A question, a struggle, an answer
A scene with no goal is hard to follow for a simple reason: the reader does not know what would count as winning. People talk, things happen, and there is nothing to hope for or dread.
A question, a struggle, an answer
- GoalTo get her sister to sign before the lawyer leaves
- ConflictSomething pushes back, more than once
- DisasterAn answer worse than she hoped for
Dwight V. Swain, in Techniques of the Selling Writer, built the scene out of three parts to solve exactly that. He called them goal, conflict and disaster.
The goal is what the character wants out of this scene, now. It is small and concrete: the key, a yes, a way out of the building without being seen. “To be happy” is a wish. “To get her sister to sign before the lawyer leaves” is a goal, because by the end of the scene we will know whether she got it.
The conflict is whatever stands in the way, and the tries the character makes to get past it. It need not be a quarrel. It can be a locked drawer, a clock, a rule, or the character’s own nerve. What matters is that it pushes back more than once.
The disaster is the answer to the question the goal raised, and it is a worse answer than the character hoped for.
What “disaster” really means
Swain’s word is stronger than the thing it names. Nobody has to die. In a quiet novel the disaster may be a remark that lands badly at a dinner.
Did they get it?
It helps to think of four possible answers to “did they get it?” A plain yes ends the matter, and often takes the reason to read on with it. A plain no blocks the character but changes little. The two that do most to drive a story are the mixed ones: yes, but there is a catch; and no, and furthermore things are now worse than before the character asked.
The mixed answers work because they hand the character a new problem, and the new problem becomes the goal of a later scene. This is how a plot comes to feel like a chain and not a list.
To use the pattern, check three things in a draft scene. Can you point to the line where we learn what the character wants? Does something resist, and does the character try again? Is the character somewhere new, and harder, at the end?
Example
Eight minutes
A woman needs a file from a public records room. Watch for the three parts, and for how early the first one arrives.
The records room closed at five. It was eight minutes to.
“File 2217,” Anneke said1, and slid the request slip under the glass. “Harbour Authority, the Kinross inspection.”
The clerk read the slip twice. “This wants a countersignature.”2
“It has one. Bottom left.”
“That is Mr Lyall’s signature. Mr Lyall retired in March.” He pushed the slip back to her.
She pushed it forward again, with a folded banknote on top of it3. “Then perhaps you could look at it as a favour.”
He considered the banknote for some time. Then he picked up the telephone, dialled two digits, and said, “Security to the second floor, please,”4 without taking his eyes off her.
It was four minutes to five.5
- ““File 2217,” Anneke said”The goal, in her first two words. From here on we know what winning looks like: she walks out with that file.
- ““This wants a countersignature.””The first push-back. The clerk is not a villain. He has a rule, and that is all a scene needs.
- “with a folded banknote on top of it”She tries again, and raises what she is risking. Conflict is this back and forth: a try, a refusal, a bolder try.
- ““Security to the second floor, please,””The disaster. This is “no, and furthermore”: she has no file, and now security is on its way up to her.
- “It was four minutes to five.”The clock that opened the scene closes it. Her next goal is already clear, and it is no longer the file.
Before and after
Two endings for one refusal
The one faultThe resistance simply gives way, so the character gets what she wanted at no cost.
Ysolde reached the ferry landing an hour after dark, with the fever-bark in her satchel and her mother’s cough still in her ears.
“I need to cross,” she said. “Tonight.”
The ferryman did not get up from his fire. “River’s in flood. I don’t cross in flood.”
“I can pay double.”
“Double of what a drowned man earns is nothing.”
“Then lend me the boat, and I will row myself.”
He looked at her arms and laughed. Then he poked the fire for a while. “Ah, well,” he said at last. “It’s not so high as it was this morning.” He fetched the pole, and they were across before the moon rose.
Both versions are the same for six paragraphs. Ysolde has a clear goal, the ferryman has a good reason to refuse, and she tries three times. The difference is all in the last lines.
In the first version the ferryman changes his mind. Nothing she did caused it, and nothing follows from it. The refusals turn out to have been a delay. She is across the river, exactly as she would have been if he had said yes at once.
In the second version she takes the boat. That is a yes with a heavy catch: she is on a flooded river at night with no pole, and she is now a thief. She got what she asked for, and she is far worse off than when she arrived. The next scene has its goal waiting.
The exception
When to break it
Goal, conflict, disaster is a pattern that suits a great many scenes. It does not suit all of them.
Some scenes are things that happen to a character: a telegram arrives, a stranger sits down opposite. There the character has no goal until the scene gives them one. Some are scenes of connection. In a romance, two people who have been at odds may finally talk, and the scene ends better than it began. A story needs those. If every scene ends in a setback, the reader stops believing that anything can go right, and the setbacks lose their force.
The size of the disaster should vary too. A book in which each scene ends at full volume is tiring. And near the end of a story the pattern turns over: the character begins to win, and the big scenes close on a yes that has been paid for.
Last, a goal can be hidden on purpose. In a mystery, or with a character who is lying to the reader, you may not want us to know what someone is after until the scene is over.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 2 min
Which part is missing?
Here is a scene in outline. “Cormac needs his sister to sign the sale papers today. She refuses. He pleads, and reminds her what they owe. She thinks it over, signs gladly, and they have tea.” Which of the three parts is missing?
Key takeaway
Give the character something to want from this scene, put something in the way that pushes back more than once, and end with an answer that is worse, or more complicated, than the one they hoped for. If you can point to all three on the page, the scene has a shape. If the ending hands the character a new problem, it also has a next scene.
