Two speeds
Fiction runs at two speeds, and a writer changes between them all the time, often without noticing.
Two speeds
In scene, the story moves at about the pace of life. We are in one place at one time. People speak and we hear the words. A hand goes to a pocket and we see it go. Reading the moment takes roughly as long as living it would.
In summary, the narrator steps back and compresses. “For three weeks she wrote to him every day and got nothing back.” Twenty-one days, twenty-one letters, thirteen words.
Neither speed is better. Summary is how a novel covers a war, a childhood or a dull week without running to ten thousand pages. Scene is how it makes a reader feel that something is happening to them. The skill is in the choice: which moments get played out, and which get told.
Choosing what to play out
A workable guide is this. Play out the moments where something changes, is decided, or is found out: the moments a reader would feel cheated to hear about second-hand. Compress the time that only has to pass: journeys, routines, the eleven attempts that went the same way as the first.
Which moments to play out
- Journeys, routinesTime that only has to pass
- Eleven tries, all the sameCompressed, with a detail or two to keep it alive
- Changed, decided, found outA reader would feel cheated to hear it second-hand
Drafts tend to go wrong in two directions. In one, the big moment is summarised. “They argued bitterly, and by morning she had gone” gives away, in a single line, the scene the whole chapter was building towards. In the other, routine is played out: a page of waking, dressing and driving before anything is at stake.
Good summary is not vague. It keeps one or two particular details, so that the reader can see something while the weeks go by.
The change from one speed to the other is usually marked by a small signal: a particular day, a particular hour, the first line anyone speaks aloud. After that signal the reader slows down with you.
Example
Changing speed
A winter of piano lessons, and then one of them. Notice where the clock slows.
All that winter Ottoline took the bus across the river on Wednesdays1 and sat for forty minutes at Madame Lavigne’s upright, getting the same eight bars wrong2. Madame Lavigne ate peppermints and looked out of the window. Neither of them mentioned the examination.
On the first Wednesday in March the piano lid was closed.3
“Sit,” said Madame Lavigne.4 “Not there. Here, by me.”
Ottoline sat on the sofa. It was the first time she had seen the room from that side.
“Your father telephoned. He would like to know if he is wasting his money.” Madame Lavigne unwrapped a peppermint and did not eat it. “I told him I would ask you.”5
- “All that winter Ottoline took the bus across the river on Wednesdays”Summary. Three months of Wednesdays in a sentence. “All that winter” tells us we are moving fast.
- “getting the same eight bars wrong”Summary can still be particular. One exact detail stands for every lesson.
- “On the first Wednesday in March the piano lid was closed.”The change of speed. One named day, and one thing that is different on it.
- ““Sit,” said Madame Lavigne.”Speech. From here we are in the room, in real time.
- ““I told him I would ask you.””This is why this Wednesday gets a scene and the others did not. Something is about to be decided.
Before and after
Told, then played
The one faultThe one moment the reader came for is told in summary.
The Brodies had been in the house for nine days before Bridie counted the attic stairs. There were eleven going up. She fetched the blanket her mother wanted, turned round at the top, and started back down.
On the way down she found that there were now more steps than there had been, and she became very frightened, and it was some time before she managed to reach the landing.
Her mother took the blanket and asked what had kept her.
The two versions share their first paragraph and their last line. Both use summary well at the start: nine days in the house go by in a clause, because nothing happened in them.
The difference is the way down. The first version reports it. We are told that there were more steps, that she was very frightened, and that it took some time. All three facts are true, and none of them is frightening, because we were not on the stairs.
The second version slows to the pace of her feet. We count with her and arrive at twelve with her. The fear is not named anywhere. It is in the damp wood and in the light that does not get any nearer. The mother’s ordinary question lands harder too, because now we know what it is a question about.
The exception
When to break it
There are good reasons to summarise a moment that matters.
The reader may have seen it already. When a character tells a friend about events we watched in chapter three, “She told him everything” is enough.
The aftermath may matter more than the event. Many writers keep a death or an act of violence off the page and open on the morning after, so that the weight falls on what it did to people.
Understatement can be the point. A calamity reported in one dry sentence is an old comic device, and a chilling one in the right hands.
And some whole modes of storytelling live mostly in summary: the fairy tale, the saga, the novel told by a strong narrating voice that is itself the pleasure.
The reverse holds as well. A routine can be played out in full once, so that the reader knows what normal looks like before it breaks. A horror story can do this, and let the dread build in the ordinary.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which one is summary?
Three of these are moments from a scene. One is summary. Which?
Key takeaway
Scene slows the story to the pace of life; summary compresses it. Spend your scenes on the moments where something changes, and use summary, with a detail or two to keep it alive, for the time that only has to pass. When you are unsure, ask which part a reader would be sorry to have missed.
