Let the cast do the arguing
Once a story has a theme question, somebody has to argue it. The narrator is a poor candidate. Better ones are already in the book: the characters.
A stance is what they would do
The method is simple to state. Give two or more of your main characters different answers to the question, and let each one act on theirs. One book often summarised as teaching this is John Truby’s The Anatomy of Story, where each character is treated as a different approach to the same moral problem. You do not need his system to use the idea. When two people who believe different things want the same ledger, the same boat or the same child, their scene is an argument, and nobody in it has to mention the subject.
A stance is not an opinion a character announces. It is what they would do. Two characters who talk differently but would make the same decision hold the same stance.
Give the other side its best case
A common fault is a rigged argument. The character who answers the question the “wrong” way does so out of greed, vanity or stupidity, gets no good lines, and is not once seen to be right about anything. The reader notices the thumb on the scale, and the ending proves nothing because nothing was allowed to oppose it.
A thumb on the scale
An opposing answer earns its place when it is held for a reason the reader can feel, by someone competent, and when it has worked at least once. A reason lands hardest as a fact or an object in the scene: a name, a folder, a grave.
There is a real trade-off here. The stronger you make the opposition, the less safe your own answer looks. That is the price of an ending that means something. The opposite risk is neatness: if every member of the cast is a walking position, the book starts to feel like a diagram. Two or three stances are usually plenty, and each should come out of a life.
Example
Two answers and one ledger
Two village police officers have found that the church treasurer borrowed from the roof fund and has been quietly paying it back. Watch what each of them does with their hands.
The ledger lay open between them on the vestry table. Hamid had found the gap in March’s column inside ten minutes. Finding the rest had taken him the afternoon: eleven small sums paid back in since1, each in the treasurer’s own hand, each entered as a gift from nobody.
“He’s four payments short of square,” Hamid said. “By harvest it’s all back and no one is hurt.2”
Sergeant Kaplan was filling in the top of a charge sheet.3 She wrote the way she did everything, without hurry.
“You know what a charge will do to him. Forty years he’s kept those books.”
“I know what one did to the Radley boy, for a crate of eggs4,” she said. “Nobody suggested waiting till harvest for him.”
Hamid closed the ledger. He kept his hand flat on the cover.5
She held out her own hand for it, and went on holding it out.
- “eleven small sums paid back in since”Hamid’s answer rests on evidence the reader can count. The man is already mending what he did.
- “By harvest it’s all back and no one is hurt.”He puts his stance as a practical plan. He does not say “mercy”, and he does not need to.
- “Sergeant Kaplan was filling in the top of a charge sheet.”Her answer arrives as an action before she has said a word about it.
- “I know what one did to the Radley boy, for a crate of eggs”Her best case. If the law waits for a man people like, it should have waited for a boy they did not. This is not a cold or foolish reason.
- “He kept his hand flat on the cover.”The argument has become physical. Whoever ends up holding the ledger has won this round, and the question is still open.
Before and after
Agreement, then argument
The one faultBoth characters hold the same answer, so nothing is argued.
The mass readout sat at the edge of the red. Neha ran the burn figures a third time and got the same answer: the hold could go home full, or the casket could go home, and not both.
“We told his mother,” she said. “I stood in her kitchen and told her.”
Felipe pulled himself down into the other seat. “Then we bring him. I’ll start the dump sequence on the ore.”
“All of it?”
“All of it. We gave our word.” He was already keying the hold doors.
Neha watched the first canisters tumble away aft, bright for a moment and then not.
A salvage crew promised a dead shipmate’s mother that they would bring him home. The ship cannot carry both his casket and the cargo.
In the first version Felipe agrees with Neha at once. The scene is tidy and the ore tumbling away is a good image, but the question of what a promise is worth never gets asked, because nobody is on the other side of it.
The second version changes from Felipe’s first line onwards. He now holds the opposite answer, and for a reason that is hard to wave away: the cargo is what the mother will live on. He wants to break the promise for the sake of the person it was made to. His hand over the key is his stance. The scene ends undecided, because now there is something to decide.
The exception
When to break it
A story told closely through one mind, with few other people in it, cannot spread its argument across a cast. A survival story or a novel of one person’s grief often puts the two answers inside the same character, who acts on one in the morning and the other at night.
Where the cast cannot argue
Satire and farce use strawmen on purpose. A pompous official who is wrong about everything can be the whole joke, and giving him a moving reason would spoil it.
An opponent who is plainly a monster can be right for horror and for some thrillers, where the theme question is being argued among the people trying to stop him and he is closer to weather than to a debater.
And not everyone in the book needs a stance. A character can be there to carry the plot, to be funny, or to be loved.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which cast can argue it?
A novel asks: should you stay loyal to a place that is dying? Which cast gives that question a real argument?
Key takeaway
Give at least two characters different answers to your theme question, and show each answer as something done. Then check the side you disagree with. If its holder has a reason you can feel and has been right at least once, your ending will have something real to overcome.
