Lesson 1 of 6
The Lantern · stone 1Foundation5 minute read

Part of: Creative Writing for Beginners, module 2 (Finding your story)

Theme as a question

The human question the story explores, phrased so it can be argued both ways.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Lantern: an iron lantern on a hilltop at dusk, with paths from every direction leading up to it.
The Lantern · Theme, stone 1 of 6

A topic is not yet a theme

Many writers, asked what lies underneath their plot, answer with one word: love, grief, justice. That word is a topic. It says where the story is standing. It does not say what the story is asking.

A theme question is still open when the plot question has been answered, and still open when the reader shuts the book.

A theme is easier to work with when you phrase it as a question, and a particular kind of question: one about how people should act or what something is worth, which two sensible people could answer differently. “Loyalty” is a topic. “Do you owe more to the stranger at your door or to the people behind you?” is a theme question. You can argue it, and so can your characters.

It helps to keep two other things apart from it. A plot question is settled by events: will she reach the border, who took the money. A lesson is an answer the writer already holds: kindness is its own reward. A theme question is neither. It is still open when the plot question has been answered, and it is still open when the reader shuts the book.

Where the question lives on the page

A theme question does not appear in the story as a sentence. It appears as a choice. A character stands between two things that both matter, and whatever they do next is an answer.

A theme question appears in a story as a choice between two things that both matter.

That gives you a test you can run on any theme question. Name one thing a character could do in a scene that would answer it yes, and one thing that would answer it no. If you can picture both, and each would cost the character something, the question is alive. If the second action is hard to picture, or nobody decent would do it, you have a lesson with a question mark on the end.

Example

A question in a pen stroke

A miller’s daughter keeps the tally for the estate that owns the valley. Read it for the two things pulling at her, and notice that neither is ever named.

Eleven sackshistorical

Prue Fairbank set the widow’s sacks on the beam scale one at a time. Eleven.

The estate took one sack in every ten, or part of ten. Ten sacks owed one. Eleven owed two.1

The brass weights had her father’s mark filed into the base of each.2 Thirty years the valley had trusted that mark. A farmer might curse the miller’s prices, but nobody had ever asked to see a sack weighed twice.

The widow stood by the door with the smallest child on her hip. She did not ask for anything.3 She looked at the eleventh sack and then at the floor.

Prue dipped the pen. The steward read the tally book every quarter day, and he was a careful man4.

She wrote 10 and blotted it.5 Then she carried the eleventh sack out to the widow’s cart herself, before the ink was dry.

  1. “Ten sacks owed one. Eleven owed two.”The honest answer has a price, and the price is given in sacks. The reader can do the sum.
  2. “The brass weights had her father’s mark filed into the base of each.”One side of the question, as an object. Honest measure is the family’s name, and thirty years of trust rest on it.
  3. “She did not ask for anything.”The other side. The widow makes no speech about need, so the pull comes from the child on her hip and where she looks.
  4. “he was a careful man”The merciful answer has a price too. Now both choices cost something, and that is what makes it a question.
  5. “She wrote 10 and blotted it.”Her answer, given as an act. The narrator does not say whether she was right. A reader could put the question as: is a kindness still right when it takes a lie to do it?

The explainer

Give the rule its reason

The moor gate at dusk, and the first version of the scene, one sentence at a time. Only two sentences need changing. Press them to swap in their rewrites, and each clue lights up as the rule gains a reason and Jaya’s choice gains a second side.

Dusk at a barred moor gate: a gatekeeper with a lantern; a man, a woman and a girl with a goat outside; mist rolling over the moor.

Changes left

3 of 3

Words

106 (was 106)

Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.

Before and after

One side, then two

The one faultThe rule she breaks has no reason behind it, so her choice has only one side.

Weaker versionThe moor gate (first version)

The dusk bell had rung, and by the charter of Greyfen the moor gate stayed barred from that bell until sunrise.

Three figures stood on the far side of the bars: a man, a woman, and a girl holding a goat by a rope. Mist was already filling the ditch behind them.

“We lost the road,” the man said. “Please.”

Jaya had kept the gate four winters. The charter gave no reason for the rule, and no warden she knew of had ever been able to supply one. It was simply what was done.

The goat pulled towards the gate and bleated.

Jaya lifted the bar.

Showing the weaker version.

Only the fourth paragraph differs. In the first version the charter gives no reason for the barred gate, so lifting the bar costs Jaya nothing. Any reader would lift it. The scene has a lesson in it (be kind to travellers) and no question.

In the second version the rule protects people. A warden once opened the gate to the wrong visitor, and a street emptied. Mercy to three strangers might now be paid for by everyone asleep behind her. Do you owe more to the stranger at the gate or to the people at your back? That can be argued both ways, and when Jaya lifts the bar she has given an answer the rest of the story will have to test.

The exception

When to break it

You do not need the question before you start. Some writers find it in the second draft, by noticing what their characters keep having to choose between. Writing it down too early can make a first draft stiff.

Treat the question as a working tool that may change as you revise, and keep it out of the story itself.

Some kinds of story begin from an answer on purpose. A fable is built to deliver its moral, and a satire often knows what it is against. A light adventure or a comedy may carry its theme loosely and be none the worse for it.

A long book can hold more than one question, and the one you write down may change as you revise. Treat the sentence as a working tool for you. It does not belong in the story itself.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Which one is a theme question?

A writer is planning a novel about two brothers after a family quarrel. Which of these notes is a theme question?

Key takeaway

Turn your topic into a question that two sensible people could answer differently. Then find the moment where a character has to choose between the two answers and pay for the one they pick. If both choices cost something, the story has a theme at work in it.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Find your own question

Write your story’s theme as a question with two opposed answers, then find one moment in your draft or outline where a character acts on each answer.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.