Ask the question more than once
A main plot tests the book’s question once, on one person, under one set of conditions. However well it is done, that is a single case. Subplots and minor characters let you run the question again with something altered: a different person, different stakes, a different answer, a different result.
Around Elizabeth and Darcy
- Charlotte LucasAccepts Mr Collins for security and not for love
- LydiaRuns off with Wickham, who will not marry her until paid
- Mr BennetHis affection for his wife wore off early
The terms come from music. A variation is the same tune changed. Counterpoint is a second line that moves against the first. In a novel, the tune is the theme question, and each variation is somebody else’s attempt at it.
Pride and Prejudice is often read this way. Around Elizabeth and Darcy, the novel sets other marriages. Charlotte Lucas accepts Mr Collins for security and not for love. Lydia runs off with Wickham, who has no intention of marrying her until he is paid. Mr Bennet’s affection for his own wife wore off early. Each is a different answer to what a marriage should rest on, and the reader weighs the main couple against all of them.
Variation or echo
The test of a variation is its outcome. If a subplot makes the same choice as the main plot and gets the same result with different people, it is an echo. The book says its piece twice, and the reader feels the repetition as slackness even when each scene is good.
Test it by the outcome
A variation changes the answer or the price. Someone chooses the other way and it goes badly. Someone gives the main character’s answer and pays far more for it, or far less. Someone refuses to choose. The most valuable kind is also the riskiest: someone chooses the other way and it works. That admits evidence against your own ending. It makes the book’s claim narrower and more honest, true for these people in this case, and it is what stops a novel reading as a demonstration.
The costs are practical. Each variation takes pages from the main line, and a vivid one can outshine it. A cast in which every member stands for a position starts to look like a chart. One scene, or one paragraph about a minor character’s past, is often enough. Placing it before the climax means the main character, and the reader, have seen what the other answers cost.
Example
A variation in one scene
From a novel in which Kirsi, the first of her village to win a place at the city academy, must decide whether to go. The book asks whether you owe your gifts to the place that raised you. This is the postmistress’s only scene.
The letter from the academy had come by the Tuesday cart, and Mrs Conrad held it a moment longer than she needed to1 before she passed it under the grille.
“Good paper,” she said.
Behind her, above the pigeonholes, ran a shelf Kirsi had never looked at properly. Railway guides, eleven of them2, their spines faded to the colour of tea.
“You went, didn’t you? My aunt said. To the capital.”
“Two years. I kept the accounts for a firm that shipped pianos.3” Mrs Conrad stamped a parcel, hard. “Then my father died, and there was the office, and nobody else who could read the tariff book4.”
“Do you mind?”
The postmistress considered this as she would have considered a query about postage. “I have the new guide sent every January,” she said. “I look up the trains.5” She pushed the ledger across. “Sign for it. Top line.”
- “held it a moment longer than she needed to”Before she speaks, the minor character has a relation to the main character’s question. The letter means something to her.
- “Railway guides, eleven of them”Her answer and its result, as objects on a shelf. The count gives the years without a sentence of backstory.
- “Two years. I kept the accounts for a firm that shipped pianos.”She is not a copy of Kirsi. She went, which Kirsi has not yet done, and then came back. The same question, with a different history.
- “nobody else who could read the tariff book”The same pull Kirsi feels: the place needed her particular skill. Here it won.
- “I look up the trains.”The outcome, and it is neither a warning nor a blessing. She stayed, the office runs, and every January she checks the times. Kirsi and the reader are left to weigh it.
Before and after
The brother’s subplot, twice
The one faultThe subplot reaches the main plot’s answer by the same route, so it repeats the argument.
Viggo had been carrying the spare key in his jacket for three weeks. He had it in his fist now, on the towpath, with Pia a step ahead of him talking about her landlord.
He nearly let her finish. He nearly put the key back.
“Pia. I want you to move in. I’ve wanted it since March, and I was too proud to ask in case you laughed.”
She stopped walking. “I’ve had a bag half packed since April,” she said. “I was waiting for you to say it.”
They stood grinning at each other while a cyclist rang his bell and went round them.
Both versions come from a romance whose main couple are too proud to say what they want, and who are happy once they do. The subplot belongs to the heroine’s brother, Viggo.
In the first version Viggo has the same fault as the leads and gets the same cure. He has been silent out of pride, he speaks, and he is rewarded. It is a pleasant scene, and it tells the reader nothing the main plot will not tell them again.
In the second version Viggo has no trouble speaking. He has asked every week since March. The scene tests the book’s claim from the far side and finds its limit: saying what you want is not enough if you do not hear the answer. Pia closes his hand over the key. When the main couple finally speak, the reader will be watching for whether they also listen.
The exception
When to break it
A deliberate echo has its uses. A parent’s story repeated in a child’s, with the same choice and the same result, can be the whole design of a family saga, where the claim is that the pattern holds. The repetition there is the point, and it works best when it is marked so that the reader sees it.
When an echo is right
Short novels, novellas and tightly plotted thrillers may have no room for a second line. One clear test of the question beats three thin ones.
A subplot can earn its place in other ways. Comic relief, a romance that gives the reader somewhere to rest, or a line that exists to deliver a plot turn need not touch the theme at all.
And in a series, variations can be spread across books, with a minor character’s answer in one volume becoming a main plot in the next.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Variation, or something else?
In a novel’s main plot a soldier deserts to save her brother, and gets him out at the cost of her name. The book asks whether loyalty to family outranks duty. Which subplot is a variation on that question?
Key takeaway
Use your subplots and minor characters to put the book’s question to other people. Make sure each one differs from the main plot in the answer given or in what it costs, and let at least one different answer work. A claim that has met its counter-evidence is one a reader can believe.
