Lesson 2 of 8
The Crossing · stone 2Foundation5 minute read

Part of: Creative Writing for Beginners, module 4 (Trouble and shape)

Stakes

What will be lost if the protagonist fails, and why we care.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Crossing: a narrow causeway with the tide coming in on both sides and one figure hurrying across.
The Crossing · Conflict and stakes, stone 2 of 8

If they fail, then what?

Stakes are what a character stands to lose if they fail. Every story asks its reader to care whether someone succeeds, and the stakes are the reason to care. You can find them by finishing one sentence: “If she fails, then…”

A reader can fear only for a loss they can picture, and concrete is not the same as large.

The first thing to ask of your answer is whether a reader could picture it. “Everything”, “her whole future” and “the fate of the kingdom” are hard to picture, so they are hard to fear for. A shop with her name over the door, a custody hearing on the ninth, a brother’s right hand: those can be pictured.

Notice that concrete is not the same as large. A city under threat can matter less to a reader than one dog, if the reader has met the dog.

Why this person cannot walk away

The second thing to ask is why the loss matters to this character and not just to anyone. Donald Maass, in Writing the Breakout Novel, separates public stakes from personal stakes. Public stakes are what the world of the story stands to lose: the town, the crew, the case. Personal stakes are what this one person stands to lose, and they are the reason she cannot hand the problem to somebody else.

Personal stakes, in Donald Maass’s phrase, tie the loss to something particular in this one character’s life.

The same loss weighs differently on different people. Losing a job is bad. It is worse for the man who persuaded his father to guarantee the mortgage last month. To make stakes personal, tie the loss to something particular in the character’s life: a promise, a debt, a history, one other person.

Timing matters as well. Stakes work on a reader only while the outcome is open, so the reader needs to know them before the attempt, not after it.

Example

Counting what is behind the door

A plant breeder on a space station, outside a deck that has just been sealed. Look for what would be lost, and for why it is hers to lose.

Deck Ninescience fiction

Deck Nine lost pressure at 0400, and by 0410 the bulkhead doors had done what they were built to do.

Rafaela Duarte stood at the sealed hatch with her palm on the cold plate. Behind it were eleven hundred seed trays and the only tomato line that had ever set fruit under the station’s lamps1. Nine years of crosses. Her mother had started the line with six seeds carried up in a film canister.2 Rafaela still had the canister. She kept pencils in it.

“Command says forty minutes before they vent the deck,”3 said Yoav. “To save the ring.”

“Then I’ve got forty minutes.”

“You’ve got a suit rated for twenty.”

She was already unclipping it from the wall. If the trays went, the station would eat paste for two years and survive4. She would be the one who went on living there, with a film canister full of pencils.

  1. “eleven hundred seed trays and the only tomato line that had ever s…”Concrete. We are given a number and a particular plant, so we can picture what is behind the hatch.
  2. “Her mother had started the line with six seeds carried up in a fil…”Personal. Anyone on the station would miss the tomatoes. Only Rafaela would be losing her mother’s work.
  3. ““Command says forty minutes before they vent the deck,””The stakes arrive with a deadline, and before she acts. From here on the reader knows what failure would cost.
  4. “the station would eat paste for two years and survive”The public stakes are modest: nobody will starve. The scene does not need them to be bigger, because the personal ones are doing the work.

Before and after

What she stands to lose

The one faultThe stakes are stated in general terms: “a great deal”, “very serious”, “what would become of her”.

Weaker versionThe gown (first version)

Leopoldine reached the Arnault house at ten past nine with the gown over both arms, wrapped in a bedsheet to keep off the soot.

The footman looked at the clock in the hall before he looked at her. “Madame said eight.”

“The beading took longer than I allowed.”

“Madame said eight,” he said again, and left her standing on the tiles.

She waited. A great deal depended on this gown. If Madame Arnault refused it, the consequences for Leopoldine would be very serious indeed, and she did not like to think what would become of her.

Upstairs a door opened. She heard the tissue being lifted, and then nothing at all for the time it takes to count the beads on one cuff.

Showing the weaker version.

Only one paragraph differs. In the first version we are told that the stakes are high, three times over, and we still could not say what Leopoldine will lose if the gown is refused. The narrator is asking us to worry without giving us anything to worry about.

The second version names it. There is a debt of forty livres, a day it falls due, and the thing that will be taken: her sewing table and her shears, which are how she earns her living. Then one sentence makes the table hers and nobody else’s. She cut her first sleeve on it, standing on a box.

The silence upstairs is word for word the same in both versions. It is only tense in the second, because now we know what is riding on it.

Follow the rule by default. Break it only when breaking it does a job.

The exception

When to break it

Stakes do not have to be large, and they do not have to be spelled out in a sentence that begins with “If”. In a quiet novel the stake may be whether two people speak honestly over one dinner. A reader who knows them will feel that without being told, and a paragraph explaining it would be heavy-handed.

Some stories hold the stakes back on purpose. A mystery may hide the reason a character is so afraid of a locked room, and the hiding is part of the pull. That works when the reader can tell that something specific is at risk, even without knowing what it is. It stops working when the reader starts to suspect that the writer does not know either.

At the opening of a book, small and clear tends to serve better than vast and vague. The world can be in danger later on, once we care about somebody who lives in it.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Concrete and personal

Which of these gives stakes that are both concrete (we can picture the loss) and personal (it matters to this character in particular)?

Key takeaway

Stakes answer the question “if they fail, then what?” A strong answer names a loss the reader can picture and ties it to this particular character. Give the reader that answer while the outcome is still open, so that they have a reason to be anxious about how it turns out.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

If she fails, then…

For the opening chapter of your manuscript, finish the sentence “If she fails, then…” (or he, or they) for whatever your protagonist is trying to do in that chapter. Then test your answer for whether it is concrete, whether it is personal, and whether the reader learns it in time.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.