Bigger is not the measure
Escalation means that each new obstacle asks more of the character than the one before. It is easy to hear that as “make each event bigger”, and to reach for a larger fire or a faster chase. Size is a poor measure. A second explosion is the first explosion again.
Bigger is not the measure
Two questions measure it better. What did getting past this obstacle cost that the last one did not? And which way out no longer exists?
The usual fault is a run of obstacles that are all one size. Three locked doors, each opened with ten minutes’ work, are a single obstacle told three times. By the third, the reader has learned that doors open, and stops worrying. Robert McKee’s name for the stretch of story where obstacles build is progressive complications, and the first word is the one that matters.
Three directions, and one condition
There are three directions a sequence can escalate in, and the strongest sequences use more than one.
Three directions, and one condition
- WidenThe trouble reaches more people
- DeepenFrom time and money to a friendship or a principle
- NarrowAllies, tools, hiding places and hours taken away
- The costs stay paidA secret told, a name written down, a door that locks
It can widen: the trouble reaches more people. It can deepen: the cost moves from things that are cheap to give up, such as time, effort and money, towards things that are dear, such as a friendship, a principle or the character’s idea of who they are. It can narrow: allies, tools, hiding places and hours are taken away until only the hard choice is left.
Whichever direction you choose, the costs have to stay paid. If the money spent in chapter nine is back in the purse in chapter ten, the reader learns that losses in this book are temporary. The steps that land hardest are the ones that cannot be undone: a secret told, a name written down, a door that locks behind.
Example
Three nights, four steps
A mother and son in a house where something has started knocking. Track what each night costs her, and what she can no longer do afterwards.
The knocking began in the cellar on the first night, three slow blows and a pause. Zdenka Adamczyk bolted the cellar door and went back to bed. That cost her nothing.1
On the second night it was in the pipes. It travelled up through the kitchen and rang in the bath taps, and it did not stop until she went out in her nightdress and shut off the water at the main2. In the morning they cleaned their teeth with lemonade.
On the third night it came from inside the wall behind her son’s bed3. Three blows, a pause. Milosz slept through it with his mouth open. She carried him down to the car with the duvet still round him, locked the doors, and sat watching the dark house through the windscreen. They could not go back in.4 She understood that quite calmly.
She had the key in the ignition when it knocked, three times, from under the back seat5.
- “That cost her nothing.”The first step is cheap on purpose. It sets the starting price, so that we can feel the price rise.
- “shut off the water at the main”The second step costs a comfort, and the cost lasts: they are still without water in the morning.
- “from inside the wall behind her son’s bed”This deepens it. The knocking has moved from the cellar to the pipes to the thing she values most.
- “They could not go back in.”This narrows it. The house was her last place of safety, and it has gone. One option is left: the car.
- “from under the back seat”The last way out closes. Each step was a different kind of loss, and none of them has been given back.
Before and after
Three coins, or three kinds of cost
The one faultThe three obstacles are the same size: each costs a coin and nothing more.
There were three gates between Teodoro and the citadel, and the letter had to be in the regent’s hand by dawn.
At the first gate the sentry wanted a coin. Teodoro paid it.
At the second gate the sentry wanted a coin as well, and a look inside the satchel. Teodoro paid, opened the satchel, and was waved on.
At the third gate the sentry wanted a coin and took his time about counting it. Teodoro paid that too.
He came into the upper court with the sky still dark and the letter dry against his chest, three coins the poorer.
The first version has an urgent errand and three barriers, and it is flat. Each gate asks for a coin and gets one. The small variations (a look in the satchel, a slow count) change the texture and not the price. You could shuffle the gates and nothing would need rewriting, which is a reliable sign that a sequence is not escalating.
In the second version the first gate is unchanged. The second takes his horse: a thing he loves, and also his speed and his way home. The third takes his anonymity, and that cannot be bought back. He will be in danger tomorrow for what he signed tonight.
The costs go from money to a possession to his safety, and each stays paid. Nothing about the gates got bigger.
The exception
When to break it
A story that tightens on every page wears its reader out. Long books need steps down as well as steps up: a small win, a night’s sleep, a joke. Those are not failures of escalation, provided the next climb starts from somewhere higher than the last one did.
Nor does every sequence want a rising line. Comedy often runs on the same obstacle three times, with the third twisted, and the sameness is the joke. Episodic forms, including many detective series, reset the cost with each case and escalate something slower underneath: a marriage, a reputation, a debt to a superior.
The costliest step is also not bound to come last. Some books put their worst loss in the middle and spend the second half on what it takes to live with it. And if you raise the price too fast, you can run out of things to take before the climax, and be left repeating the top note. Spending the character’s losses in the right order is part of the craft.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Not just more minutes
A mother has to get her feverish child to a doctor tonight. Her car will not start, and she loses ten minutes borrowing a neighbour’s. Which next obstacle would cost her something new, and not only more time?
Key takeaway
Measure escalation by cost and by options, not by size. For each obstacle, ask what it took from the character that the last one did not, and which way out it closed. Move from costs that are cheap to costs that are dear, and keep every loss in force.
