Look before you speed up
When a book takes longer than you hoped, the first idea is usually to find more hours: get up earlier, give up the weekend, write on holiday. Sometimes that helps for a month. It rarely changes the next book, because the time a book loses seldom goes on slow typing.
Two ways to go faster
It goes on chapters written twice. On weeks of not knowing what happens next. On an opening polished six times while the middle waited. On research that ran on, a restart at the halfway mark, a draft sitting in a drawer while you wondered whether it was any good.
So before you plan the next book, look at the last one. Not to judge it, and not to judge yourself, but to find where the weeks actually went.
Four kinds of time
Sort the last book’s weeks into four piles. A rough count is enough. Your word log, the dates on your files, your calendar and your emails will usually tell you more than memory does.
Where a book’s weeks go
- ForwardNew pages that stayed in the book
- ReworkDrafted twice, cut, or rewritten
- StallsStuck, circling, or not opening the file
- Waiting and restWith readers, chosen breaks, and life
Forward: new pages that survived into the finished book.
Rework: pages drafted twice, cut, or rewritten because something underneath them changed.
Stalls: weeks when you were stuck, or circling, or not opening the file.
Waiting and rest: time when the book was with readers or an editor, and breaks you chose. These are not losses. A planned rest belongs in the plan. Weeks given to illness, caring for someone or a house move go here too, written down plainly. They are life, not a fault in your process, and the audit should not treat them as one.
Follow the rework upstream
The useful question is not how much you rewrote but why. Big losses usually start somewhere earlier. A decision you put off, such as who the killer is or what the lead gives up at the end. A discovery that came late, like a midpoint that did not hold. A plan that never fitted your week.
From loss to change
- The lossChapters 9 to 14 drafted twice
- What started itThe culprit changed in month four
- The rootThe solution was never decided first
- The changeA page on the crime before chapter one
For each large loss, write a short chain: what was lost, what started it, and what would have caught it sooner. Often two losses share a root, and that root is worth more than the rest of the audit put together.
Then choose one to three changes for the next book, each aimed at a root you found. “Work harder” is not a change to the process. It asks the same process to run on less sleep.
Example
An audit
A mystery writer looks back at her last novel before planning the next.
Started drafting 6 January. Finished the first draft 30 September, three months later than I planned.
Forward drafting: about fourteen weeks of new pages that stayed in the book.1
Rework: about nine weeks. Chapters 9 to 14 drafted twice. The opening rewritten four times before I reached chapter 3.
Stalls: about six weeks in all, most of them in June, when I did not know how Ruth finds the ledger.
Waiting: five weeks while my two readers had the draft, which I had planned for. Two weeks off in August, also planned.2
Why chapters 9 to 14 were redrafted: in April I changed who forged the will. I had never decided it before I started.3
Why the opening went round four times: I went back to it whenever the middle was hard.
Why June stalled: the ledger had no route to Ruth. Same root as the redraft: the solution was not worked out first.4
Changes for the next book: decide the crime, the culprit and the trail of clues on one page before chapter one.5 Leave the opening alone until the draft is finished, and keep notes instead.
- “Forward drafting: about fourteen weeks of new pages that stayed in…”Forward time is counted on its own, so the losses can be seen against it.
- “Waiting: five weeks while my two readers had the draft, which I ha…”Waiting and rest are recorded, and not counted as losses.
- “Why chapters 9 to 14 were redrafted: in April I changed who forged…”The rework is traced upstream, to a decision that was never made.
- “Same root as the redraft: the solution was not worked out first.”Two losses share one root. That root is where the next book’s change should go.
- “Changes for the next book: decide the crime, the culprit and the t…”Each change answers a cause found above. Neither asks for more hours.
Before and after
What the audit asks for
The one faultThe changes ask for effort instead of answering the causes.
Drafting ran from March to December, four months over.
Rework: the first act drafted three times, because Nell’s job changed twice. I had not settled what she gives up by staying in the town.
Stalls: most of October. Once her ex left town in chapter 12, the fake-dating plan had no reason to go on, and I could not see what kept it going.
Waiting: none to speak of.
Changes for the next book: be more disciplined. Write every day, however tired I am. Stop putting it off.
Both versions find the same two causes, and find them well: the first act was redrafted because Nell’s stake was never settled, and October stalled because the pretend relationship had nothing to keep it going.
The first version then throws that away. Its changes are about the writer’s character, not the book’s process. More discipline would not have told her what Nell gives up, and writing while exhausted would not have fixed chapter 12.
The second version aims one change at each cause. Both can be done in a planning week, and both would have saved months.
The exception
When to break it
If this is your first book, there is no last book to audit. Look at the longest piece you have finished instead, or skip the audit for now and keep a light log as you draft, so there is something to look at next time.
If the last book went well, the audit is short. Write down what worked so that you keep doing it on purpose.
And if most of the lost time went to life rather than to the book, say so and stop there. The fix for a hard year is slack in the next plan, not a new method.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The villain’s plan
A fantasy writer’s audit shows that she drafted the second half of her last book twice. Three-quarters of the way through, she realised the villain’s plan made no sense, and everything after the midpoint had to change. Which change for the next book answers that cause?
Key takeaway
Before you plan the next book, find where the last one’s weeks went: forward, rework, stalls, and waiting or rest. Trace each big loss back to what started it, and choose one to three changes aimed at those roots. Asking for more hours is not a change to the process.
