The fairness problem
Suppose the heroine is trapped, the reader can see no way out, and on the last page she finds that she can fly. The problem is solved and the reader feels cheated. Nothing was at risk after all, since the author could hand over a new power whenever one was wanted.
Sanderson’s First Law
The novelist Brandon Sanderson has put the principle into one sentence, which he calls his First Law: an author’s ability to solve conflict with magic is in proportion to how well the reader understands that magic. If the reader knows what the power can and cannot do, a solution that uses it feels earned, because the reader could have thought of it. If they do not know, it feels like a rescue.
The same holds for anything able to settle a plot: a starship’s engine, a detective’s laboratory, a hacker’s access, a rich aunt’s money. Realist novels are not exempt. A test result that comes back in an hour because the chapter is ending is a spell by another name.
Limits and costs
Sanderson’s Second Law is shorter: limitations matter more than powers. What an ability cannot do, and what it takes from the person using it, give a story more than the ability itself.
Limits matter more than powers
A limit is something the ability cannot do, however skilled the user. A cost is what each use takes: strength, time, money, years, somebody’s trust. “He can hear any conversation in the city” is a power, and a man who has it can solve every mystery by lunchtime. Add that he can follow one voice at a time and is deaf for an hour afterwards. Now he has to choose whom to listen to, and he can be caught while he recovers. The scenes come from the limits.
One more habit is worth forming. Show the rule at work on something small before it has to work on something large. A reader who has watched it mend a jug will accept what it does, and what it costs, when a life depends on it.
Example
A rule shown small
In this invented craft, a break can be moved but not unmade. Watch how much of the rule you learn from one cracked jug, long before the story needs it.
The jug had a crack from lip to foot. Ebba took it in her left hand and a blank clay token in her right, and held them until her wrists ached. There was a sound like a knuckle. The jug rang whole when she flicked it, and the token lay in two halves on her palm1. She dropped the halves into the sack under the stall, which was nearly full2.
“Two pence,” she said. “And one for the token.”3
The woman paid. She did not go. “My boy’s arm. He fell from the hay door.”
“Take him to the bonesetter.”
“They say you can do it.”
“They say right.” Ebba wiped the clay dust from her hands. “Clay goes into clay. Iron goes into iron.4 Bone goes into bone, mistress, and I’d need a whole one to put it in. Whose would you like me to use?”5
The woman looked at her own arm, and then at Ebba’s, and took her jug and went.
- “the token lay in two halves on her palm”The power and its limit in one picture. The crack has gone from the jug, and it has not gone from the world. It had to go into something.
- “which was nearly full”Costs pile up. Every mend she has ever done is in that sack.
- ““And one for the token.””The cost has a price, and the customer pays it. The magic has entered the town’s economy.
- ““Clay goes into clay. Iron goes into iron.”The rule, said aloud to someone with a reason to ask. It is put as a tradeswoman would put it.
- “Whose would you like me to use?””The same rule at human scale. From here on the reader knows what a mended arm would take, so that if the story ever asks someone to pay it, nobody will call it a trick.
Before and after
The same proof, sprung and planted
The one faultThe thing that breaks the alibi, a tracker in every hired van, is first mentioned at the moment it wins the scene.
“I was at home,” Clive said. “All evening. Ask my wife.”
“I did.” Yelena put a single sheet of paper on the table. “This is from the hire firm. Every van they rent out has a tracker fitted behind the dashboard, and they keep the records for a month. Your van left their yard at seven. It stood outside the pumping station from ten past eight until nine.”
He looked at the paper for a long time.
There is no magic here, and the fault is the same one. In the first version the investigator has to stop in the middle of her own triumph and explain the tracker, because the reader has not heard of it. The alibi falls, and the reader could not have seen how it would.
The second version adds one short exchange from earlier in the day, in which a bored clerk mentions the tracker while she is hiring a van herself. The confrontation is otherwise the same, and it is shorter, since she no longer needs to explain. A reader who remembers the clerk gets there half a second before the suspect does, which is the best place to be. In a full novel the clerk would come chapters earlier, among other details, where it would look like nothing.
The exception
When to break it
Not all magic wants rules. Sanderson himself describes a scale. At one end is “hard” magic, with rules the reader knows, which characters can use as a tool. At the other is “soft” magic, kept mysterious for the sake of wonder or dread. Fairy tales, ghost stories and a good deal of classic fantasy sit at the soft end, and a ghost whose powers have been listed is less frightening. His guideline for soft magic is that it may cause problems freely, and the people in the story should solve them by other means.
Sanderson’s scale
- Rules the reader knowsCharacters can use it as a tool
- Kept mysteriousFor wonder or dread, as in ghost stories
The reader does not need the whole system, only the rule the solution uses. A manual is not a story.
Comic and tall-tale writing can cheat in the open, because the cheat is the joke.
And ordinary abilities need no planting. Nobody has to be shown early on that a telephone can make calls. The capabilities to set up are the special ones: the ones a reader would not assume.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which escape is fair?
A prisoner gets out of a locked cell at the climax of a fantasy novel. Which version plays fair with the reader?
Key takeaway
Anything that can solve your plot needs rules the reader has met beforehand. Decide what it can do, what it cannot do and what it costs. Show that on something small. Then let your characters win inside those rules and pay what they owe.
