Three places trouble comes from
Conflict is whatever stands between a character and something they want. Without a want there is no conflict: a storm is only weather until someone needs to cross the bay tonight.
Three places trouble comes from
- InnerA fear, a doubt, two wants pulling apart
- PersonalA parent, a partner, a rival at work
- Wider worldA law, a war, the weather, a stranger with a knife
It helps to sort conflict by where it comes from. Robert McKee, in his book Story, describes three levels, and the idea is simple enough to use straight away.
Inner conflict is the character against themselves: a fear, a doubt, a habit, or two wants that pull in opposite directions.
Personal conflict is the character against someone they know: a parent, a partner, a friend, a rival at work. These are people whose good opinion matters to the character, which is why their opposition hurts.
Wider-world conflict is the character against something larger or less personal: a law, an employer, a war, the weather, the opinion of a whole town, a stranger with a knife. McKee’s own term for this level is extra-personal.
Join them up
A story can run on one level. An adventure where all the trouble is cliffs and pursuers can be exciting, and a quiet novel can live almost wholly inside one head. But a long story that stays on one level can start to feel thin, because people in real difficulty are seldom troubled from one direction only.
Join them up
- A floodThe wider world forces them together
- Two sisters in one atticEstranged: the personal
- Is she still angry?The inner decision
The stronger effect comes from connection. The levels are connected when trouble on one makes trouble on another worse. A flood (wider world) forces two estranged sisters into the same attic (personal), where one of them has to decide whether she is still angry (inner). Take any one of those away and the other two slacken.
Here is a quick test. Can you draw a line from each conflict to the same decision? If all three press on one choice, they are connected.
Example
Three levels in one room
A schoolteacher in a mill town, during a strike. Watch where each piece of pressure comes from.
The notice came on Monday, on the Company’s good paper. From the first of the month, the children of men absent from their looms would not be admitted to the Company school1. Miss Wilhelmina Krantz was to read it aloud at assembly and pin it by the door.
She read it twice at her desk. Forty-one of her sixty pupils had fathers on the picket.
Her brother came by at noon, as he did most days now, smelling of the brazier at the mill gate. Casimir sat on a bench made for a child of eight and looked at the paper in her hand.
“You’ll not read that out,” he said.2
“The Company owns the roof, Cas. And the slates, and the stove.”
“And you?”
She had told herself for eleven years that a teacher took no side3, that the schoolroom was the one fair place in the town. She folded the notice in half, and then, because her hands wanted something to do, in half again.4
- “the children of men absent from their looms would not be admitted…”Wider world. The order comes from the Company, on paper. There is nobody in the room she can argue with.
- ““You’ll not read that out,” he said.”Personal. Her brother is on the other side of the strike, and he is sitting in front of her. Refusing the Company would be easier than refusing him, and obeying it would be harder.
- “She had told herself for eleven years that a teacher took no side”Inner. Her idea of herself is in the way. Whatever she does with the notice, she can no longer be the person who takes no side.
- “She folded the notice in half, and then, because her hands wanted…”All three levels meet on one sheet of paper. That is what connection looks like: a single decision made hard from every direction.
Before and after
The same checkpoint, twice
The one faultAll the trouble comes from outside the character: a table, a penlight and a stranger.
The bag check had not been there that morning. Julien Roussel saw it from the stairs: a folding table across the lobby, two guards in grey, a queue of people holding their satchels open.
The copies were in the lining of his coat. Sixty pages, the whole of the March ledger.
He joined the queue. The guard at the table worked fast, a penlight in one hand, the other patting down each bag. He did not look at faces. Four people ahead. Three.
Julien took off the coat and folded it over his arm, lining inward, the way a man does in a warm lobby.
“Bag,” said the guard.
He held it open. The penlight went in and came out.
“Go on.”
The revolving door was eleven steps away. He counted them.
Both versions have the same checkpoint, the same hidden pages and the same eleven steps to the door. In the first, everything that threatens Julien is outside him. The guard is nobody to him and does not look at faces. The scene is tense, and it is all on one level.
In the second, the guard is someone who was kind to him when nobody else was, so getting through means deceiving a friend. That is a personal conflict. One added sentence tells us he has spent six years catching people who do exactly this, so he is also acting against his own idea of himself. That is an inner one.
Nothing else has changed. The checkpoint is no more dangerous than before, but passing it now costs him something whether or not he is caught.
The exception
When to break it
Three levels is a way of looking at a story. It is not a quota for every scene. A fight for a seat in a lifeboat does not need the hero to doubt himself halfway through, and stopping to supply an inner conflict there would slow the scene for nothing.
A way of looking, not a quota
Short stories often choose a single level and go deep. Some kinds of book lean one way by design: a survival story can be nearly all wider world, and a story of two people in one house can be nearly all personal. Across a whole novel, what counts is that the reader is not left for long with trouble from one direction only, and that when levels appear together they have something to do with each other.
Be wary, too, of bolting on an inner conflict that the plot does not touch. A fear of heights that is mentioned in chapter two and put to no test is decoration.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is inner?
Four characters, four kinds of trouble. Which of these is an inner conflict?
Key takeaway
Trouble can come from inside the character, from the people close to them, and from the wider world. Name one conflict at each level, then check that all of them press on the same decision. When they do, one choice becomes hard from every side.
