The doubt in the middle
Somewhere in a long draft, often past the first third and well short of the end, the book starts to look worse. The opening that excited you reads as flat. The idea seems thinner than it did. You begin to wonder whether to start again, or start something else.
Where the doubt tends to arrive
- The idea is new
- The doubt arrives
- The end in sight
That doubt is a familiar part of writing a long draft, and it is poor evidence about the book. You are judging a half-built thing against the finished idea in your head, from close up, after weeks of looking at it. Nobody can see the shape of a novel from inside its middle, including the person writing it. Comparing it with a published novel is no fairer: you are setting a first draft beside a book that has been revised many times over.
The doubt does not need to be argued with or cured. It needs to be worked around, so the draft keeps moving while the feeling runs its course. Four ways of doing that follow. None of them is guaranteed to make the doubt go away. They help you keep writing while it is there.
Four ways through
Shrink the session. If an hour feels impossible, set fifteen minutes, or one paragraph, and stop when it is done. A small session you finish does more for the draft than a long one you avoid.
Ways through a slump
- Shrink the sessionFifteen minutes or one paragraph, then stop
- Skip aheadWrite the scene you want, and bracket the gap
- Doubt becomes a taskOn the change list, as a fix for later
- Read back lessThe last page, not the whole draft
Skip ahead. Write a scene you want to write, even if it comes six chapters later, and leave a bracketed gap where you jumped from: [the hearing goes here]. Forward words on any page keep the draft moving, and the scene you wanted to write often shows you what the skipped stretch needs.
Turn the doubt into a task. When the doubt has content (“the opening is too slow”, “her brother is a cardboard cut-out”), write it on your change list as a fix for later. On the list it is a job with a place in the queue, not a verdict on the book.
Read back less. Start each session with the last page you wrote, not the whole draft. Rereading from the beginning in a low week gives the doubt more to feed on, and it spends the time you meant for new words.
Example
One week in a slump
A literary novelist is in the middle of her draft and has lost faith in it. Her session diary for the week shows how she kept going anyway.
Mon. Opened the file and read chapter one. The whole thing is grey.1 Closed the file. No words.
Tue. Rule for this week: fifteen minutes, then I may stop.2 Wrote 240 words of the drive to the coast. Stopped at fifteen.
Wed. Doubt of the day: Alma is too gentle to have done what she does in chapter four. Change list: [fix: ch 2 and 3 — show Alma’s temper once before the shop scene].3 Fifteen minutes, 310 words.
Thu. Did not want to write the funeral. Wrote the scene I have wanted to write for months instead, Alma and her father on the pier.4 Left [funeral goes here]. 900 words in forty minutes. Did not notice the time.
Fri. Read only yesterday’s last page and wrote on from the pier. The funeral is clearer now: it is where she decides not to forgive him.5 520 words.
- “Opened the file and read chapter one. The whole thing is grey.”Monday starts at the beginning of the book, and the doubt takes the session.
- “Rule for this week: fifteen minutes, then I may stop.”She shrinks the session until it is small enough to keep in a bad week.
- “Change list: [fix: ch 2 and 3 — show Alma’s temper once before the…”A doubt with content becomes a task, with a chapter and a fix. Then she goes back to the page she was on.
- “Wrote the scene I have wanted to write for months instead, Alma an…”She skips ahead to a scene she wants to write, and leaves a plain gap for the one she is avoiding.
- “The funeral is clearer now: it is where she decides not to forgive…”Writing the later scene showed her what the skipped one is for. Reading only the last page kept her in the new material.
Before and after
Same session, two starts
The one faultShe rereads the whole draft at the start of the session.
Sunday. Forty minutes. I started, as usual, by reading the draft from the beginning to get back into it. Chapter one still embarrasses me. I fixed the café scene again, then read on to where I had stopped, chapter nine, the night of the gala. By then it was time to cook. No new words, and I feel worse about the book than I did this morning.
The session is the same length in both versions, and the doubt is the same: chapter one embarrasses her either way.
In the first, she starts at page one to “get back into it”. That walks her straight past the pages she likes least, and she stops to fix one of them. By the time she reaches the gala, the forty minutes are gone and the doubt has had the whole session to work on her.
In the second, she starts at the last page. The embarrassing chapter is still there and still embarrassing, and she leaves it alone. Forty minutes produce three beats of the gala and 640 words. Her opinion of the book has not improved. The book has.
The exception
When to break it
Sometimes the doubt is right. If it names a real story problem, such as not knowing what happens next or a character who will not do what the plot needs, working around it will not help for long. The lesson on getting unstuck, earlier in Writing process, covers telling the kinds of stall apart.
Sometimes the slump has little to do with the book. Illness, grief, money worries, a new baby or a hard month at work can all drain the drafting out of you. Then a planned pause may serve the book better than fifteen-minute sessions. Decide it, write down where you stopped and what comes next, and put a date in the diary to look again.
And sometimes the doubt is about the whole project. If it is still there after the draft is finished and has rested, take it seriously. Finish first if you can, though: a finished draft is a far better place to decide from than a half-built one.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Where the session goes
Owen is halfway through his draft and has lost faith in it. Each evening he sits down for an hour, rereads from chapter one to get back into the story, and stops at bedtime having written nothing new. What is the most useful change to make tomorrow?
Key takeaway
Doubt in the middle of a long draft is common, and it says little about the book. Work around it: make the session small enough to finish, skip to a scene you want to write, put the doubt on the change list as a task, and read back only the last page.
