What happens after the door slams
A character is turned down for the loan. In the next paragraph she is at the pawnshop with her mother’s ring. Something has been skipped, and a reader can feel it. How did the refusal hit her? What else did she think of? Why the ring, which she swore she would keep?
After the scene, its sequel
- ReactionFeeling before thought: the hands, the breath, the walk round the block
- Dilemma“What now?” None of the choices is good
- DecisionShe picks one: the pawnshop, with her mother’s ring
The decision is the next scene’s goal
Dwight V. Swain, in Techniques of the Selling Writer, gave the missing piece a name. After a scene comes its sequel: the stretch in which a character takes in what has just happened and works out what to do next. He divided it into three steps.
Reaction. The blow lands. This is feeling before thought, and it tends to show in the body and in behaviour first: the hands, the breath, the walk twice round the block.
Dilemma. The feeling settles into a question, which is “what now?” The character looks at what is open to them. If the scene before ended badly enough, none of the choices is good.
Decision. The character picks one. That choice is the goal of the next scene.
Why it is worth the space
The sequel is where a reader finds out what an event meant. Two people can lose the same job and one will be relieved. Until we see the reaction, the event is only a fact.
How long a sequel runs
- In a chaseShort sequels keep a book running
- In a novel of mannersLong sequels let it breathe
It is also where motive is made. A decision reached in front of us, with the costs counted, is one we will follow the character into. A decision that simply appears can look like the author moving a piece on a board.
And it controls pace. A sequel can be a single line in a chase and several pages in a novel of manners. Long sequels slow a book down and let it breathe. Short ones keep it running. If your draft feels breathless, the sequels may be missing. If it feels stuck in a character’s head, they may be too long, or circling the dilemma without arriving at a choice.
A sequel does not have to be a person alone with their thoughts. The dilemma can be talked through with a friend, or argued over with an enemy.
Example
Nine to two
A councillor on an orbital station has just lost a vote. The scene itself is over in the first sentence. Everything after it is sequel.
The council voted nine to two, and the two were Halima and a man who had fallen asleep.
She walked the ring corridor twice round without seeing it. Her hands would not stay in her pockets.1 Nine. People she had fed at her own table.2
So. The pumps would be shut off at the end of the month, and the lower farms would go dry with them. She could appeal, and the appeal would be heard by the same nine.3 She could go to the growers tonight and tell them, and by morning there would be a crowd outside the council door and no way to walk it back. Or she could say nothing, keep her seat, and be useful later.
She had never been much use later.4
At the next junction she turned down, towards the farms.5
- “She walked the ring corridor twice round without seeing it. Her ha…”Reaction, in the body. No feeling is named, and none needs to be.
- “Nine. People she had fed at her own table.”The reaction turning into thought. We learn what the vote means to her: it is personal.
- “She could appeal, and the appeal would be heard by the same nine.”The dilemma begins. Each of the three options comes with its cost attached, so none is easy.
- “She had never been much use later.”The hinge. She chooses for a reason that belongs to her, which is what makes a decision reveal character.
- “At the next junction she turned down, towards the farms.”The decision, shown as an action. We know the goal of the next scene without being told it.
Before and after
The same evening, with and without a choice
The one faultThe sequel stops at the dilemma. No decision is made.
The letter came back on the Tuesday with her own seal unbroken and a single word written across it in the steward’s hand: Refused.
Lavinia put it on the fire and then, absurdly, tried to get it out again, and burned two fingers. She sat on the floor of the still-room with her hand in the water bucket.
He would not see her, then. She could write again, and be refused again. She could go to the house herself and be turned away at the gate, where the whole village would hear of it by supper. Or she could go to his mother, who had never liked her, and who never refused anything that might prove interesting.
It was a great deal to think about. She dried her hand, banked the fire, and went up to bed.
Only the last paragraph differs. Both versions give Lavinia a sharp reaction, the burned fingers, and a real dilemma: three ways forward, each with a price.
In the first version she then goes to bed. The story has been brought to a stop, and it is not clear what will start it again. Whatever she does in the next chapter, we will not have seen her choose it.
In the second version she looks for her good gloves. She has chosen the third option, the mother, and she has chosen it without a word of explanation. The gloves and the Thursday tell us. The paragraph is shorter than the one it replaces, and the next scene now has somewhere to be.
The exception
When to break it
A full sequel after every scene would make a slow book. Several things can shrink or reshape it.
In the middle of a chase or a fight there is no time to weigh anything. The reaction is half a line and the decision is a reflex. The thinking, if it comes, comes after the danger.
When there is only one thing a character could possibly do, playing out the deliberation is padding. Go straight to the doing.
Sometimes you want the reader not to know what was decided. A heist story may do this: the plan is made out of our hearing, and the next scene shows it in action.
The order can bend. A person in shock may act first and feel it days later, and a delayed reaction can hit harder than a prompt one.
And some characters do not reflect. A narrator who goes from disaster to action without a pause is telling us something about themselves. That is a choice about character, and it works as long as it is one.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Find the decision
The bank has just refused Dora’s loan. Four sentences follow. Which one is the decision?
Key takeaway
After something goes wrong, let the character feel it, face the choices, and choose. The reaction tells us what the event meant, the dilemma shows what it will cost, and the decision gives the next scene its goal. Make it as long or as short as the pace needs, but get to the decision.
