What stays under water
Ernest Hemingway compared good prose to an iceberg. Most of an iceberg is under water, and he argued that a writer who knows a subject thoroughly can leave much of it out and the reader will still feel it there. He added a warning. Leave out what you do not know, and the reader feels a hole instead.
Hemingway’s warning
He was talking about writing in general. Novelists who build worlds have borrowed the image since, and it fits their problem well. You may know your town’s whole history, or your invented empire’s, or every job your character’s grandfather held. The page has room for very little of it. The iceberg idea says that this is no loss. What you know and do not say still shapes what you do say, and it keeps the details you show consistent with one another.
The Subtext element has a lesson on the same image applied to what lies between people: a loss, a shared history. This one is about the world: its past, its customs and how it works.
How depth shows without being explained
Depth reaches the page through small, exact things that only make sense if there is more behind them.
- A nameThe New Inn, plainly the oldest building
- A habitEveryone touching the doorpost
- Wear and repairA step hollowed by feet
- A passing reference“since the flood”
A name can do it: a pub called the New Inn that is plainly the oldest building in the street. So can a habit nobody remarks on, such as everyone touching the doorpost on the way in. So can wear and repair: a step hollowed by feet, a wall patched in a different brick. So can something that is pointedly not done, like the chair by the window where no one sits. And so can a passing reference that the characters understand and do not explain: “since the flood”, “before the road came”.
Each of these is a tip showing above the water. A good one passes two tests. You, the writer, could answer the question it raises. And the scene still works for a reader who is not given the answer.
Example
A club, years later
A woman comes back to the social club of the town she grew up in. Nothing here is explained. Count the questions the passage raises and leaves open.
The Institute still had its two doors. Estelle went in by the left one without thinking, and was halfway down the corridor before she remembered that it no longer mattered which1.
The bar had been moved to the back room. Above it hung the banner, under glass now, and beside the banner the photograph of the strike committee, with three faces she could put names to and one that had been cut out with a blade2. The barman was a boy. He asked what she was having, and did not ask whose she was3.
“Is Mr Rudge still secretary?”
“There’s no secretary. There’s a management company.” He set her glass down on a mat that advertised the retail park4. “You’ll want the function room. They’re all in there. Mind the step, it never did get fixed5.”
- “it no longer mattered which”Once there was a rule about who used which door. We are not told the rule, only that her feet still obey it.
- “one that had been cut out with a blade”A strike, a committee, and somebody the town chose to remove from the picture. A chapter of history is implied in a single clause, and the scene does not stop.
- “did not ask whose she was”A hint made from something missing. In the town she remembers, a barman would have asked which family she belonged to.
- “a mat that advertised the retail park”What came after the works closed, shown as an object under a glass. No sentence says the works closed.
- “it never did get fixed”A plain remark that carries years. The boy assumes she knows the step, so he is the one who tells us she belongs here.
Before and after
An inn, explained and unexplained
The one faultEvery hint is followed at once by its explanation, so nothing is left for the reader to feel or wonder about.
The inn at the crossroads was called the Third Lantern, because two earlier inns on the same spot had burned down, the first in a raid and the second when a cook fell asleep. Kojo ducked under the lintel. Every traveller before him had touched the iron nail driven into it, which was an old custom meant to stop the marsh-spirits following a person indoors, and the wood round the nail was worn to a hollow. He touched it too. The room was full, and men stood three deep along the wall with their bowls in their hands. No one was sitting at the table by the hearth, since that table was kept free for the ferrymen’s dead, who were believed to come in from the river on cold nights. He found a stool by the door and asked for whatever was hot.
The first version has three good hints: an inn called the Third Lantern, a nail that travellers touch, and an empty table in a crowded room. Each is then explained in full: the two fires, the marsh-spirits, the ferrymen’s dead. The explanations are inventive, and they turn a place with a past into a list of footnotes. They also make a tired man take far longer to reach a stool.
The second version keeps the three hints and cuts the three explanations. It adds two small touches so that the hints can speak without help: the size of the hollow, and a table laid for six. The name now makes the reader wonder what became of the first two. The worn hollow shows that many hands have touched the nail, and Kojo touching it shows that he knows why. The crowd standing along the wall while the best table sits laid and empty says that the table is for someone, and that nobody here would dream of taking it. The author still knows about the fires and the dead. That knowledge is why the three details agree with one another.
The exception
When to break it
Whatever the plot turns on has to be above the water. If the ending depends on a custom or a rule, the reader needs to have been given it plainly, and a hint will not do.
Above the water
How much to leave out depends on who is reading. A fast thriller, or a book for younger readers, may want more said and less implied, because a hint that is missed is wasted space.
In a mystery, an unexplained detail is read as a clue. Leave too many of them open at the end and they look like loose threads.
The image can also be misread as an order to build the whole iceberg first. Plenty of writers find out what lies under the surface while they draft, and go back afterwards to plant the tips. Months of world notes before a first page can be a way of not writing the book. And vagueness is not depth: “the town had its secrets” has nothing underneath it.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is a tip?
Four sentences about a town. Which one hints at a larger history through an exact detail, and leaves it unexplained?
Key takeaway
Know more than you tell. Let the page carry the tips, in the form of names, habits, wear and things left undone, and explain only what the scene cannot work without. Before you cut an explanation, check that you could still answer the question the hint raises.
