A range, not two camps
Somewhere before or during a draft, a writer has to settle one question: how much do I decide in advance?
A range, not two camps
- Draws the whole house firstThe main events, the ending, sometimes every scene
- Fixes the endingAnd three or four turning points; discovers the rest
- Plans a few scenes aheadWrites them, then plans a few more
- Plants a seedStarts with a character or a situation and finds the story
At one end is the outliner, who works out the story before drafting: the main events, the ending, sometimes every scene. At the other end is the discovery writer, who starts with a character or a situation and finds the story by writing it. You may have heard the two called plotters and pantsers (from writing “by the seat of your pants”). The novelist George R. R. Martin likes to call them architects and gardeners. One draws the whole house before building. The other plants a seed and tends what comes up.
Plenty of writers sit somewhere between. Some fix the ending and three or four turning points, and discover the rest. Some plan only the next few scenes, write them, and plan a few more. Some write a loose first draft to find the story and outline afterwards, treating that draft as a very long plan.
None of these is the proper way. They are different places to put the same work.
Where each method puts the hard part
A story’s problems have to be solved at some point: what the characters want, why one event leads to the next, how it ends. Your planning style decides when you meet them.
When you meet the problems
An outline moves the problems to the front. You find the hole in the middle while it is still one line on a page, and the draft can go faster because each scene knows where it is heading. The cost is time before any pages exist. For some writers there is a second cost: once the story is outlined it feels already told, and the draft goes flat. Outlines also get overtaken. Characters grow on the page, and the plan has to be redrawn.
Discovery puts the problems at the back. The draft stays alive because you are finding things out much as a reader will. The bill comes in revision: scenes that led nowhere, a middle that wandered, an opening that has to be rebuilt once the ending is known. A discovery draft can also stop dead at the point where the lack of a destination catches up with it.
So the useful question is not which kind of writer you are. It is what happened last time. Where did your last project stall? What did the revision have to fix? Those answers are evidence, and they may point somewhere your label does not.
Example
A plan with gaps left on purpose
This is one writer’s whole plan for a mystery novel. It sits in the middle of the range. Notice what she has fixed and what she has chosen to leave open.
Ending (fixed)1: Thandiwe proves the surveyor was never on the mountain. She does not prove who was.
Opening: the claim arrives at the land office with a map that is too good.
Turn 1: she walks the first boundary and the cairns are new.
Turn 2: the old guide who could confirm it has been paid to go north. By whom? Don’t know yet. Find out when I write him.2
Turn 3: she has to choose between the true map and her post.
Between the turns: no plan.3 Ride the mules and see.
Not decided: whether Bastien is helping her or the company. I change my mind every week. Draft him both ways in chapter four and keep the one that argues back.4
- “Ending (fixed)”The destination is settled before she starts. Everything else can move; this cannot.
- “Don’t know yet. Find out when I write him.”A gap left on purpose. She knows the question and trusts the drafting to answer it.
- “Between the turns: no plan.”She has planned the signposts and nothing between them. The stretches of road are for discovering.
- “Draft him both ways in chapter four and keep the one that argues back.”A decision she cannot make in outline, so she plans an experiment and lets the draft decide.
Before and after
One writer’s note to herself, two ways
The one faultThe method is chosen from a label, and the writer’s own history is ignored.
I am a discovery writer. I have never outlined and I am not going to start now, because an outline kills a story for me. My first novel took four years and stopped twice in the middle, once for eight months. The second I gave up at about the same place. For the third I will do what I do: start with Sofia on the night ferry and see where she takes me.
Both passages contain the same history: two novels, both stalled in the middle. The first writer states it and then steps over it. Her decision comes from the label in her opening sentence, and so book three is set up to stall where the first two did.
The second reads the same facts as evidence. She notices what the two stalls had in common: an easy opening, then a stop at the point where what she already knew ran out. She does not swing to a full outline, because nothing in her history says she needs one. She makes the smallest change that answers the pattern, and she treats it as a test. If the middle still defeats her, she will have learned something more.
The exception
When to break it
Choosing on evidence assumes you have some. If this is your first long project you have none yet, so pick whichever approach makes you want to start, and treat the project itself as the experiment.
Choosing for this book
The right amount of planning can change from book to book. A mystery whose solution has to be fair to the reader, or a story told across several timelines, may ask for more to be worked out in advance than a quiet novel about one family. A writer who discovered her way through the one may need to plan the other.
Other people change things too. If a co-writer has to draft half the chapters, or someone has to approve the story before it is written, some form of outline is hard to avoid.
And an outline is not a contract. If the draft finds something better than the plan, change the plan.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Three stalled novels
A writer has begun three novels without a plan. Each opening came easily, and each draft was abandoned near the midpoint. “I’m just a pantser,” she says. Which next step answers what her evidence shows, and changes nothing else?
Key takeaway
How much to plan is a choice about when to meet your story’s problems: before the draft, during it or after. Every position on the range has a cost. Choose yours by looking at what happened on your own past pages, and be ready to choose differently for the next book.
