Five parts, one of them a choice
Shawn Coyne’s Story Grid method names five things that a working unit of story contains, and calls them the five commandments. Its own worked examples apply them to single scenes as well as to whole books. The Story Grid page lists them as inciting incident, turning point progressive complication, crisis, climax and resolution. This lesson takes the second apart into the complications and the turning point that ends them, because each does a different job. You have met most of the parts already under other names.
Five parts, one of them a choice
- Inciting incidentOff balance, and something to want
- ComplicationsTries that fail, up to the turning point
- CrisisA best bad choice, or irreconcilable goods
- ClimaxThe character acts on the choice
- ResolutionWhat the act costs or wins
The inciting incident knocks the scene’s main character off balance and gives them something to want.
Progressive complications are the tries that fail. The last of them is the turning point: the moment after which the character’s way of going about it will no longer work. The lesson on value shift called this the turn.
The crisis is a choice the turning point forces. It is a real one: between two things the character does not want, or between two things they want and cannot both have. Story Grid calls these the best bad choice and irreconcilable goods.
The climax is the character acting on the choice.
The resolution is what the act costs or wins.
The new idea here is the crisis. Goal, conflict and disaster can all happen to a character. A crisis cannot: it is the point where the outcome depends on what somebody decides.
What the crisis is for
Swain’s sequel puts the dilemma and the decision after the scene, as a stretch of reflection. The crisis puts a choice inside it, under pressure and in a few lines: the short version, taken with the clock running.
Tag the five in a flat scene
In revision, tag the five in a scene that feels flat though plenty happens. A scene with no turning point has complications that only repeat. A scene with no crisis has a main character who is carried along. A scene with no climax has its decision taken off the page.
For the crisis to work, the reader must be able to see both options and what each would cost before the character moves. One line each is enough. And the climax has to be an act: something said or done that cannot be taken back.
Example
All five in a cargo hold
A freighter captain is being inspected. Find the paragraph where she has to choose, and notice that you know both options before she moves.
The customs drone finished its sweep of the hold and stopped over crate nine.
“Thermal anomaly,” it said. “Open the crate, Captain.”1
Ebele had loaded crate nine herself: seed stock, sealed, cold. She held the manifest up to its lens. The drone did not look. She offered it the port fee twice over, in the tone that usually worked, and it logged the offer as a second offence2.
Then the crate knocked.3 Three slow knocks, from inside.
She could open it.4 The drone would take whoever was in there, and she would keep her licence and never learn who had knocked. Or she could blow the clamps and run, with customs behind her, a stranger in her hold and no port that would have her.
The crate knocked again, once.
Ebele put her hand on the release and blew the clamps.5
The drone was still reciting her offences when the bay doors shut on it. In the quiet she picked up a pry bar and went aft to see what she had just ruined herself for6.
- ““Open the crate, Captain.””Inciting incident. A routine sweep has become a problem, and she now has a goal: get the drone off crate nine.
- “it logged the offer as a second offence”Progressive complications. She tries the manifest, then a bribe. Each try fails, and the second makes things worse.
- “Then the crate knocked.”The turning point. Talking her way out assumed the crate held seed. That approach is finished.
- “She could open it.”The crisis begins. Both options are laid out with their costs: her licence kept and a stranger handed over, or the stranger kept and everything else lost. Neither is good, so this is a best bad choice.
- “Ebele put her hand on the release and blew the clamps.”The climax: one sentence, an act, and no way back from it. We see what she does.
- “to see what she had just ruined herself for”The resolution names the cost, and hands the next scene its question.
Before and after
The same turning point, with and without a choice
The one faultThere is no crisis: after the turning point the outcome simply happens to her.
The burial register was where the index said it would be, and Maureen had it open on the vestry table before the kettle boiled.
The entry she wanted was not there. Neither was the page. Someone had taken it out with a blade, close to the binding, and done it neatly.
She turned back one leaf. Its reverse was blank. She tilted the book to the window and the blank filled with dents: the ghost of the missing page, pressed through by a hard pen. A name. Half a date.
The outer door banged. “Only me,” the verger called. “Don’t get up.”
He came in before she could close the book. “Ah, the old registers,” he said. “I’ll take that one. The binding’s going.” He lifted it out of her hands, kindly, and locked it in the vestry safe.
She was pouring the water when he came back with the biscuit tin.
The two versions are identical up to the verger’s call from the door, which is the turning point: Maureen has found the evidence, and the one man who could remove it has arrived.
In the first version he walks in and removes it. The scene still has a turn and a loss, but Maureen is a bystander at her own scene.
The second version puts three sentences between the door and the outcome. They give her two options, each with a price: lose the book, or steal it from a church she helps to run. His stick on the flagstones puts a clock on it. Then she acts. The outcome is different, and has to be, because it now results from her choice.
The exception
When to break it
The five commandments are a tool for looking at a scene after it is drafted, and a poor checklist to draft from.
A tool for looking, not drafting
Not every crisis needs spelling out. When the reader already knows what each option would cost, a beat of hesitation can stand for the whole dilemma.
The choice may belong to someone other than the viewpoint character, who can only watch another person decide.
In some stories, horror and tragedy especially, the absence of choice is the point: the character is carried, and the reader is meant to feel it.
The opposite risk is a book in which every scene ends in an agonised either-or. In a small scene the crisis can be as light as whether to answer the phone.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which line is the climax?
Late in a scene, an accounts clerk called Aditi has reached her crisis: own up to the error and probably lose her job, or stay silent and let a colleague take the blame. Which of these lines is the climax?
Key takeaway
A scene that works usually has an event that starts it, tries that fail until one changes things, a choice in which both options cost something, an act and a result. When a scene is busy but flat, look for the choice. Show both options before the character moves, and make the move an act.
