Lesson 7 of 11
The Stage · stone 7Intermediate6 minute read

Stimulus and response order

Cause before effect; within a response, feeling, then reflex, then deliberate action and speech.

Reviewed by BlurbBio editorial team, 2026-11-11

The Stage: an open-air stone amphitheatre above the sea, with two figures mid-scene.
The Stage · Scene craft, stone 7 of 11

The reader gets things in the order you give them

Keiko flinched as the kettle shrieked.

First something the reader can see or hear for themselves, then the character’s response to it.

In conversation nobody would blink at that sentence. On the page it does something odd. The reader sees a woman flinch, at nothing, and half a second later is handed the reason and has to go back and attach it. The flinch came first in the sentence, though it came second in the kitchen.

One such sentence does no harm. A page of them, in a fight or a chase, leaves the reader half a beat behind throughout.

The repair is an order. First the stimulus: something outside the character that the reader can see or hear for themselves. Then the response. The kettle shrieked. Keiko flinched. The pairing is usually credited to Dwight V. Swain, whose scene and sequel the earlier lessons drew on, and is often taught under his label, the motivation-reaction unit.

Inside the response

The response has an order of its own, and it follows how a body works.

You seldom need every stage, but whichever you keep, keep them in this order.

Feeling comes first, because nobody chooses it: the drop in the stomach, the heat in the face. Then reflex, which is nearly as quick: the flinch, the step back, the hand that goes to the rail. Then what the character decides to do. Speech usually comes last, since saying something sensible is about the slowest thing a startled person can manage.

You seldom need all of these. Most responses on the page are one or two of them. The order matters more than the completeness: whichever parts you keep, keep them in sequence. A character who says a full, reasonable sentence and then jumps looks like a puppet with a slow string.

In a draft, the reversals hide in a few constructions. “As” and “when” pretend that two things happened at once, and tend to put the response first. “After” and “before” report events in the wrong order on purpose. An opening participle (“Pulling on her boots, she ran down the stairs”) claims two actions at the same moment that cannot be. And sometimes the cause is simply missing: she gasped, and we find out why in the next paragraph.

Example

Three rounds in a stairwell

A woman is walking down a multi-storey car park at night. Three things happen to her, and she responds three times. Watch what order each response comes in, and how much shorter the third one is.

Level fourthriller

The stairwell light went out.1

Nasrin’s stomach dropped.2 She stopped with one foot on the next step, and her hand closed on the rail3. Two floors down, a door opened and did not close.4

Cold went up the back of her neck. She slid her keys out of her pocket and folded them into her fist, one key between each finger, the way her brother had shown her when she was fourteen and she had laughed at him. “Hello?” she said. “Is somebody fixing the lights?”5

Nobody answered. A shoe scuffed on concrete, nearer than the door had been.

She went up.6 She took the stairs two at a time, on her toes, and did not let herself breathe out until she had the fire door in both hands.

  1. “The stairwell light went out.”The stimulus, in a paragraph of its own. The reader is in the dark before Nasrin has done anything.
  2. “Nasrin’s stomach dropped.”Feeling first. She has not chosen this and could not have stopped it.
  3. “her hand closed on the rail”Reflex. The wording gives the hand the verb, which is how a reflex feels from inside.
  4. “Two floors down, a door opened and did not close.”A second stimulus. It ends the paragraph, so the response to it gets a fresh start.
  5. ““Hello?” she said. “Is somebody fixing the lights?””Speech arrives last in the second response, after the cold on her neck and the business with the keys. By now she is thinking.
  6. “She went up.”The third response skips feeling and reflex and goes straight to the decision. The reader supplies the fear. Leaving stages out is how the pattern speeds up.

Before and after

The same visit, in two orders

The one faultReactions are placed before the things that cause them.

Weaker versionHer own mark (first version)

Bronwen’s shoulders tightened as the bell over the forge door rang and a man in the Duke’s grey came in out of the rain. “We’re closed for the feast day,” she said, after setting the tongs down on the anvil and wiping her hands on her apron.

Heat rose in her face when he held out a sword hilt-first, because her own mark was stamped below the guard and the blade had snapped a hand’s width above it. “I didn’t forge this,” she said. “Someone has put my mark on it.” Her breath had gone out of her a moment before, when she took the hilt and turned the break to the light and found the steel inside grey and grainy as old bread.

He put a folded paper on the anvil after saying, “The Duke’s son was holding it when it broke.”

She did not pick the paper up.

Showing the weaker version.

The events, the spoken lines and almost all the words are the same in both versions. Only the order has changed.

In the first version Bronwen’s shoulders tighten before the bell has rung, she speaks before we are told she has put down the tongs, and she denies forging the sword before she has looked at the break. Each time the reader gets a reaction and has to wait for its cause. The words doing it are small: as, after, when, because, and one “had gone” that sends us back a moment in time.

In the second version each cause has its own sentence and comes first. The visitor’s line about the Duke’s son now lands before the paper does, which is the order in which she would have dreaded them.

The exception

When to break it

Putting the response first is a real technique when you do it on purpose. “She stopped. On the step, where nobody had left one, stood a second glass.” The stop makes the reader lean forward to find out why. It works when the gap is a sentence long and the device is rare.

Putting the response first works when it is deliberate and rare, and “as” is honest when two things truly overlap.

A narrator looking back can report the response first because that is how it was lived: “I was across the road before I understood what I had seen.” Shock bends the order as well. A person may act at once and feel nothing until the evening, and the earlier lesson on sequels covers that delay.

“As” is the honest word when two things truly overlap and both go on for a while: he talked as he drove. The trouble is only with “as” joining a sudden cause to its effect.

And the order belongs to scene, where time runs moment by moment. Summary has no moment to protect.

The opposite risk is real too. A page in which every response marches through feeling, reflex, action and speech is correct and dead. Vary how many stages you show.

Check yourself

Quick checkabout 1 min

Cause first

A gate bangs in the night and Dario, alone in the house, reacts. Which version gives the reader the cause before the response?

Key takeaway

In a scene, give the reader the cause before the effect: first what happened, then what it did to the character. Within the response, let the unchosen things (feeling, reflex) come before the chosen ones (action, speech), and show only as many of them as the moment needs. When you reverse the order, do it because the delay buys something.

Practise

Exercises for this lesson

One is open to try now. The rest are free with an account.

Apply

One page of your fastest scene

On one page of fast action from your own draft, find each place where a response reaches the reader before its cause, decide whether the reversal is deliberate, and repair the ones that are not.

Use it on your own book

With a free account you can work through this on a passage of your own and keep the result.