The white room
Every time a scene begins, the reader arrives with nothing. They do not know where they are, what time it is or who is in the room. You know all of it, because you can see the scene in your head, and that is why it is so easy to forget to say.
When a scene gives no place
When a scene gives no place, readers do one of two things. Some picture nothing: voices in a blank space, which writing workshops sometimes call a white room. Others invent a place of their own, and are thrown when the story contradicts it ten lines later. A reader who has put two people in a kitchen does not enjoy learning that they were in a rowing boat.
The cure is called grounding. It means giving the reader, early in the scene, just enough to stand somewhere.
Three anchors, two senses
The reader needs three things: where this is, roughly when (the time of day, or how long it has been since the last scene), and who is present. A sentence or two will usually carry all three.
Grounding in seven words
The night2 bus1 smelled of wet coats3.
- A placeThe bus
- A time of dayNight
- The weather, by smellA sense other than sight
The quickest way to deliver them is through the senses. A place name tells the reader where they are. A sound or a smell lets them feel that they are there. “The night bus smelled of wet coats” gives a place, a time of day and the weather in seven words. Aim for two senses in the opening lines, and let one of them be something other than sight.
Be choosy. Grounding is not a list of everything in the room. A reader can build a whole place from two or three well-picked details, and a long list only makes them wait for the scene to start.
Example
Grounded in three sentences
A detective meets a man who may know something. Look at how much you know by the end of the first paragraph, before anyone speaks.
By six in the morning the fish market was nearly done.1 The ice had gone grey underfoot, and the gulls had come down off the roof to argue2 over whatever the hoses pushed out. Sergeant Rukhsana Tench stood under the awning of the last open stall3 with her hands in her pockets, breathing through her mouth4.
“You’re late,” the stallholder said. He did not look up from the knife.
“You said after the rush.”
“I said before the cleaners.” He nodded past her. Two men in yellow boots were working down the aisle with a hose, and the water was already running pink round her shoes5.
- “By six in the morning the fish market was nearly done.”When and where, in the first eleven words. “Nearly done” adds what stage the place is at.
- “the gulls had come down off the roof to argue”Sound, without the word “noise”. The reader supplies the racket.
- “Sergeant Rukhsana Tench stood under the awning of the last open stall”Who is here, and exactly where she is standing. The market is no longer a backdrop; someone is in it.
- “breathing through her mouth”The smell, given by what she does about it. The passage never says the market stinks.
- “the water was already running pink round her shoes”A fresh touch of place in the middle of the talk. It keeps the two speakers from turning into voices.
Ground again when you move
Grounding is not a job done once a chapter. Each time the story jumps to a new place or a new time, the reader is back at nothing and needs a fresh anchor. One line is often enough.
Every move resets the reader
- The story movesA new place or time, and the reader is back at nothing
- A fresh anchorOne line is often enough
- Touches in long talkA cup, a draught, a look at the clock
Long conversations need a touch of place now and then as well: a cup, a draught from the door, a look at the clock. Without one, the people fade into talking heads.
Before and after
The same talk, in a room and out of one
The one faultThe scene has no place or time: two people talk and a bell changes hands, but the reader cannot tell where they are or what hour it is until a bus is mentioned.
“You kept it,” Sorcha said.
“I keep everything. You know that.”
“Not everything.”
Bruno laughed, but not for long. “No. Not everything.” He held the bell out to her. “Go on. It’s yours, really.”
She took it and turned it over. Her initials were still scratched inside the dome, with the year of the first summer.
“I should go,” she said. “The last bus is at nine.”
“It’s ten to.”
“Then I should certainly go.”
“Or you have ten minutes,” he said, “and I have a kettle.”
Nothing is wrong with the dialogue in the first version. The two people are distinct and the bell matters to them. But the reader has to hold the whole exchange in mid-air. Are they in a house, a street, a station? Is it day or night?
The second version changes no spoken word. It adds three things. An opening paragraph gives the place (a repair shop), the time (an hour after closing, raining) and where the bell has been. Bruno’s sleeve brings a smell. And the clock over the door ties the last bus to the room they are standing in. The opening paragraph does most of the work in three sentences, and the other two touches are a few words each.
The exception
When to break it
“Early” does not mean “first”. Plenty of good scenes open on a line of speech or a sudden action and give the anchor in the second or third line. What tends to lose the reader is half a page with no place at all.
The anchor can wait or shrink
Sometimes the reader should be lost. A character who wakes in the dark, or comes round after a blow, does not know where they are, and a scene that keeps the place back for a few lines lets the reader share that. It works because the character is as blank as the reader is.
A scene that returns to a place the reader knows well needs very little: “back in the kitchen” may be all of it. And when the pace is fast, one touch is plenty. A chase is no moment to describe the wallpaper.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which opening grounds you?
Each of these is the first line of a scene. Which one tells you where you are, roughly when, and who is there?
Key takeaway
At the start of every scene, and again after every jump in place or time, tell the reader where, when and who within the first few lines. Do it with two or three chosen sense details and not a list, then get on with the scene.
