Notice, note, keep going
Partway through a draft you find out things the early chapters did not know. The cousin should be a sister. The well is in the wrong place. A key that matters in chapter twenty has never been seen before. Each discovery comes with a pull to go back and put it right, now, while it is fresh.
What to do with a discovery
- NoticeSomething in an earlier chapter is now wrong
- Note it hereIn square brackets, on the page you are writing
- Add it to the listOne line on the running change list
- Write on as if doneFrom this page, the change is true
Resist it. Write a note where you are, in square brackets, and then write on as if the change had already been made. If the cousin is now a sister, she is a sister from this page on, even though chapter one still says otherwise. The draft will disagree with itself for a while. That is what the notes are for.
Going back costs more than it seems. A change to chapter three pulls you into rereading chapter three, then four, and the session that was meant to move the book forward ends where it began. And the change may change again. Twenty chapters on, you may find the sister should have been a brother after all, or that the scene she lives in has been cut.
A note you can act on later
A note is written for a stranger: you, months from now, with no memory of what you meant. “[fix this]” will tell her nothing. A useful note says what is wrong and where the change goes, and, when it matters, what follows from it.
Inside a useful note
[fix:1 ch 3 —2 the clerk is a woman.3 She is one from here on.]4
- The keywordfix, check or add, so a search finds it
- WhereThe chapter the change reaches back to
- WhatThe change itself, in plain words
- What followsHow to write on from here
It also helps to start each note with one of a small set of words, so you can search for them later. Three cover most needs. [fix: …] changes something already written: “[fix: ch 3 — the clerk is a woman.]” [check: …] is a fact to look up: “[check: did the ferry run on Sundays?]” [add: …] puts something new into an earlier chapter, usually a setup a later scene needs: “[add: ch 5 — show the key on its hook.]”
Square brackets are rare in fiction, so a search for “[fix:” finds every one. The lesson on permission to draft badly, earlier in Writing process, covers placeholders for the names and words you do not know yet.
The running change list
Notes in the text are found where they sit. A running change list gathers the ones that reach back into earlier chapters, so you can see them all at once. Keep it in one file, outside the manuscript, and add a line whenever you write a fix or add note.
One line on the change list
- WhereChapter 3
- WhatThe clerk becomes a woman
- Found inChapter 15, the ferry office
- Depends on itThe Tuesday alibi in chapter 9
Each entry needs three things: where the change goes, what it is, and the chapter where you found it. A fourth is worth adding when it applies: what else depends on it.
When the draft is done, this list is where revision starts. Some entries will have become unnecessary, because the ending solved them. Some will have grown. Read together, five small entries may turn out to be one larger change.
Example
Notes left in a draft
A mystery writer, fifteen chapters in, has found out two things her early chapters got wrong, and has one fact she is not sure of. She notes all three and keeps going.
Inspector Halloran reached the ferry office at ten past six. [check: first winter crossing, six or seven?]1 The clerk was already there, sorting yesterday’s stubs into a shoebox.
“The Tuesday crossing,” Halloran said. “Who sold the tickets?”
“I did. I sell them all.”
[fix: ch 3 — the clerk is a woman, which changes the Tuesday alibi. She is one from here on.]2
She tipped the shoebox towards him.3 Halloran saw the stub at once: a single return, punched at the wrong end.
[add: ch 5 — Ruth has to mention that she always buys a return. Plant it at the funeral tea.]4
“Who buys a return,” he said, “and never comes back?”
- “[check: first winter crossing, six or seven?]”A fact to look up. It changes nothing in the story, so it can wait until revision.
- “[fix: ch 3 — the clerk is a woman, which changes the Tuesday alibi…”Where, what, what depends on it, and how to write on. The note is longer than the line of dialogue before it, and it is worth every word.
- “She tipped the shoebox towards him.”The very next line treats the change as done. Chapter three still says otherwise, and that is fine for now.
- “[add: ch 5 — Ruth has to mention that she always buys a return. Pl…”The clue only works if the reader has seen it before. Rather than write the earlier scene now, she says exactly where it should go.
Before and after
The same notes, made usable
The one faultThe notes do not say what to change or where.
Teo cycled the airlock twice before Captain Imre would let him through. [fix this] The hold smelled of coolant and old oranges.
“You signed for forty crates,” Imre said. “I count thirty-nine.”
“Then someone opened one.” [??]
Imre did not look at him. She was looking at the seal on the nearest crate, which was the wrong colour. [sort out the seals]
The writer noticed the same three problems in both versions, and in both she rightly kept going. The difference is what she left for herself.
In the first, the notes are flags with nothing on them. Three months from now, “[fix this]” beside the airlock could mean the airlock, the captain, Teo or the sentence. “[??]” could mean anything at all. She will have to rediscover each problem before she can solve it, and some she will not rediscover.
In the second, each note names its kind, its chapter and its change. Revision can start from them on the first morning, and a search for “[fix:” will find the airlock without rereading the book.
The exception
When to break it
Some discoveries cannot wait. If the change alters the scenes you are about to write, such as who is telling the story or whether a character is alive, settle it before you go on, or you will draft chapters you already expect to throw away. Settle it by deciding, not by rewriting: make the decision, note it, and write on in line with it.
Many writers reread the last page or two before they start, and tidy a sentence on the way in. That is a warm-up, not a rewrite, and it does no harm as long as it stays small.
And if a note keeps growing, until you are writing half a page in brackets, the change may deserve a few minutes of planning. Do that on the change list, then come back to the page you were on.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
The note you will thank yourself for
At chapter sixteen, a writer realises that Harriet should be Harry’s sister, not his cousin. It affects chapters one, three and seven. Which note, left on the page where she is writing, will be most use to her in revision?
Key takeaway
When the draft teaches you something about an earlier chapter, write a note where you are and keep going as if the change were made. Make each note say what and where, start it with fix, check or add, and gather the ones that reach back into one running change list for revision.
