The Lantern: an iron lantern on a hilltop at dusk, with paths from every direction leading up to it.

Writing Lessons and Exercises · The Lantern

Theme: lessons and exercises

What the story is about beneath its events, and how to carry that without a sermon.

  • 6 lessons
  • about 31 minutes of reading
  • 30 exercises
  • 10 warm-ups

The path · 6 lessons

Six stones to the Lantern

  • Foundation 1
  • Intermediate 4
  • Advanced 1
  1. Foundation

    Lesson 1: Theme as a question

    The human question the story explores, phrased so it can be argued both ways.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  2. Intermediate

    Lesson 2: Thematic argument through character

    Giving characters different answers to the theme question, and letting them argue it through what they do.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  3. Intermediate

    Lesson 3: Theme through outcome

    What an ending claims through the main character’s final choice, what it costs and where it leaves them.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  4. Intermediate

    Lesson 4: Motif and symbol

    Images or objects that keep returning in a story and gather meaning as they change.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

  5. Intermediate

    Lesson 5: Avoiding the sermon

    Letting an action carry a story’s meaning instead of having a character or the narrator state it.

    6 min read · 5 exercises

  6. Advanced

    Lesson 6: Variations and counterpoint

    Subplots and minor characters that test the theme from other angles.

    5 min read · 5 exercises

What you’ll practise

By the last stone

Each lesson is short and ends in exercises. By the last stone you will have practised all of these.

The lessons draw on Egri, McKee and Truby.

  • Foundation · 1 lesson
    • Theme as a question
  • Intermediate · 4 lessons
    • Thematic argument through character
    • Theme through outcome
    • Motif and symbol
    • Avoiding the sermon
  • Advanced · 1 lesson
    • Variations and counterpoint

How you’ll practise

Ten kinds of exercise in this craft

  • Multiple choice6 exercises

    A novel asks: should you stay loyal to a place that is dying? Which cast gives that question a real argument?

  • Spot it2 exercises

    A father lets his teenage son hold the rope for him on a climbing wall for the first time. The scene shows what it means well enough, and twice it also says so. Select the two paragraphs that state the scene’s meaning.

  • Compare two versions3 exercises

    A man is selling a car with a hidden fault. The two versions differ in one paragraph, and he does the same thing at the end of both. In which version does the scene put a real question to him? Choose the version, then the reasons that hold.

  • Sort4 exercises

    Nine endings, each from a different story. Sort them by what happens at the point of decision. Does the main character choose and pay for it? Choose, and lose nothing by it? Or never have to choose at all?

  • Label the passage3 exercises

    A patrol has caught an enemy herald. The three soldiers each have a different answer to the question of what a captured enemy is owed. Six actions are marked. Label each with the answer it argues.

  • Rewrite2 exercises

    This scene explains itself twice: once in the ferryman’s last speech, and once in Taro’s thoughts on the far bank. Rewrite it so that neither of them states the meaning, and something Taro does shows that he has taken it in. Keep the opening as far as “both crossings”. You may add a person or an object on the far bank.

  • Write a scene3 exercises

    Write one complete scene that puts a theme to work without ever stating it.

  • Write under a rule2 exercises

    Write three short moments from one story. A coat appears in each of them. By the third, it should mean something it did not mean in the first, and you may not say what.

  • Apply to your book6 exercises

    Read the ending of your own story as a stranger would, and write down what it claims.

  • Warm-up10 exercises

    Write two or three sentences in which a character states a firm belief out loud while doing something that contradicts it. Do not comment on the gap.

Bring it together · about 45 min

The thing that cannot be halved

Write one complete scene that puts a theme to work without ever stating it.

Free with an account

Write the scene, read it beside a model answer and check it against the lessons you have done.