An ending is a claim
A story can spend three hundred pages asking its question fairly. The ending answers it. Whoever is left standing, and in what condition, is read by the reader as the book’s verdict, whether or not the writer meant one.
“The Necklace”, read as a claim
Years of a life are thrown away1 when pride will not let someone admit a loss2.
- The resultThe state things end in
- The causeWhat brought it about
Screenwriting teaching has a name for that verdict, the controlling idea, usually credited to Robert McKee’s book Story. It is commonly summarised as one sentence in two parts: the state things end in, and what caused it. Lajos Egri’s The Art of Dramatic Writing is often summarised as asking for something similar under the name premise, a statement the play sets out to prove.
Try it on Maupassant’s story “The Necklace”. A woman borrows a diamond necklace for a ball, loses it, and says nothing. She and her husband replace it and spend ten years in poverty paying off the debt. Then she learns the original was imitation. One fair reading of what that ending claims: years of a life are thrown away (the result) when pride will not let someone admit a loss (the cause). You may word it differently. The point is that the ending supports a sentence of that shape.
Read your ending for three things
To find the claim your own ending makes, look for three things in the last chapters.
Choice, cost, state
- The choiceWhat the character finally does about the question
- The costWhat it takes from them, in particulars
- The state it leavesWhat they have, and what they are, on the last page
The choice: what the main character finally does about the question. The cost: what that choice takes from them, in particulars. The state it leaves: what they have, and what they are, on the last page.
The cost is a common place for drafts to go wrong. A character tells the truth, or shows mercy, or walks away from the money, and the story is so pleased with them that it hands everything back within a page. The intended claim was “honesty is worth what it costs”. The claim on the page is “honesty is free”, which is hard to believe and answers a question nobody was asking.
The second common fault is an outcome the character did not choose. If a storm, a rescuer or a confession from someone else settles the matter, the ending says only that things sometimes work out.
Example
An ending that pays
The last scene of a quiet novel about a potter and the man who wants her to leave with him. Look for the choice, the cost and the state she is left in.
The night train south was called at ten past six. Rashid had both tickets in his coat, as he had said he would, and he held one out without making anything of it.
Dunja looked at it. Second class, window. He had remembered the window.1
Behind her, across the river, the kiln would need lighting by eight if Thursday’s order was to be glazed at all. Her mother could no longer lift the shelves. There was nobody else who knew the firing.2
“They have clay in the south,” he said.
“They have.”
She took the ticket, because he had paid for it, and put it in his breast pocket and buttoned the pocket3. Then she kissed him, for long enough that the guard looked away4.
She watched the train out as far as the signal. It was twenty to seven. She walked back over the bridge fast, to be in time for the kiln.5
- “He had remembered the window.”The cost is made particular before the choice. He is a man who remembers which seat she likes, and that is what she is about to give up.
- “There was nobody else who knew the firing.”The other pull, given as work and not as a principle: a kiln, an order due on Thursday, a mother who cannot lift the shelves.
- “put it in his breast pocket and buttoned the pocket”The choice, as an action. Buttoning the pocket makes it final without a word of explanation.
- “for long enough that the guard looked away”The story does not shrink the cost to make the choice look easy. She loves him, and she is still not going.
- “She walked back over the bridge fast, to be in time for the kiln.”The state it leaves: alone, and with something to do. A reader might put the claim as: a working life of your own is worth keeping, even at the price of someone you love. Nobody in the scene says so.
Before and after
The same choice, free and paid for
The one faultThe right choice is rewarded at once, so it costs nothing and the ending proves nothing.
Olwen held the river’s name in her mouth one last time. With it she could keep the flood wall standing by a word, as her teacher had, and his teacher before him. The river had not chosen that.
She spoke the name backwards, the way a name is given back.
The water in the millrace shivered and went still. Then it rose in a smooth brown shoulder against the wall, leaned there, and did not come over. It would hold the wall of its own will now, the river told her, in the voice of a weir, for as long as she lived.
Olwen went home through the dry streets of Saltby and slept until noon.
A young witch inherits the power to bind a river, and the book has asked whether a power is worth keeping when it was taken from something that never agreed to give it. In both versions she gives the name back. Only what follows is different.
In the first version the grateful river holds the wall anyway. She loses nothing and neither does the town. The ending now says that doing right costs nothing, and the book’s question, whether a power is worth keeping when it was taken without consent, goes unanswered, because no price was ever charged.
In the second version the wall leaks, the town is out with shovels, and it will be every spring. The claim is one a reader can argue with: what was taken should be given back, even when everyone has to pay. The neighbours who refuse to thank her are arguing with it already.
The exception
When to break it
The price need not be heavy. Comedy, romance and cosy mysteries promise a happy ending, and a cost in those can be swallowed pride, a public embarrassment or a plan given up. It only has to be real to the character.
Other ways to make the claim
A tragedy makes its claim the other way round. The main character chooses badly, and the wreckage is the argument.
An open ending can be the honest one when the question is too hard to settle. It works best when the character has still chosen and only the result is left hanging. An ending where nobody decides anything is a different thing.
An ironic ending sets the outcome against what the character believes they have won. There the claim lies in the gap, and it is the reader who sees it.
In a series, one book’s ending may answer a smaller question and leave the large one for later.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
What does the necklace claim?
In Maupassant’s story “The Necklace”, Mathilde borrows a diamond necklace from a wealthy friend, loses it, and hides the loss. She and her husband replace it and spend ten years in poverty paying the debt. Then the friend tells her the original was imitation. Which sentence gives a claim that ending could be making, in the shape the lesson asks for: a result and its cause?
Key takeaway
Write your ending’s claim as one sentence: how things end up, and why. Check that the “why” is something your main character chose, and that the choice cost them something the reader cares about. If the sentence is not what you meant to say, change the ending or change your mind.
