A choice that costs either way
A choice between a good thing and a bad thing is not a dilemma. We know what a decent person will choose and what a villain will choose, so the choosing tells us nothing new. A dilemma is a choice where each option has a real cost and the character cannot have both.
A choice that costs either way
There are two kinds. Robert McKee, in Story, describes them as a choice of the lesser of two evils and a choice between irreconcilable goods. Shawn Coyne, in The Story Grid, gives the first a name that is easier to remember: the best bad choice. In a best bad choice, both options do harm, and the character has to decide which harm to cause. With irreconcilable goods, both options are worth having, and taking one means giving up the other. Often one is good for the character and the other is good for somebody else.
Dilemmas matter because of what they show. When both roads cost something, the one a character takes tells the reader what that person values most. No amount of description does that as well.
Three leaks
A dilemma is easy to set up and easy to spoil. It usually leaks in one of three places.
Three leaks
- A third option arrivesHelp turns up, or a loophole nobody mentioned
- One cost is not realIt falls on a stranger, or can be put right next week
- The character does not chooseEvents decide for them
A third option arrives. Help turns up, or a loophole appears that nobody mentioned before. The character is spared, and so is the reader, who had been promised something harder.
One of the costs is not real. It falls on a stranger, or it can be put right next week, or it is only described as terrible. Then one option is simply better and the choice is easy.
The character does not choose. They hesitate until events decide for them.
So the working conditions are these: put both costs in front of the reader before the choice; close the obvious ways out, in a line each; make the choice an act; and stay long enough to show what it cost.
Example
Two sluices
A lock-keeper in a flood. Follow how the passage sets out both costs, shuts the way out, and then makes him act.
By four the river was a hand’s width under the top of the lock gates, and Cornelius Drummond had the sluice key in his fist.
There were two ways to spill the water.1 The east sluice would send it across the bottom meadows, where the Corrigans had forty acres of barley standing, a week off harvest, and a note at the bank against it2. The west sluice would send it down Cooper’s Row. Eleven cottages.3 The people in them had been told to move upstairs.
He could hear the gates. Oak of that size did not creak. It hummed.
If he did nothing, he lost both, and the lock as well.4
Barley could be sown again, he told himself, and he knew what a year without a crop did to a family, because it had been done to his5. He went to the east sluice. The key was stiff. He put his weight on it6, and the water went out across Corrigan’s barley, brown and fast, laying it flat in a widening fan.
- “There were two ways to spill the water.”The choice is framed in one plain sentence. The reader knows there are two options and no more.
- “forty acres of barley standing, a week off harvest, and a note at…”The cost of the first option, in particulars: a crop, a date and a debt.
- “Eleven cottages.”The cost of the second. Two words are enough, because the number does the work.
- “If he did nothing, he lost both, and the lock as well.”The way out is closed. He cannot wait, and the passage says so before the reader can suggest it.
- “because it had been done to his”He is not allowed to think the cheaper option is free. He knows from his own family what he is about to do to another.
- “He put his weight on it”The choice is an act, and the last image is the cost being paid: the barley going flat.
The explainer
Leave the choice in her hands
The shuttle’s cockpit, and the first version of the ending, one sentence at a time. Press a sentence to swap in its rewrite. Each clue lights up as the rescue from outside goes and the choice comes back to her.

Changes left
5 of 5
Words
127 (was 127)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
The tender that comes round the nightside
The one faultA third option arrives from outside and takes the choice away.
The shuttle had fuel for one landing and one climb, and Jacinta Verhoeven had two beacons on her board.
Hadley Station: fourteen miners, air for six hours. Kepler Camp: three people, air for nine, and one of the three was her brother Joaquin, who had taught her to fly.
“Verhoeven, we need a heading,” said Control.
Fourteen was more than three. A child could do that sum. She set her hand on the stick and found that it would not turn either way.
“Verhoeven.”
“Stand by.”
Then the board chimed. A survey tender, the Pelican, was coming round the nightside, six minutes out, with fuel to spare. “We’ll take Kepler,” said its pilot. “You take Hadley.”
She let out her breath and turned the nose towards Hadley.
The two versions are identical up to “Stand by.” Both set out the costs with care: fourteen strangers with six hours of air, or three people with nine, one of them her brother. Both show her hand refusing to move.
In the first version a second ship appears with fuel to spare. Nothing earlier in the scene prepared for it. Everyone lives, and Jacinta never has to find out what she would have done. Neither do we. The reader, who was made to feel the weight of the choice, is let off, and will trust the next hard choice in this book a little less.
In the second version she checks the board again, finds nothing, and chooses. We learn something about her that description could not have told us. And the cost is not skipped: the other beacon stays lit at the edge of the board all the way down.
The exception
When to break it
Plenty of important choices in stories are not dilemmas and do not need to be. A plain choice between right and wrong can carry a scene when the question is whether the character has the nerve. That is a test of courage, and temptation stories run on it.
A third way out
A third way out is not forbidden either. Romance and adventure often end with the lead finding a path that keeps both goods, and that is part of what many of those readers came for. What separates a third way that satisfies from one that cheats is whether it has been paid for. If it uses something set up earlier, and costs the character a real loss or risk, it will feel earned. If it arrives from outside at the moment of choosing, it will read as the writer flinching.
Use the device sparingly. A book with a wrenching choice in every chapter teaches its reader to brace, and then to stop caring. A few, placed where the story turns, will do more than many.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which one is a dilemma?
Four characters face a decision. Which decision is a dilemma: a choice in which both options carry a real cost?
Key takeaway
A dilemma is a choice in which both options cost something real and the character cannot have both. Show both costs first, close the ways out, and make the character choose by doing something. What they choose shows the reader who they are.
