Four depths
An outline can stop at any of four depths.
How deep to plan
- SpinePremise, turns, ending
- ChaptersA line for each
- ScenesWant, obstacle, outcome
- BeatsMoments inside scenes
The spine: the premise, the main turns and the ending, on a page or less.
The chapters: a line for each chapter, saying what happens and what changes.
The scenes: for each scene, who wants what, what stands in the way and how it ends.
The beats: the moments inside each scene, sometimes with lines of dialogue.
Each step down costs planning time and saves drafting time, but only up to a point. Plan below the depth you need and the draft stalls or has to be redone. Plan beyond it and you spend weeks deciding things the draft would have found in minutes, and often changes anyway.
Plan to where the rework was
The best evidence for how deep to go is your last draft. Look at what you had to redo, and ask which depth would have caught it.
Choosing a depth
- Find the last reworkWhat did you have to redo?
- Find the depthWhich level would have caught it?
- Plan down to itThere, and no deeper
- Stay shallow elsewhereWhere the draft went well
If you rewrote half the book because the ending changed, you needed the spine settled before you began. If the middle chapters wandered and were cut, a line per chapter would have shown the gap. If scenes kept going flat and had to be rebuilt, scene outlines would have helped. If the scenes came easily and survived, you do not need to outline them, however tidy it would look.
You can mix depths in one book. Outline deeper where you went wrong last time, and stay shallow where you did not.
Load-bearing decisions
Whatever the depth, some decisions hold the book up. Who did it. What the lead chooses at the climax, and what it costs. What the magic can and cannot do. Who dies. Change one of these halfway through and whole chapters come down with it. Make them before you start.
Two kinds of decision
Other things are cheap to find in the draft: what is said at dinner, which inn they stop at, the jokes between two minor characters. Changing one of these moves a scene, not a book.
Write the cheap ones down too, on a short list headed “Open on purpose”. Then a gap in the outline is a choice you made, and finding it out in the draft is part of the plan rather than a sign that the plan failed.
Example
An outline plan
A science fiction writer decides how deep to plan her next book, using what happened in her last one.
Last book: the ending held, but chapters 10 to 19 were drafted, cut and drafted again, because I did not know what the crew tried between the breach and the vote1. The scene outlines I wrote for the first act were wasted.2 I changed every one of them in the draft, and those chapters came out fine.
So this time: the spine first, then one line per chapter for the whole book, and scene outlines for the middle only, chapters 9 to 203.
Decided before chapter one: Okafor opens the airlock at the end, knowing what it costs her. The station’s air runs out on day nineteen. The saboteur is the doctor, and she does it to save her son.4
Open on purpose: how the crew finds out about the doctor; the cargo pilot’s storyline; every scene in the first act.5
- “chapters 10 to 19 were drafted, cut and drafted again, because I d…”The evidence: where the last draft had to be redone, and why.
- “The scene outlines I wrote for the first act were wasted.”The other half of the evidence: where planning cost time and bought nothing.
- “scene outlines for the middle only, chapters 9 to 20”Depths are mixed. She goes deep only where her last book went wrong.
- “The saboteur is the doctor, and she does it to save her son.”A load-bearing decision, made before the draft whatever the depth.
- “Open on purpose: how the crew finds out about the doctor; the carg…”The gaps are named, so finding them out in the draft is planned.
Before and after
The ending left open
The one faultA load-bearing decision is on the open list.
Last book I knew every chapter in advance and still rewrote the last third twice, because I changed my mind about how it ended. My scenes were fine without detailed outlines.
So: one line per chapter, no scene outlines.
Decided before chapter one: Mara and Jonah meet at the farm auction in chapter 1. The pretend engagement starts in chapter 4. The black moment is the newspaper story in chapter 22.
Open on purpose: whether they end up together and what Mara gives up for it; the second couple; the scenes at the bakery.
Both plans choose the right depth from the right evidence. The writer’s scenes come out well without outlines, so a line per chapter is enough.
But her last book lost weeks because the ending moved, and the first plan leaves the ending open again. In a romance, who ends up together and what each person gives up shapes every chapter that leads there. Leaving it to the draft repeats the very rework she is trying to avoid.
The second plan moves the ending into the decided list and leaves the genuinely cheap things open. It is no deeper. It has simply made the decision that holds the book up.
The exception
When to break it
Some writers find the story only by drafting it, and a detailed outline drains the book for them. If that is you, keep the outline to a spine and a short list of load-bearing decisions, and plan the speed into revision instead: a reverse outline at the end, and passes in order.
Some books need more depth than your habit suggests. A tightly plotted mystery, a heist or a book with several timelines may need scene-level planning even from a writer who usually works from a page.
And if the outline is taking longer than the draft would, stop and start drafting. Planning can become a comfortable way of not writing.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
The vault
A thriller writer’s last two drafts both stalled at the same place, about two-thirds in, when she had to work out how her team gets into the vault. Both times she rewrote the chapters before it. Her openings went quickly and survived. How deep should her next outline go?
Key takeaway
Plan to the depth your last draft says you need: deeper where you had to redo work, shallow where the draft went well. Whatever the depth, make the load-bearing decisions first, and write the rest on a list headed “Open on purpose”.
