps half his age. She had grey eyes4, and she spoke Portuguese to the steward and English to no one. The first mate, Mwangi, gave up his cabin to them and slung a hammock in the chart room5.

  1. “on the ninth of June”Timeline: Porto, 9 June. Every later “three weeks out” or “by midsummer” will be counted from here.
  2. “the two smallest fingers missing from his left hand”Body: left hand, two fingers. This is the sort of detail that has moved to the other hand by chapter twenty.
  3. “a caged finch”Object, and a living one. If the finch is mentioned here it has to be somewhere later: singing, dead, or given away. It cannot simply stop existing.
  4. “She had grey eyes”Body: Mrs Havilland, grey eyes. And one line up, an age: about half of fifty.
  5. “slung a hammock in the chart room”Place: from now on Mwangi sleeps in the chart room. A later scene that finds him asleep in his cabin is an error, unless the Havillands have left the ship.

Before and after

One object, two places

The one faultAn object is in two places: the umbrella is left by the door, then hooked over a chair in the office.

Weaker versionThe will (first version)

Isolde left her umbrella in the stand by the door and followed the solicitor down the hall. His office smelled of pipe smoke and wet dog.

“Your aunt’s will is quite short,” he said. He unlocked a drawer, took out a single sheet and laid it on the blotter. “She left the house to the church and the contents to you.”

“The contents.”

“Furniture. Books. A quantity of jam.” He turned the sheet towards her. “And one item listed separately. A key, with no lock named.”

Isolde read the line twice. She hooked her umbrella over the arm of the chair and asked whether her aunt had kept a safe deposit box.

Showing the weaker version.

The two versions differ in two words. In the first, Isolde leaves her umbrella in the stand in the opening sentence and has it in her hand in the last. Nothing in between brings it down the hall.

Slips are often made this way. The opening line was probably added in a later draft to give her something to do at the door, and the closing line, written months before, was left as it was.

The fix chose the opening as the true version and gave her hands something else to do. It could have gone the other way: she keeps the umbrella with her, and the first sentence changes. Either is fine. Having both is not.

The exception

When to break it

Some inconsistency is deliberate. Two witnesses remember the night differently. A narrator shades the truth. A liar forgets what he said last time. All of that is craft, but the reader needs a sign that it is meant: another character notices, or the clashes form a pattern. Without the sign it will be read as a slip.

The fewer facts you fix, the fewer can drift, and it is enough to note each fact as the draft states it.

You can also choose to state less. “In her thirties” cannot be contradicted the way “thirty-four” can. A fable or a dreamlike story may give almost no hard facts, and so have very few to keep straight. The fewer you fix, the fewer can drift.

In fantasy and science fiction the rules of the world count as facts. If the spell needed moonlight in chapter two, it needs moonlight in chapter thirty, or a reason.

And do not let the record become a way of not writing. A long story bible built before the first draft can be a pleasure and a delay. It is enough to note each fact as the draft states it.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Do the sum

In chapter three, set in the spring of 1911, Wanjiru is twenty-nine. Chapter fourteen is set at Christmas 1914. How old can she be in chapter fourteen?

Key takeaway

Names, dates, bodies, objects and who knows what all have to agree from the first page to the last, and memory will not keep them straight. Write each fact down once with where it was stated. When two versions clash, choose one, change every mention, and follow the knock-on effects.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

One character against the record

Choose one character who appears throughout your draft. Write down every hard fact the text states about them, with where it is stated, and resolve each clash you find.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.