Tension when nothing is happening
Plot tension asks what will happen in the story. Micro-tension asks what will happen in the next few lines. The term is Donald Maass’s, from The Fire in Fiction, and his argument is that this small-scale tension comes less from events than from feelings in conflict.
Two sizes of tension
It matters most where the plot is quiet. Journeys, meals, reunions, the morning after a victory: these are the pages a reader is tempted to skim, and they are where a manuscript with a sound plot can still lose people. A chase can be slack if nothing is in doubt for the person driving. Two people drinking tea can be hard to look away from.
The working unit is small. Ask of any half page: what has not been settled here? If the answer is nothing, the page is resting, and the reader may rest too.
Four places to find it
Inside one character: two feelings at once that do not cancel out. Relief with resentment in it. Pride, and shame at being proud.
- Inside one characterRelief with resentment in it
- Between people, unspokenA talk about beans that is about something else
- Words against actionsSays one thing; the hands say another
- A detail that does not fitA third cup, a coat kept on indoors
Between people, unspoken: a disagreement neither of them will name, so that a conversation about beans is also about something else.
Between words and actions: a character says one thing while their hands say another.
In a detail that does not fit: a third cup, a coat kept on indoors. A small question, noticed and not answered.
Two cautions for experienced writers. First, the tension lasts only while it stays open. The sentence that explains the feeling, or lets the character decide it does not matter, lets the air out, so the craft lies largely in what you refuse to write. Second, micro-tension is not bickering. Characters who snipe at each other in every scene are tiring, and their friction is generic. The useful kind belongs to these two people and touches something one of them wants.
Example
Tea, and three things unsettled
A daughter visits her mother. Nobody raises their voice and nothing happens. Count the things left open.
“You’ve had the kitchen painted,” said Coralie.
“Your brother did it. Over Easter.” Her mother set down two cups, then went back to the cupboard for a third, and put it by the window where nobody was sitting1.
“It’s nice. Yellow.”
“He chose it.”
Coralie had offered at Christmas to come and paint, and been told there was no need.2 She drank some tea. It was the good tea, from the tin kept for visitors, and she could not decide whether that was a kindness or a way of telling her what she was3.
“He’s very handy,” she said.
“He’s here,” said her mother, and smiled, and passed the biscuits.4
The third cup steamed by the window. Coralie looked at it, and decided not to ask5.
- “put it by the window where nobody was sitting”A detail that does not fit. The passage does not explain the third cup here, or later.
- “Coralie had offered at Christmas to come and paint, and been told…”The unspoken disagreement. It surfaces only as a remark about the colour yellow.
- “she could not decide whether that was a kindness or a way of telli…”Two readings of one tin of tea, both held at once. She does not choose between them, and neither does the narrator.
- ““He’s here,” said her mother, and smiled, and passed the biscuits.”Words against actions. Two words carry the whole accusation, and the smile and the biscuits belong to a different conversation.
- “decided not to ask”The passage ends with the cup, the grievance and the tea all still open. Asking would have closed one of them.
Before and after
A feast with nothing left over
The one faultEverything in the scene is settled: nobody feels or wants anything that pulls against the celebration.
They gave Sabine the seat at the duke’s right hand, and a cup that had belonged to his father.
“To the Warden of the North Road,” said the duke, and the hall drank.
It was good wine. She had not tasted wine since the autumn. Down the table her sergeant, Cathal, caught her eye and raised his own cup, grinning, and she grinned back. They had held the road together for ninety days, and now it was done, and there was roast goose.
“You’ll want land,” said the duke. “I’ve a manor at Hartsfell with nobody in it.”
“Your Grace is generous.”
“I’m grateful. It’s cheaper.” He laughed, and so did she.
The musicians began again. Sabine stretched her legs under the table and thought that she would sleep that night in a bed.
The first version is cleanly written and has good details: the father’s cup, the joke about gratitude being cheaper than land. But every feeling in it is single. She is pleased, the sergeant is pleased, the duke is pleased. A reader can leave the hall at any sentence without missing anything.
The second version changes one exchange of looks and adds what lies behind it. The sergeant does not grin. On the sixty-first day he did something she is being honoured for, and only the two of them know it. Now the toast, the manor and her laugh at the duke’s joke all have a second meaning, and she cannot look down the table.
Nothing is said and nothing is resolved. We do not know whether Cathal resents her, whether she will tell the duke, or whether she will sleep. The scene is still a celebration. It has simply stopped being safe to skim.
The exception
When to break it
Constant unease is tiring, and a book that gives its reader no rest can feel airless. Stories need moments of true ease: a meal where everyone is simply glad, a joke that is only a joke. They work as relief, and they make the next disturbance register. Treat micro-tension as a default for the stretches where little is happening. It is not an order to trouble every paragraph.
Some kinds of book want less of it. Cosy fiction, comfort reads and many stories for small children trade on safety, and their readers have chosen that on purpose. Fast action can run for pages on plain outer danger.
The technique has its own way of going wrong, which is mannerism. If every character always feels two things at once, and every cup of tea hides a grievance, readers begin to see the trick. Use the conflicting feeling that is true of this person at this moment. Where you cannot find one, ask whether the passage is needed, or whether a line of summary would do.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Left open, and unsaid
A woman has just told her oldest friend, Elif, that she is engaged. Which version leaves something unresolved without anyone saying so?
Key takeaway
Micro-tension is the small unsettled thing that holds a reader in a paragraph while the plot is quiet. Look for it in mixed feelings, in what two people are not saying, in hands that contradict words, and in details that do not fit. Then leave it open, because the explanation is what ends it.
