Lesson 1 of 6
Subtext Cove · stone 1Intermediate6 minute read

The iceberg

Leaving out what the writer knows so the reader feels it beneath the surface.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

Subtext Cove: calm water with reefs showing beneath the surface.
Subtext Cove · Subtext, stone 1 of 6

What the writer knows and does not say

A woman lays the table for two, looks at it, and puts one plate back in the cupboard.

Leaving out what you never knew leaves a hollow place, so the iceberg is two jobs: find out, then choose what shows.

Nobody has told you anything, and you already know a good deal. Someone used to sit there.

Ernest Hemingway gave this effect its best-known name. In Death in the Afternoon (1932) he argued that a writer who knows a subject well enough can leave out things he knows, and the reader will still sense them, provided the rest is written truly. His image was an iceberg, whose slow, steady movement comes from the great mass hidden under the water.

The same passage carries a warning. Leaving something out because you never knew it is not the same thing at all: it leaves a hollow place in the writing. So the iceberg is two jobs. First you find out what is under the water. Then you choose the small part that shows.

The part that shows

What shows is not a hint or a riddle. It is the ordinary evidence a hidden thing leaves behind: a habit that has outlived its reason, an object kept or avoided, a question answered a little to one side, a job done for somebody who is not there.

What shows is not a hint or a riddle but the ordinary evidence a hidden thing leaves behind.

Do you know it? Write the submerged fact as a plain sentence, in your notes if not in the book. If you cannot, the reader will find a blank where the weight should be.

Is there a trace? At least one concrete thing on the page has to be there because of the hidden fact.

Could a reader say roughly what it is? They should be able to say “someone has died” or “these two have a history”, and feel the size of it.

This is not the same as keeping a secret for a twist, which is hidden so that the reader cannot see it yet.

Two other lessons sit close to this one. The lesson on the iceberg, under Setting and worldbuilding, applies the same image to a world: how much of a place’s history and workings the writer knows and keeps off the page. The lesson on subtext in speech, under Dialogue, shows people talking round a subject. Here the thing held back is what the scene is about, a loss or a shared history, and it is the narration that declines to explain.

Example

A man plants beans

Nowhere does this passage say who is missing, or what happened in March. Watch what shows.

Broad beansliterary

Bernard got to the allotment at seven, before the others, and dug two trenches where there had always been two1.

He set the broad beans a hand apart, as the back of the packet said. He did not eat broad beans.2 He had said so every summer for thirty years, over a plate of them.

He had cut new row markers and written on them himself, in capitals, but when he opened the tin in the shed last year’s were still there, in a slanting hand, in green ink3. He pushed one of those into the soil4 at the end of each row and put his own back in the tin.

Nadine from the next plot stopped at the fence at eight.

“Beans in already,” she said. “She’d have been pleased with that.”5

“They’re late,” said Bernard. “They should have gone in in March.”6

He watered both rows, and then the empty bed beside them, where the sweet peas went7.

  1. “dug two trenches where there had always been two”A habit carried on. We do not yet know whose habit it was.
  2. “He did not eat broad beans.”The first trace. If he does not eat them, the beans are for somebody else, and the next sentence gives that somebody thirty summers at the same table.
  3. “in a slanting hand, in green ink”The other person arrives as handwriting. She is not described and not named.
  4. “He pushed one of those into the soil”A choice made with an object. He has markers of his own, and he uses hers.
  5. ““She’d have been pleased with that.””The nearest the passage comes to saying it, and the tense of the verb does all the work. Nobody says “died”.
  6. ““They should have gone in in March.””He answers the gardening and not the kindness. Why the beans are late is left under the water.
  7. “the empty bed beside them, where the sweet peas went”He waters bare soil. “Went” is in the past tense, and the passage stops there without comment.

Before and after

Cut the paragraph that explains

The one faultThe narration stops to explain the history between the two people.

Weaker versionBerth four (first version)

Keld Station answered on the second hail.

“Tug Linnet, this is Keld control. Go ahead.”

Stina knew the voice. She and Oscar had flown the Linnet together for six years, until the collision at Port Haro, and at the inquiry he had told the board that the docking error was hers. She had lost her long-haul licence and he had been given a desk. She had not forgiven him, and she knew that he had not forgiven himself.

“Keld control, Linnet,” she said. “Requesting a berth. Eleven hours, cargo only.”

“Linnet, you have berth four.”

Berth four was the one beside the hub, with the short walk to the canteen. Pilots waited days for it.

“Negative, control. Give me something on the outer ring.”

The channel stayed open. She could hear him breathing.

“Berth nineteen,” he said. “The port clamp sticks. You have to ease it, the way we—” He stopped. “Ease it by hand.”

“Copy nineteen.” She closed the channel before he could say her name.

Showing the weaker version.

The two versions differ by three sentences. In the first, the narration tells us what happened at Port Haro, who lost what, and who has forgiven whom. It also means that when Oscar offers the best berth on the station, we are only watching him do what we were told he feels.

Take the three sentences out and read the radio traffic again. He gives her the berth pilots wait days for. She asks for the outer ring. He starts to say “the way we” and cannot finish. She cuts the channel before he can use her name. The reader does not know about the inquiry, and does know that these two worked together, that he wronged her or believes he did, and that she will not let him make it up.

The exception

When to break it

Leave out what the reader can feel, and say what the reader has to know. If the plot turns on the fact that these two were once married, or that the bridge is mined, a reader with only a feeling about it will be lost at the moment you need them sure. State it, plainly and once.

Leave out what the reader can feel, and say what the reader has to know.

Some stories promise explanation. A mystery owes its solution in so many words, and an invented world may need some of its workings stated before anything in it can be felt.

And silence can wear thin over a whole novel. A long book may be the stronger for letting the hidden thing be said at last, late, by the person who has avoided it longest.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 2 min

Under the water

Two brothers have not spoken since their mother’s house was sold. The writer has cut the paragraph that explained the quarrel. Which sentence keeps the quarrel off the page and still lets the reader feel it?

Key takeaway

Know more than you tell. Work out the hidden fact until you could state it in one sentence, then leave that sentence out and keep the evidence it leaves in the scene: a habit, an object, an answer given slightly to one side. If a reader can feel the weight and say roughly what it is, you have cut the right thing.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

Chart your own iceberg

List what you know about the history behind one scene, mark what the scene states and what it shows, and cut one stated item that the scene already shows.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.