One sentence to finish
Take any scene in your draft and try to finish this sentence: “By the end of this scene, something is different, and it is…”
“By the end, something is different…”
If you can finish it, the scene has a purpose. If all you can say is what the scene is about, it has a topic. The two are easy to confuse. “This scene is about Verity’s marriage” names a topic. “Verity finds the second phone and stops believing him” names a change. A topic says what a scene contains. A purpose says what it does.
The change can be of three kinds, and a strong scene often manages more than one.
The situation changes: someone gains or loses something, a door closes, a secret gets out.
A character or a relationship changes: a decision is made, trust is given or withdrawn.
What the reader knows changes: we learn something that alters how we read everything after it, even if nobody in the story has learned it yet.
Why a scene without a change feels slow
Someone reading a story keeps a rough tally of where things stand: who wants what, who knows what, how much danger everyone is in. Each scene is a chance to move that tally. When a scene ends and the tally is untouched, the reader may feel they have been kept waiting, even if every sentence was good.
A purpose line
- At the start, thisVerity believes him
- By the end, thatShe stops believing him
- Because this happensShe finds the second phone
These are often the scenes a writer is fondest of: the one that shows the friendship, the one that sets the mood, the one with the best jokes. All of that is worth having. The fix is seldom to throw it out. More often it is to find the scene where something does change and let the friendship, the mood and the jokes happen there.
A useful form for a purpose line is: at the start, this; by the end, that; because this happens. If the middle of the line is empty, you have three choices. Cut the scene. Fold its best material into a neighbour. Or find the change the scene was reaching for and put it on the page.
Example
A scene that earns its place
A printing shop, some time before machines set type. As you read, work out what is different by the last line.
Mistress Arkwright counted the type herself that evening, case by case, and Gwilym held the lamp for her1.
“Forty-one of the small e,” she said. “There were sixty at midsummer.”2
“They wear, mistress. The soft ones crack.”
“Cracked type goes in the scrap box, and I melt the scrap box myself.” She shut the case. “I have melted eleven.”
Gwilym said nothing. The lamp was steady; he took some pride in that.
She went to the shelf above his cot and lifted down his Sunday boots. The left one rattled.3 She tipped it over the composing stone, and the little letters ran out across it like spilled barley.
“You may finish the week,” she said. “I will write to your father tonight.”4
- “Gwilym held the lamp for her”Where things stand at the start: he is the apprentice, trusted enough to help with the count.
- ““There were sixty at midsummer.””The question that drives the scene. Something is missing, and we wait to learn where it went.
- “The left one rattled.”The change, and we are in the room for it. It is caused by something a character does: she goes and looks.
- ““I will write to your father tonight.””Where things stand at the end. He has lost his place and his family will know why. The scene stops once that is settled.
Before and after
The same kitchen, twice
The one faultNothing is different at the end of the scene.
Dev chopped the onions badly, as he did every Sunday, and Kirsten took the knife away from him, as she did every Sunday.
“You hold it like a pen,” she said.
“I hold everything like a pen. I’m an accountant.”
She laughed and slid the onions into the pan. The window over the sink steamed up. He wrote her initial in the steam with one finger, then his own beside it.
“Wine?” he said.
“There’s the bottle your sister brought.”
He found it behind the cereal and poured two glasses. They ate at the counter, standing up, the way they liked to, and afterwards he washed and she dried.
The first version is pleasant to read. The couple are easy with each other and the details are particular. But try the sentence on it. By the end, what is different? Nothing. They began the scene fond of each other with dinner ahead of them, and they end it fond of each other with dinner behind them. A reader could skip from the scene before to the scene after and lose only the onions.
The second version keeps every line of the first up to the wine. Then he finds the letter. Now the purpose can be stated: at the start Dev believes they have no secrets; by the end he knows she has kept one for weeks. The Sunday routine has not been wasted. It has become the thing that is at risk.
The exception
When to break it
This is a test for revising with, not a law of fiction, and it is a poor thing to have in your head while drafting. Write the scene first. Ask what it changed afterwards.
The change does not have to be large. A scene after a disaster may exist mostly to let everyone breathe, and its change can be as small as a character deciding to eat something.
Some scenes earn their place in other ways. A comic set piece can stay because it is funny. In a cosy or slice-of-life novel, part of what the book offers is time in good company, and a scene of that alone can be right. The first pages of a later book in a series often re-establish people and places before anything turns. And a scene can leave every character exactly where they were while changing only what the reader knows. That one passes the test, though it may not look as if it does.
The risk is in numbers. One scene kept for pleasure is a gift. Five in a row is a book standing still.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Topic or change?
Four writers describe what a scene in their draft is for. Which of them has named a change?
Key takeaway
A scene’s purpose is what is different by its last line: in the situation, in a person or a relationship, or in what the reader knows. Say it in one sentence, as a change. If the sentence will only come out as a topic, the scene is not finished yet.
