Things that come back
A motif is anything a story returns to: an object, an image, a sound, a phrase, a colour. A symbol is a thing that has come to stand for more than itself. The two overlap, and many symbols in fiction begin as motifs. Something keeps turning up, and by the third time it means more than it did.
One object, three stages
- IntroducedA plain thing with a plain use
- GathersPresent when something that matters happens
- TurnsBack in a new state, in different hands
The meaning is not something the writer assigns. It builds up from what happens near the object. A useful way to think of it is in three stages. First the thing is introduced, as a plain thing with a plain use. Then it gathers: it is present when something that matters happens, and some of that event sticks to it. Then it turns: it comes back in a new state, in different hands or put to a different use, and the reader feels the distance between then and now.
This is how theme reaches a reader without argument. No one explains anything. A cup, a key or a coat simply carries the story’s question from one scene to another.
Choosing and handling one
The motifs that work hardest are often things the characters would be handling anyway. A tool, a garment, a piece of furniture or a daily habit can come back as often as you like, because people need it. A raven on the fence can only sit there and be significant.
Three kinds of return
A motif that repeats without changing is a reminder. The reader gets the same message each time and learns to skim it. What changes need not be the object. It can be who holds it, where it is kept, what it is used for, or that it is missing.
How often is a judgement. With fewer than about three appearances a reader may not connect them. With one in every chapter the reader starts to feel nudged. In a novel, one or two motifs carried all the way through can do more than six that each appear twice.
You do not have to plan them. In revision, look for what you have already repeated by accident, and decide which of those repetitions deserves a third appearance and a turn.
Example
One object, three moments
Three moments from a novel about a daughter and her father, with years between them. Follow the atlas.
Her father kept a road atlas in the door pocket of the van1, though the van had a screen that talked. Before any journey he would open the atlas across the steering wheel and draw the route in pencil2, even to places he had driven to a hundred times.
On the morning of her driving test the atlas was already open on the passenger seat. He had pencilled the four streets from the house to the test centre. Frida moved it to the back without looking at him.3 “I know where it is, Dad.”
The van came to her in March, with the rest of his things. In June the screen died on a ring road outside a town she did not know, in rain, and she pulled into a bus bay and took the atlas out of the door pocket because there was nothing else4.
It fell open at her own city. There was a pencil line on the page that she had never seen: from his house to her door, every turn5, and a small cross where the parking was.
- “kept a road atlas in the door pocket of the van”Introduced as a habit and a thing with a job. Nothing about it asks to be read as important.
- “draw the route in pencil”The detail that will matter later, set down lightly among others.
- “Frida moved it to the back without looking at him.”It gathers. The atlas is now his fussing, something she pushes away on a day when she wants to be trusted.
- “because there was nothing else”The third appearance arrives through need. She is lost in the rain with a dead screen, so the object still has its ordinary job.
- “from his house to her door, every turn”It turns. The same pencil habit that annoyed her is now evidence that he had been working out the way to her. The narrator says nothing about what she feels.
Before and after
Repeating, and changing
The one faultThe cup comes back three times in the same state, doing the same thing.
The first morning, Fatima served his coffee in a blue cup with a chip in the rim. Cyrus turned the chip away from his mouth and drank.
By October he was in most mornings. The blue cup with the chip in the rim was on his table again, and he turned the chip away from his mouth and drank.
The week after the argument about the lease he came in on the Friday. She brought the coffee over herself. It was the blue cup with the chip in the rim. He turned the chip away from his mouth, and he drank.
Three mornings in a café, from a love story. In the first version the chipped cup appears each time exactly as before. The repetition has a rhythm, but the reader learns nothing from the second and third appearances that the first did not give. The quarrel in the last paragraph leaves the cup untouched.
In the second version something happens to the cup at each return. It starts as an accident, the only clean one. Then it is kept apart on a hook of its own, which tells us how Fatima feels without a word from her. Then the hook is empty, and a perfect white cup arrives in the hands of someone else. The reader measures the quarrel by the cup, and the cup never has to be called a symbol of anything.
The exception
When to break it
An unchanging refrain can be the right choice when the point is that the thing stays the same while everything round it alters: a clock that goes on striking through a family’s collapse, or a phrase a narrator clings to. There the change is in the listener.
When a motif may stay still
Fairy tales, fables and picture books often use fixed emblems whose meaning is agreed in advance, and nobody is confused by a wolf.
A narrator who reads meaning into objects can be a matter of character. A first-person voice that says “I decided the dead tree was an omen” is telling us about the speaker, and the story is free to prove them wrong.
Short stories may only have room for two appearances. And some books need no motif at all. An object forced into a draft to be meaningful tends to read as exactly that.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which plan makes the gate a motif?
A novel about two brothers and a failing farm mentions, on its third page, that the yard gate hangs crooked. The writer wants the gate to gather meaning. Which plan does that best?
Key takeaway
Pick an ordinary object your characters already use. Let it be present when something matters, then bring it back changed: in other hands, in another state, or gone. Describe it as an object every time, and leave the reader to feel what it has come to mean.
