The line that explains the scene
A sermon line is the point where a story stops and tells the reader what it means. A character says the theme aloud as settled wisdom, or the narrator sums the scene up in a general statement. It can be one sentence. It is often the last one.
Told, or done
The trouble is not that the line is false. It is often true, and often the writer’s favourite. The trouble is what it does to the reader. By the time the line arrives, a reader who has been paying attention has reached the meaning already, and being told it turns something they found into something they were taught. A stated claim also invites an argument with the author. An action only invites a feeling about the character.
So the working method is to let something done carry the meaning: a choice, a gesture with an object, a job finished or handed on.
Where they hide, and how to test one
In a finished draft, sermon lines collect in a few places. Look at the last line of each scene and chapter. Look at any speech by an older or wiser character, especially one that begins with a memory. Look at the paragraph after a climax where the main character works out what it all meant. And look at any sentence that would still make sense printed on a poster.
Cut the line, read the scene again
The test is to cut the line and read the scene again. Three things can happen. The scene still says it, in which case the line was a caption and can stay out. The scene says it faintly, in which case one action needs sharpening. Or the scene says nothing at all without the line, and then the problem is the scene. No sentence of explanation can stand in for an event that did not happen.
When you replace a line, choose something the character does that only makes sense if the meaning is true for them. A smile, a nod or a tear seldom qualifies. Those are reactions.
Example
A scene that declines to explain
On a ship that will take generations to arrive, an old woman tends trees meant for timber. A boy gives her every chance to make a speech.
The oaks in Bay Nine were for beams, once there was ground to build on. The schedule put the felling ninety years off. Josefina was seventy-one.1
She worked down the row with the knife, taking off the side shoots so that the trunks would run straight. The boy who had been sent to help her held the bucket and got bored.
“You won’t see them cut,” he said.2
“No.”3
“Then why are you doing the labels so neat?”
She finished the one she was on. It said BAY 9, ROW 4, and under that the date and her initials. She tied it at the height a grown hand would reach.4
“Hold the next one steady,” she said. “No, lower. You’ll be showing somebody this.5”
He held it lower.
- “Josefina was seventy-one.”Two numbers are put side by side and the subtraction is left to the reader. That small piece of work is where the feeling starts.
- ““You won’t see them cut,” he said.”The boy puts the scene’s question in his own blunt way. A question can be said aloud. It is the answer that needs to be shown.
- ““No.””The place where a speech about future generations would go. She declines it in one word.
- “She tied it at the height a grown hand would reach.”Her answer, as an action. She is working for a person who does not exist yet, and she has thought about how tall they will be.
- “You’ll be showing somebody this.”The nearest the scene comes to stating anything, and it is an instruction about a job. It also hands the work to him.
Before and after
With the speech, and without
The one faultThe teacher states what the scene has just shown.
Mr Kirby stood in the schoolroom door with his cap in his hands and said that Hedy would not be coming after Friday. There was a place for her at the mill. He was sorry for it.
Miss Moreau asked him to wait. She went to the cupboard and came back with a folded bundle.
“These are the papers the mill gives you with your pay. Hedy brought them in for the arithmetic class. I asked each child to bring some real sums.” She opened the bundle on the front desk. Down every margin, in a child’s round figures, the week had been added again.
She put her finger beside the fourth week, and the ninth, and the twelfth, where the child’s total and the mill’s did not agree.
“You see what her schooling is worth, Mr Kirby. A girl who can reckon cannot be cheated, and nor can her father. That is what a school is for.”
He looked at the papers for a long time. Then he asked whether he might borrow them until Monday.
The two versions are the same until the fifth paragraph. In the first, Miss Moreau points to three weeks where a child’s arithmetic has caught the mill out, and then tells the father what this proves. Her speech also changes the scene from a man discovering something into a man being instructed by his daughter’s teacher, with his cap in his hands.
In the second version she takes her hand away and goes back to her desk. The three weeks are left on the paper. Mr Kirby reaches the conclusion himself, and his request to borrow the papers shows that he has. A reader could say what the scene is about, the worth of a girl’s schooling to the people who would end it, and nobody in the room has said it.
The exception
When to break it
A character may state a belief when the story does not simply agree. If the speaker is wrong, or is answered by someone else, or does the opposite a moment later, the line is part of the argument and not its summary.
When a stated belief belongs
A theme can be voiced early as an open question or a claim to be tested. The Save the Cat beat sheet, a widely used planning method, includes such a moment near the start, called Theme Stated, usually spoken to the main character by someone else. That is a different thing from a verdict delivered at the end.
Fables, parables and many picture books state the moral because the form calls for it.
Some voices are built for reflection. A first-person narrator looking back, or an essayistic one, is expected to think aloud.
And some characters preach because that is who they are. A sermon from a preacher is characterisation.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which last line trusts the reader?
A story about a son who resented his late father’s shop ends on the day he reopens it. Which closing line lets an action carry the meaning?
Key takeaway
Find the sentence that tells the reader what your scene means, and cut it. If the scene still says it, leave the line out. If it does not, give a character something to do that only makes sense if the meaning is true, and let the reader be the one to put it into words.
