Two jobs, two sittings
A first draft and a finished page are made by two different kinds of work. Drafting is getting the story down: who does what, in what order, to the end. Editing is making what is down better: clearer, tighter, more exact. Both matter. The trouble comes from doing them in the same minute.
The first draft has one job
When you stop mid-scene to find a better verb, you have swapped jobs. The sentence improves, and the scene slips out of your head. Do that every few lines and an hour can pass with one good paragraph to show for it and the end of the scene no nearer.
Anne Lamott makes the case for the rough first draft in her book Bird by Bird: a draft nobody else will see, allowed to be bad, so that there is something to fix.
The first draft has one job. It has to exist. A rough scene that reaches its last line can be revised next week. A polished opening paragraph with nothing after it cannot.
Three habits that keep a draft moving
Drafting badly does not mean not caring. It means deciding which problems belong to today. Today’s problem is what happens. The exact word, the right name and the checked fact can wait, as long as you leave yourself a note.
Three habits
- Mark the gap and pass it[RIVER NAME], or TK for “to come”
- Let the wrong word standA cliché is a note about roughly what belongs there
- Put changes of mind in the draft[from here she is a sister; fix earlier chapters]
Mark the gap and pass it. When you do not know a name, a date or a fact, type a placeholder and carry on: [RIVER NAME], or [check: did trains run on Sundays?]. Some writers type TK, a mark long used in newsrooms and publishing to mean “to come”. Few English words have those two letters side by side, so a search for it turns up little else.
Let the wrong word stand. If the phrase that comes is a cliché or a near miss, type it, flag it if you like, and go on. A cliché in a first draft is a note to yourself about roughly what belongs there.
Put changes of mind in the draft. If you realise in chapter nine that the brother should have been a sister all along, do not go back. Write [from here she is a sister; fix earlier chapters] and continue as if it were already done.
Example
A first draft doing its job
A telegraph clerk in the 1890s takes down a message and finds it is about her own family. This is the writer’s first pass, with her notes to herself left in.
Rosamund took the message down the way she took all of them, without reading it. [what does the machine look like? brass? CHECK]1 It was only when she counted the words for the charge that she saw the name. Not the grocer’s. Hers.
She looked at the door. Mr Clement was in the back with the ledgers, humming something [TK song, from 1893 or before]2.
MOTHER WORSE STOP COME BY THURSDAY STOP. Sent from [TOWN, two days away by rail], and today was Wednesday. Her heart was in her mouth [cliché, fix]3. She could not leave the key unattended, that was the rule, she had signed a paper.
She folded the form small and put it in her shoe. Then she wrote out a fresh one, to the grocer, about nothing, about the price of [something], so the count in the book would come right. [does this work? would the numbers match? think later]4
“Miss Garroway?” Mr Clement called. “Was that the wire?”
“A wrong address,” she said, and it was done.5
- “[what does the machine look like? brass? CHECK]”A research gap, passed in a few words. What the machine looks like is a problem for another day.
- “[TK song, from 1893 or before]”A placeholder with enough of a note to act on later: she needs a song, and it has a date limit.
- “Her heart was in her mouth [cliché, fix]”The wrong phrase is allowed to stand and is flagged. It holds the place of the feeling until revision.
- “[does this work? would the numbers match? think later]”A doubt about the plot, written down and not solved. Solving it now would have cost her the scene.
- ““A wrong address,” she said, and it was done.”The draft reaches its end. She has lied to her employer, and the writer now has a whole scene to revise.
The explainer
Leave a bracket and keep going
The kitchen table before the children wake, and the first version of the morning, one sentence at a time. Press a sentence to swap in its rewrite. Each clue lights up as the draft stops waiting for the right word and goes on without it.

Changes left
5 of 5
Words
105 (was 105)
Press a sentence to make its change and watch the room.
Before and after
A writer’s account of one morning, twice
The one faultThe writer stopped drafting to look something up.
I had forty minutes before the children woke, and the scene was going well. Merrick had the hatch open and was about to climb down into the hold. Then I needed the word for the ladder on a ship. Not “ladder”. There is a proper word. I opened a browser to find it. The word led to a diagram of a cargo ship, and the diagram led to a forum where two retired engineers were arguing about hatch covers. When the alarm went I had the word, and eleven facts about hatch covers. I typed the word in. Merrick was still standing at the top.
These are two accounts of the same forty minutes, and they are word for word the same until the writer needs a term she does not know. In the first she goes to find it. The search is not idle, and she comes back with the right word. But the scene has not moved: her character is where he was when she left him.
In the second she types a placeholder and goes on. She hits another gap a line later, the smell of the hold, and brackets that as well. By the alarm she has the thing the scene existed for, which is the empty crate. The ship’s ladder still needs its proper name. That will take two minutes on some other day, and the scene will still be there when she has it.
The exception
When to break it
Splitting drafting from editing is a working method, and it does not suit every writer or every day.
A gap you can bracket, and one you cannot
Some writers revise as they go and cannot move on until the page behind them is sound. If that is how you work, and your drafts get finished, there is nothing to fix. The test is whether drafts reach their end, not which method got them there.
Rereading yesterday’s pages and making light corrections is a common way back into a book. It is worth keeping if it leads into new writing and does not replace it.
Some gaps cannot be bracketed. If the missing fact decides what happens next (could she have reached the border by dawn?), look it up now, because everything after it depends on the answer. And if you find mid-draft that the story has a deep fault, such as the wrong narrator, pushing on to the end may only produce more pages to throw away. Stopping to rethink is then the quicker road.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Today’s job
You are halfway through the first draft of a scene. Which of these is a drafting job, to do now?
Key takeaway
A first draft has one job, which is to exist from first line to last. Mark what you do not know, let the wrong word stand, and keep today’s work to finding out what happens. Editing gets a sitting of its own.
