Lesson 4 of 8
The Crossing · stone 4Intermediate6 minute read

Opposition with a point of view

Forces of antagonism that are as strong as, or stronger than, the lead.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Crossing: a narrow causeway with the tide coming in on both sides and one figure hurrying across.
The Crossing · Conflict and stakes, stone 4 of 8

An obstacle and an opponent

An obstacle is in the way. An opponent wants something. That is the whole difference, and it changes how a scene reads. A character can get round an obstacle by effort or cleverness, and once it is passed it stays passed. An opponent watches what the character does and answers it.

A protagonist can be only as interesting as the forces against them, and those need not be villains.

Opposition that holds a reader has two properties. It is strong: at least a match for the lead in power, skill, knowledge or simply in being right. And it has a point of view: reasons that make sense from where it stands. Robert McKee calls the underlying idea the principle of antagonism. In paraphrase, a protagonist can be only as interesting as the forces against them make them.

This is not only about villains. The opposition in a scene may be a loving parent, a careful boss, or the friend who happens to be right.

Giving the other side its case

Four working methods, none of them complicated.

If a fair-minded reader could take the other side for a paragraph, the outcome is in doubt.

Write the argument from the opponent’s side first, and give them the best line in the scene. Give them one thing that is true and that the lead cannot deny. Give them means: something in this room that the lead cannot simply overrule, such as authority, a signature, a skill, or a past favour. Then let them win a round, so that the lead has to change tack.

The test is whether a fair-minded reader could take the other side for the length of a paragraph. If so, the outcome is in doubt, and the reader has a reason to keep going.

A warning for anyone revising a draft: the opponent’s case tends to be weakest in the scenes the writer most wants the lead to win. Those are the scenes to check first.

Example

The quartermaster’s sum

A generation ship. The engineer wants forty sleepers woken to make a repair, and the quartermaster controls the food. Watch what he brings to the argument.

Forty pairs of handsscience fiction

“Wake forty of them,” Kalinda said. “Forty pairs of hands, and I can have the collector re-rigged in a month.”

Quartermaster Ojukwu did not look up from his tablet. “Forty people eat. I have stores for the nine of us on watch, to the gram, for eleven more years.1”

“If the collector fails we don’t have eleven years.”

“If. Your own report gives it better than even odds of holding.2”

He turned the tablet so that she could read it. It showed a column of names, each with a date beside it.

“These are the ones I’d have to leave under when the food ran short, to pay for your forty. I’ve done the sum already, Kalinda. I did it the night you filed.3 Do you want to choose them, or shall I?4”

She had come in with a wiring diagram. She found she had rolled it into a tube.5

  1. “I have stores for the nine of us on watch, to the gram, for eleven…”A fact she cannot deny. He is not being obstinate. He is counting.
  2. “Your own report gives it better than even odds of holding.”He has read her evidence and uses it against her. An opponent who knows the lead’s case is far harder to beat than one who has not listened.
  3. “I did it the night you filed.”He has thought about this longer than she has. The list of names shows that his refusal has cost him something too.
  4. “Do you want to choose them, or shall I?”He has the means to say no, since the stores are his to issue, and now he hands her the price of saying yes. She loses this round.
  5. “She found she had rolled it into a tube.”The lead gives ground, and we see it in her hands. Nothing is settled, and it is no longer clear that she ought to win.

Before and after

The man with the onions

The one faultThe person in her way has no real case and gives in at the first push.

Weaker versionThe letter from Lisbon (first version)

“Lisbon,” said Evaristo. He put down the knife. “For how long?”

“Two years. It’s the restoration post, the one I told you about.” Beatriz kept her hands flat on the letter.

“But I’d miss you.”

“You could come.”

“I don’t like the heat.” He shrugged. “And I’d have to learn Portuguese.”

“Evaristo.”

“No, you’re right. I’m being silly. You should take it.” He picked the knife up again and went back to the onions.

She looked at the letter. She had read it nine times, and it did not say what to do about him.

Showing the weaker version.

Only Evaristo’s lines differ, apart from one word in her reply. In the first version his objections are small ones (he would miss her, he dislikes heat, he would have to learn a language) and he withdraws them the moment she says his name. He is an obstacle with a face. Because he folds, her decision is easy, and the closing line about not knowing what to do about him has nothing behind it.

In the second version he has reasons she cannot wave away: an operation with a date, apprentices who depend on him, and four years he has already spent waiting for her. He also does something harder than refusing. He tells her to go, and makes sure she knows the cost.

He never raises his voice in either version. What makes him strong in the second is that he is right about something.

The exception

When to break it

Not every force against the lead needs a point of view. A blizzard has none, and survival stories do very well with one. A monster in a horror novel can be more frightening for being unreadable, and explaining its reasons may shrink it. In books like those the strength of the opposition still matters, even where its reasons do not.

Not every force needs a point of view, but a case stronger than the lead’s should change the protagonist, or make you ask whose book it is.

Understandable is also different from sympathetic. In a thriller you may want the reader to see exactly why the poisoner does it and still want her stopped on every page. Giving the opposition a case does not oblige you to make anyone fond of it.

There is a real cost at the other extreme. If the opposing case is stronger than the lead’s and the story hands the lead the win anyway, the ending will feel rigged. Either let the stronger case change your protagonist, or consider that you may be writing the other character’s book. And in broad comedy and stories for small children, a plainly wrong-headed opponent is often the right choice, because the pleasure is in the comeuppance.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Which director has a case?

A young doctor wants to try an unapproved treatment on a dying patient, and something stands in her way. In which version does the opposition have a point of view of its own?

Key takeaway

An obstacle is in the way. An opponent wants something, has reasons, and has the means to win. Give the other side its best argument, one fact the lead cannot deny, and at least one round. If a fair reader could take that side for a paragraph, the outcome is in doubt, and that doubt is what you are after.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Brief for the other side

Choose the person or group who most stands in your protagonist’s way. Write their case as they would make it, then use it to strengthen the scene in your manuscript where they are weakest.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.