What the reader does not know at a scene break
The lesson on arriving late was about where a scene should begin and stop. This one is about the sentences that stand at those two points, and what each has to carry.
Who, where and when
By the third night3 on the ferry2, Lorna1 had stopped pretending to sleep.
- WhoLorna, and it is her scene
- WhereOn the ferry
- WhenMeasured from the scene before
A reader who crosses a scene break arrives knowing nothing about the far side. An hour may have passed, or a year. In a book with more than one viewpoint, they do not know whose head they are in.
So the opening lines have a first job, which is to orient. Three things: who is here (and whose scene it is), where, and when, measured from the scene before. A workable target is to have all three on the page within about three sentences.
This need not cost a paragraph of setting. Orientation folds into action: “By the third night on the ferry, Lorna had stopped pretending to sleep.” One sentence, and the reader has a person, a place and a time, with room left over for the second job.
A reason at the top, a pull at the bottom
The second job of an opening is to give the reader a reason to go on: something wanted, something slightly wrong, a small question. In the ferry sentence it is the word “pretending”. A reason can be quiet. What it cannot be is absent while the scene clears its throat.
Three habits that weaken a last line
The two jobs compete, so most strong openings are a trade: orient with the fewest words that will do it, and make one of those words carry the question.
At the other end, the last line is the one the reader holds while deciding whether to go on. The lesson on chapter breaks names what tends to carry them over: a question, a decision not yet acted on, a fact that changes things. At the level of the sentence, three habits weaken any of these. The scene runs one beat past its strongest line. The narrator explains what the line meant. Or the last sentence buries its key word in the middle, when the end of a sentence is where the weight tends to fall.
Example
Both edges of a short scene
A whole scene in five short paragraphs. Read the first sentence for who, where and when, and then look at the word the scene stops on.
Three days after the funeral, Cecily went down to the mill office to ask for her husband’s last wages.1 The paymaster kept her standing at the counter while he finished a column of figures, and she let him, because she had nowhere else to be2.
“Paid up to the Friday,” he said at last. “Collected the same afternoon.”
“He was in bed on the Friday. He couldn’t lift a cup.”
“Then he sent somebody.” He turned the wages book round and put his finger beside the entry. “Signed for. There.”
She bent over the book.3 It was her husband’s name, every letter of it. It was not her husband’s hand.4
- “Three days after the funeral, Cecily went down to the mill office…”When, who and where in one sentence, and what she has come for. “The funeral” and “last wages” also tell us whose funeral without a sentence of backstory.
- “because she had nowhere else to be”The reason to read on is quiet here. It is a clause about her state, and it makes the reader want something to go right for her.
- “She bent over the book.”A short sentence of action that slows the moment just before the last line and puts our eyes where hers are.
- “It was not her husband’s hand.”The scene stops on the new fact, and on the word that carries it. Cecily does not gasp, speak or draw a conclusion; that is left to the reader.
Before and after
The same scene with two first paragraphs
The one faultThe opening paragraph does not say who is here, where they are or when it is.
It was not going to work. That much had been obvious from the start, and it was more obvious now, with everything laid out and nowhere left to put any of it. There had to be another way of looking at it. There usually was. But the longer the thing sat there, the less it seemed like a problem and the more it seemed like an answer nobody wanted.
“You’ve been staring at that for an hour, Anika,” Rhys said from the doorway. He had his tie in his pocket and two mugs in one hand.
“Your mother can’t sit with your father. Your father can’t sit with his sister. Nobody can sit with Uncle Ivo.”
“Put me next to Ivo.”
“You’re at the top table. You’re the groom’s brother.”
“And you’re the bride’s best friend. Same table.” He put a mug down by her knee and took the two cards she was holding apart, his name and hers. He looked at them a little too long before he set them down, side by side.
From the first line of speech onward the two versions are word for word the same, and they end on the same gesture. Only the opening paragraph differs.
The first version’s opening has a voice and a hint of trouble. But for five sentences the reader is holding a mood with nobody to attach it to and nothing to look at: “it”, “everything”, “the thing”. A name arrives in the second paragraph. The place and the night are never stated, and have to be pieced together from the talk of tables.
The second version spends one sentence on the same work: the time, the person, the room, the cards, and the fact that the plan will not come out. It then keeps the best of the brooding, which now has an owner.
The exception
When to break it
Three sentences is a guide for revision, not a count to enforce. A book with one viewpoint and one setting needs far less: “Next morning” may be all the orientation a scene requires.
When the edges bend
A scene can open on a line of speech, or on a wide view with nobody in it, as long as the missing piece arrives in the next sentence or two. And an opening can disorient on purpose when the character is disoriented too: someone coming round in a strange room. There the confusion is the orientation, because the reader knows whose it is.
Withholding who is present can be the design of a scene in a mystery or a thriller, as a rare effect the reader can tell is deliberate.
Endings bend as well. A reflective first-person narrator may comment on what just happened because the commentary is the voice. A scene of rest after a hard stretch may close fully. And if every scene ends on a sharp last line, the sharpness stops being felt.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Oriented, and still curious
Each of these is the first line of a scene in the middle of a novel. Which one tells the reader who, where and when, and also gives a reason to read the next line?
Key takeaway
At the top of a scene, tell the reader who, where and when within about three sentences, and let one of those words raise a question. At the bottom, stop on the line that leaves something open, with its key word at the end, and do not explain it.
