Ground before the first blow
An action scene asks the reader to track bodies moving fast through a space they cannot see. They can only do that if they have the space before the moves begin. Spend two or three sentences on the ground in the quiet before the fight: where each person stands, and the two or three things in the room that will matter. The bannister, the open hatch, the knife on the table.
Set out before the fight
- Where each person standsAgainst a door, a table, each other
- What the fight will useThe hatch, the knife, the ink ball
- The way outAnd who is between the character and it
Once the action starts, every sentence of description is a sentence in which the fight stops. And if the reader learns about the trapdoor only as someone falls through it, it feels like a convenience. If they saw it on the way in, it feels like fate. The Blocking and staging lesson covers keeping track of positions; this one is about using them at speed.
One move at a time
A reader builds an action in their head one piece at a time. A sentence that carries a block, a counter and a fall asks them to picture three things at once, and it is easy to skim it and lose the thread. Give each move that matters its own sentence or its own clause, and put the cause before the effect: the blade comes down, then he gets his arm up. That is the order the character lives it in, and it lets each move land before the next one starts.
Packed, and one at a time
Sentence length sets the pace. Short sentences hand over one move at a time and read fast. A long run joined by “and” can feel like a scramble with no time to breathe. What slows a fight down is the clause that explains (because, which, so that) and the comparison that takes the reader’s eye off the action.
What the character can take in
A person in a fight does not see the whole fight. Attention narrows to a hand, a blade, a door. Sounds drop out. Pain can blank everything for a moment, and seconds go missing. Letting the prose narrow and blur with the viewpoint character is honest, and it is often more frightening than a clear view from above.
The limits cut the other way too. The character cannot see what happens behind them, read the attacker’s thoughts or watch their own face. When the narration reports those things, the viewpoint breaks at the moment the reader should be closest to it. Blur works when you, the writer, still know where everyone is, so that the pieces the character does catch fit together.
A fight is a scene
Choreography is a list of moves. A fight becomes a scene when the character wants something inside it more specific than winning: to reach the radio, to keep hold of the letter, to get the boy out without killing his father. That goal shapes every choice, and the choices are what the reader follows. Let at least one be visible, a moment where the character could do one thing and does another.
From choreography to scene
- A goalSomething more specific than winning
- The movesOne at a time, cause before effect
- A choiceShe could run, and she stays
- A costSomething that lasts past the scene
And let it cost. Fights tend to be short and exhausting. Arms go heavy fast, a hand that has hit a jaw does not close properly afterwards, and the shaking comes later. A fight that leaves no mark suggests the next one will not matter either. A cut that is still stiff two chapters on keeps the stakes alive.
Example
Something she will not leave
A printer in her own shop, a man with a cudgel, and a pamphlet she will not abandon.
The print shop was one long room: the press in the middle, the yard door at the back.1 The man with the cudgel had come in by the front and shut it behind him.
Hester could have reached the yard door. She looked at it once.2 Then she looked at the press, where two hours of work sat locked in its iron frame, every line of the pamphlet that would clear her brother3, and she stayed where she was.
He came round the press on the left. She went right, keeping it between them.
He swung across the bed of the press. The cudgel cracked against the iron, and the shock of it opened his hand.4 It dropped behind the press, out of reach.
He came over the top for her instead. She snatched the ink ball off its rest, sodden and black, and drove it into his face. He reeled back with both hands to his eyes, and she got her shoulder into his ribs and pushed until the front door met his back.
Afterwards she tried to lock the door and could not turn the key. Her arms had gone to water5, and the heel of her hand, where she had caught the edge of the press, was split across. She sat on the floor by the door until the shaking stopped.
- “The print shop was one long room: the press in the middle, the yar…”The ground, in one sentence, before anyone moves. Everything the fight uses is here or arrives with the man: the press, the two doors.
- “Hester could have reached the yard door. She looked at it once.”A visible choice. She could leave, and the reader watches her decide not to.
- “every line of the pamphlet that would clear her brother”The goal inside the fight. She does not need to beat him. She needs the press untouched.
- “The cudgel cracked against the iron, and the shock of it opened hi…”Cause, then effect, in the order it happens. One move in the sentence, and its result.
- “Her arms had gone to water”The cost. She cannot turn a key, her hand is split, and the shaking comes afterwards.
Before and after
The locker room
The one faultSeveral moves are packed into each long sentence, so no single move lands.
The guard was bigger than Nadia, and he knew it, so he came in low with his arms wide to pin her against the lockers, but she stepped left and his shoulder hit metal, and as he turned her knee went into the side of his thigh, which made the leg fold, though he grabbed her jacket on the way down and took her with him, so that they hit the tiles together with his weight across her hips. The keycard was on his belt, where she could see it but not reach it, so she drove her elbow back into his face, then again, until his grip loosened and she could tear the card free and roll clear.
The events are the same in both, in the same order: the rush, the sidestep, the knee, the fall, the keycard, the elbow. In the first version they arrive in two long sentences held together by so, but, as, which and so that. The reader has to keep the sidestep in mind while the knee arrives and the fall begins, and most of it blurs.
The second gives each move its own sentence and lets the paragraph breaks mark the turns. Notice the short paragraph about the keycard. It holds the action for a heartbeat to show what Nadia wants, so that the elbow that follows reads as a choice, not just another blow.
The exception
When to break it
Not every fight wants the full treatment. If the outcome is not in doubt, or the aftermath matters more than the blows, summarise it in a line and spend the words on what follows.
A confused fight can be right for a viewpoint character who is drunk, concussed or in a fight for the first time; the reader shares the chaos, and the clarity comes afterwards. And some readers, of martial fantasy and historical swordplay among others, enjoy precise technique, so a named parry is part of the pleasure. Even then, keep the character’s goal and choices in view, so that the technique serves the story.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
The trapdoor
A fight in an inn cellar will turn on a trapdoor in the floor: the attacker goes through it. Where in the chapter will the trapdoor do the most for the reader?
Key takeaway
Set out the ground before the first blow. Give each move its own beat, cause before effect, and let sentence length set the pace. Stay inside what the viewpoint character can take in. Give them a goal inside the fight, let their choices show, and make the fight cost something that lasts.
