Nobody sees the whole room
Walk three people into the same kitchen. The plumber looks under the sink. The guest looks for somewhere to put her coat. The child looks at the cake on the counter. Ask each of them afterwards what the kitchen was like and you will hear about three different kitchens.
Three people, one kitchen
Fiction can use this. Most scenes are told through one character, the person whose eyes and thoughts the reader is borrowing. That person is called the viewpoint character. When you describe a place through them, you can describe it as they would notice it: the details they would pick out, in the order they would come to them, in the sort of words they would use.
A description written this way does two jobs in the same space. The reader learns what the place is like, and learns something about the person looking at it.
What decides which details get noticed
The first thing is who the person is. People notice what they know about: a nurse sees how someone is breathing, and a builder sees the crack over the window. People also notice what they need. A character who is running late sees the clock before the wallpaper.
- What they knowA nurse sees how someone is breathing
- What they needRunning late, they see the clock first
- Their moodA lit window: a welcome, or somebody watching
The second thing is mood. The same person sees the same street differently on the day they are hired and the day they are fired. Mood decides which details stand out and what they get compared to. A lit window at night can look like a welcome, or like somebody watching.
You do not have to state the trade or the mood. If the details are well chosen, the reader can work both out.
Example
A father visits
A retired carpenter sees his daughter’s first flat. Nothing in the passage gives his trade or says how he feels.
Walter Halewood stood in his daughter’s hallway with his coat still on. The front door had closed behind him with a click and then a second, smaller click, which meant the latch plate sat a hair too deep1. Somebody had painted over the hinges.
“Kitchen’s through here,” Yvonne called.
He followed her voice. The floor was the kind that came in packs and snapped together, and whoever laid it had left no gap at the wall, so by August it would lift2. He stepped over the place where it would lift. In the kitchen the cupboard doors hung level, which he had not expected, and he ran a thumb down the edge of the nearest one before he could stop himself3.
“Dad. Sit down.”
There was one chair.4 It was new, and it had her coat over the back of it.
- “a click and then a second, smaller click, which meant the latch pl…”Most visitors would hear a door shut. He hears a fitting that was set wrong. The detail tells us about the door and about his ear.
- “so by August it would lift”He sees the floor as it will be, not only as it is. Knowledge shows in what a person expects as well as in what they see.
- “he ran a thumb down the edge of the nearest one before he could st…”Here is the mood. He is trying not to inspect his daughter’s home, and he cannot help it.
- “There was one chair.”The last thing he notices has nothing to do with carpentry. One chair, with her coat on it: she lives alone here, and there is no obvious place for him.
Before and after
One schoolroom, described twice
The one faultThe room is described as anyone would see it, so nothing in the description belongs to the governess who has just walked in.
The housekeeper left her at the door. The schoolroom was on the second floor at the back of the house. It had two tall windows that faced north, and green paper on the walls. A long table stood in the middle, marked with ink, and there were four chairs round it. On one side was a fireplace, and the grate was laid but not lit. A shelf held a globe, a row of grammars and a row of adventure stories. A rocking horse stood in the corner, facing the wall. Miss Ashworth took off her gloves.
The first version is clear and tidy, and you could draw the room from it. But the housekeeper, a visitor or a child could each have given the same account. Miss Ashworth is in the doorway and the description passes straight by her.
The second version keeps the same room and nearly all the same objects. The change is that each one is now seen by a woman who has to work here and is not sure of her footing. North windows mean short afternoons. Four chairs do not match the three pupils in her letter. An unlit grate is a question about what she is allowed to ask for. The books tell her how much the children have been taught. Two things have gone, the globe and the wallpaper, because she has no reason to stop on them. No sentence says she is uneasy, and none needs to.
A test you can run
Take a description from your own pages and imagine handing it to a different character in the story. If you would not need to change a word, the description belongs to nobody yet.
Whose description is it?
- Hand it overTo another character in the story
- Ask three questionsWhat do they know, want and feel?
- Swap a few detailsTwo or three only this person would pick
Ask three things about the person who is looking. What do they know about? What do they want in this scene? How do they feel as they walk in? Then swap two or three details for ones that only this person would pick.
The exception
When to break it
Not every story is told from inside one head. A narrator who stands above the characters can describe a valley or a city in a voice of their own, and many well-loved books open that way. In that case the description shows us the narrator, and that is a choice as well.
Other ways to describe
Some moments call for a plain account. If the reader needs to understand how a room is laid out for a fight or a puzzle that follows, clarity matters more than colour. A description bent too far towards one person’s concerns can leave the reader unable to say where the door is.
A viewpoint character need not be an expert, either. Someone walking into a place far outside their experience will see it vaguely and may get things wrong, and that vagueness is true to them. The version to watch for is the one with no observer at all, where the narration lists what a camera would record and nobody in particular is looking.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Whose harbour?
Four sentences describe the same harbour. Which one describes it as one particular person would notice it?
Key takeaway
A place on the page is somebody’s view of it. Choose the details this character would notice, given what they know, what they want and how they feel today, and the same few lines will show the reader the place and the person.
