What stands in the way?
Ask what stands between a character and what they want, and the answer usually falls into one of a handful of kinds. Writing guides call these the types of conflict. Older textbooks name them “man vs. nature” and so on; here they are character against nature, character against society, and the rest.
What stands in the way
- SomeoneAnother character, or a society and the people who enforce its rules
- SomethingNature or technology: forces that cannot be argued with
- Something beyondThe supernatural, or a fate that seems already written
- The selfA fear, a habit, or two wants pulling apart
Character against character: an opponent with a will and a plan of their own. Character against society: a law, a custom, a class or a town’s opinion, and the people who enforce it. Character against nature: weather, ground, distance, illness, an animal. Character against technology: a machine or a system, often one people built and can no longer control. Character against the supernatural: a ghost, a god, a curse, the thing in the cellar. Character against fate: a prophecy, a diagnosis, an ending that seems already written. Character against self: a fear, a habit, a belief, or two wants pulling apart.
The lesson on levels of conflict sorts trouble by how close to the character it comes; this one names what the opposing force is, because that tells you what a scene against it has to do.
What each type asks of a scene
The names are worth knowing for what they tell you to put on the page, not as a list to learn.
What four of the types ask for
An opponent needs a goal and moves of their own, so the scenes become exchanges: she acts, he answers. A society is abstract until it has a face, so give the reader a rule they understand and a person who enforces it. Nature cannot be persuaded or tricked into a change of heart, so the tension comes from measurement: hours of light, water left, miles to go. Technology frightens in proportion to how well the reader understands it, so show enough of how the system works to make its failure legible. The supernatural needs rules, partly hidden, that the character has to learn at a price. Fate changes the question from whether the end will come to what the character does on the way. And a fight with the self has to come out in choices we can watch, or it stays a description of a mood.
Layer them, and know which one drives
Few books run on one type. A survival story is mostly character against nature, but the survivors quarrel, and one of them has to master his own panic. A novel like Andy Weir’s The Martian sets one man against a planet, and much of the trouble comes through his machines.
Finding the driver
- List every conflictName each one’s type
- Take each one awayDoes the plot still run without it?
- The one it cannot loseIts outcome is what the ending settles
- Let the others pressOn the driver’s decisions, not beside them
Layering is usually a strength. What matters is knowing which conflict drives the plot. A simple test: take each conflict away in turn and ask whether the plot still runs. The one it cannot run without is the driver, and its outcome is what the ending has to settle. The others earn their place by pressing on the driver’s decisions: the quarrel makes the climb harder, and the panic makes the quarrel worse.
Naming the driver also helps with the jobs around the book. It tells you what the blurb is about, which scenes can be cut, and what the climax must decide.
Example
Three types, one arm in a housing
A technician on a failing space station. Three types of conflict are present, and one of them drives.
The station’s air system had been talking to Mirela for six hours, and in that time it had not said one untrue thing1. CARBON DIOXIDE RISING. SCRUBBER B OFFLINE. RECOMMEND REDUCED ACTIVITY. It recommended reduced activity the way a wall recommends that you stop walking.2
She had the panel off the scrubber housing and her arm in it to the shoulder when Haddad came down the ladder.
“Leave it,” he said. “The shuttle’s on its way. We evacuate at eight, and I want you on it.”
“If I leave it, there’s no station to come back to.”
“There’s no station either way. Out of the housing, Mirela. That’s an order.3”
She did not take her arm out. Somewhere behind the filter bed was the valve she had signed off as sound in March, without opening the casing, because it was late and she had wanted her dinner4. Her name was on the log. If the valve had failed, she would find it with her own fingers, here, and know.5
Her hand closed on something cold and loose.
- “it had not said one untrue thing”Character against technology, and the driver. The system is not cruel; it reports and follows its rules. Its fear comes from how plainly it works.
- “It recommended reduced activity the way a wall recommends that you…”What this type asks for: the reader understands the machine well enough to see that it cannot be bargained with.
- “Out of the housing, Mirela. That’s an order.”Character against character. Haddad has a goal of his own, and a good one: he wants her alive. An opponent with a reason is harder to push aside.
- “because it was late and she had wanted her dinner”Character against self. Her guilt is concrete: one valve, one month, one ordinary lapse.
- “If the valve had failed, she would find it with her own fingers, h…”The layers meet. The machine, the order and the guilt all press on one decision: whether she takes her arm out.
Before and after
A flood with no measure
The one faultIn the middle paragraph the flood is never measured against the two women, so it is a mood rather than an opponent.
The rain had started somewhere upstream, out of sight, an hour after Dani and Ruth dropped into the canyon. They only knew because the light changed: the strip of sky above them went from blue to the colour of a bruise.
Dani looked at the walls. They were smooth and red and very high, and there was nowhere to climb. Water would come down this channel when it came, and it would come fast, and the canyon seemed to know it.
“Run or wait?” Ruth said.
Dani picked up her pack. “Run.”
Both versions share the opening, the question and the answer. Only the middle paragraph changes. In the first, the walls are high and the water will come fast, and the canyon is even given a kind of knowing, but the reader has no way to judge whether running can work.
In the second, the same danger is measured: thirty feet of wall, a mile and a half back to the last ledge, forty minutes to the ladder, twenty for the water. That is what a conflict against nature needs. The force cannot be argued with, so the reader watches the sums, and “Run” becomes a gamble we can follow.
The exception
When to break it
The types overlap, and a story does not have to fit one box. A machine that wants something is a character. A plague is nature, and the quarantine that follows is society. If you find yourself arguing about which label applies, the labels have done their work; go back to the scene.
Ghost or mind?
- Witnesses see the door open
- Only she hears it
- The doctor finds the pills
Some stories keep the type in doubt on purpose. A great deal of horror lives in the question of whether the haunting is real or in the haunted person’s mind, and a story that settled it on page one would lose its fear. There, hold the doubt steady, and make sure the clues point both ways.
And a quiet literary novel can run almost entirely on character against self, with the outside world barely pushing back. That is a choice, not a gap.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which one drives?
A writer’s novel has three conflicts: a flood that cuts off a valley town, a feud between the two brothers who run its only shop, and the younger brother’s gambling. Her writing group asks which one drives the plot. Which question will tell her best?
Key takeaway
The seven types name what stands in the way: another character, society, nature, technology, the supernatural, fate or the self. Use them as a lens, not a list. Each type asks a scene for something different, most books layer two or three, and one of them drives the plot: the one whose outcome the ending has to settle.
