A plus and a minus
Here is a quick way to test a scene, borrowed from the teaching of screenwriting. Take a pencil. Next to the first paragraph write a plus or a minus. Next to the last paragraph do the same. If the two marks match, look again at what the scene is doing.
The pencil test
- − at the startAlone in a new city for a year
- The turnShe is asked to the neighbours’ table
- + at the endAlone becomes together
The marks stand for the state of a value. A value, in this sense, is something a character has at stake that can be in better or worse condition. It is easiest to name as a pair of opposites: safe and in danger, trusted and doubted, together and alone, free and trapped, hopeful and defeated, in the dark and in the know.
In a scene that turns, the value opens in one state, something happens, and the value closes in another. That movement is the value shift, and the moment where it flips is called the turn.
The shift can go either way. A woman who has been alone in a new city for a year is asked to the neighbours’ table: minus to plus. A convoy reaches the pass in good order and finds the bridge gone: plus to minus. Things can also go from bad to worse, or from good to better. The pencil mark is then the same at both ends, but the state is not, and that still counts as a shift.
Why the direction matters
A change in someone’s fortunes is one of the main things a reader feels as movement. A scene can be full of activity and still read as flat if, when it ends, everyone is exactly as safe, as loved or as lost as they were when it began.
Mark a run of scenes
The value does not need to be large. In a school story it might be a girl’s standing with three friends. What matters is that we know it is at stake and can see which way it went.
Direction gives a book its rhythm as well. Mark a run of your scenes and look at the pattern. If six in a row go from plus to minus, the story is a long slide, and the sixth blow will land more softly than the first. A turn upward makes the next fall hurt again.
To use the tool, ask three things of a scene. What is at stake here, in two words? Where does it stand at the start, and at the end? And can I put my finger on the line where it turned?
Example
Second from the bottom
A girl has been trying for a place on the school team all term. Decide what the value is, and where it turns.
The team sheet went up outside the gym at four, and by five past Jody had read it eleven times. Her name was there.1 Second from the bottom, but there.
She took a photo of it. She took another, with her thumb in.2
“Reserve,” said Coach Baptiste, behind her. “You saw that it says reserve.”
“It says my name.”
“It does.” He pulled a pen from behind his ear. “And if Niamh’s ankle is still bad on Saturday, you start. So I need to know now, not Saturday.” He tapped the sheet. “Your mother told the office you’re away that weekend. At your dad’s.”3
Jody looked at the two photos on her phone.
“I can change it,” she said, and did not know yet whether that was true4.
- “Her name was there.”The opening state, and it is a plus. The value is her place on the team: in or out. She is in.
- “She took another, with her thumb in.”A small action that shows how much the plus means to her. The higher the opening state, the further there is to fall.
- ““Your mother told the office you’re away that weekend. At your dad’s.””The turn. After this line the scene cannot go back to how it was. Her place now depends on something she does not control.
- “did not know yet whether that was true”The closing state: her place is in doubt. It is not a full minus, and it does not need to be. It is plainly different from where she began.
Before and after
A morning in hiding, twice
The one faultThe scene ends on the same value it began with.
Ilan checked the street from the bathroom window, the only one that faced the road. A bakery van. A woman walking two dogs. The same grey sky.
He checked the door: both bolts, the chain. He checked the phone. One bar, no messages. The rule was that no message meant stay put.
He made coffee and drank it standing, away from the windows. At noon he checked the street again. The bakery van had gone. A boy on a bicycle went past and did not look up.
No message. He rinsed the cup, dried it, and put it back exactly where he had found it.
The value here is easy to name: safe or exposed. Both versions open with Ilan safe, and nervous about it.
In the first version he is still safe at the end. The checks are well observed, and the detail of the cup put back exactly is a good one. But the plus at the top is a plus at the bottom. We have learned his routine and nothing has happened to it.
The second version is the same until the end of the third paragraph, where the boy on the bicycle looks up. That is the turn. The photograph confirms it. By the last line he is exposed, and the cup he does not rinse tells us he knows. Every careful check in the opening now counts for more, because we have watched it fail.
The exception
When to break it
A plus and a minus are a crude instrument, and it is worth knowing where they stop being useful.
Where the marks stop helping
Many good scenes end mixed. A character gets the job and loses the friend who wanted it. Do not force such a scene into one mark. The test is that the end is different from the start, not that it is the opposite.
Some scenes hold a value still on purpose. In a story about someone who is stuck, in a marriage, a town or a war of waiting, a scene where nothing moves can be the point, and the reader is meant to feel the weight of it. That effect is strong in small doses and wears off quickly.
A scene can also turn a value for the reader alone. The characters go home content, and we have seen the letter under the mat.
Last, do not plot by alternation. A book that goes up, down, up, down in strict order becomes as predictable as one that only goes down. The marks are for finding flat scenes in revision. They are a poor way to design a story.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which scene turns?
Four scenes in outline. In which one does the value at the end differ from the value at the start?
Key takeaway
Name what is at stake in a scene as a pair of opposites, and mark where it stands at the start and at the end. If the marks differ, find the line where it turned and make sure the reader is there to see it. If they match, the scene may be describing a situation without changing it.
