One test
Advice about adjectives and adverbs tends to arrive as a ban. A ban is easy to follow and it produces thin prose, because some modifiers are the most important words in their sentences. The useful question is not how many you have. It is what each one does.
Take it out and read again
So take the modifier out and read the sentence again. If the reader would picture the same thing, the word was a passenger. If the sentence now says something different, or has lost the one fact that mattered, the word was working.
“He picked up the wrong suitcase.” Take out “wrong” and there is no story.
Four passengers
Doublers repeat the word they sit beside. Whispered quietly, shouted loudly, tiny speck, unexpected surprise. A quick check is to try the opposite. If nobody can shout quietly, “loudly” is adding nothing.
- DoublersWhispered quietly, tiny speck, unexpected surprise
- DefaultsGreen grass, cold snow, a dark night
- IntensifiersVery, really, absolutely, extremely
- StacksThe long, dark, narrow corridor
Defaults supply what the reader would have assumed. Green grass, cold snow, a tall mast, a dark night. They are true, and the reader had already painted them in.
Intensifiers try to turn up the volume: very, really, absolutely, extremely. They usually signal that the word they lean on was not strong enough, or was strong enough already. “Absolutely certain” is no surer than “certain”.
Stacks are three adjectives where one would serve. The long, dark, narrow corridor. Each added adjective takes attention from the others, so the reader ends up holding none of them. Choose the one that this corridor has and other corridors do not.
What a working modifier does
It picks out which one: the left boot, the second door. It measures: half asleep, three-legged, twice. It goes against what the reader expected: warm snow, a cheerful undertaker, smiled coldly. Or it carries the judgement of the person whose eyes we are behind: her wretched cousin, the so-called doctor.
Four jobs worth keeping
That last kind is easy to cut by mistake. In a close point of view, an adjective is often a piece of characterisation. It tells us less about the cousin than about the person looking at her.
Plenty of adverbs are not about manner at all. Already, still, almost, upstairs, twice and tomorrow tell us when, where or how far. They are part of the structure of a sentence, and no sensible advice is aimed at them.
Position matters too. A modifier placed last, or set off by commas, takes the stress. Save that seat for one that deserves it.
Example
Every modifier working
A child narrator describes an aunt. There are few adjectives here and one -ly adverb. Try removing each.
My aunt kept the good scissors in the second drawer and the bad scissors on a nail1 by the door, where anyone could take them. She had one deaf ear, the left2, and she turned it towards people she had finished with. On the Sunday my father came to ask for the loan she listened to him with her whole3 face. Then she got up, slowly4, and turned her head.
- “the good scissors in the second drawer and the bad scissors on a nail”“Good” and “bad” pick out which scissors, and show a woman who ranks her belongings. “Second” picks out the drawer. Remove any of the three and the sentence stops making sense.
- “one deaf ear, the left”A fact, a number and a side. The side is placed last, after a comma, where it will be remembered. The ending depends on it.
- “whole”Take it out and “listened to him with her face” is nonsense. With it, we know she has not yet turned the deaf ear.
- “slowly”A manner adverb, and the passage would be poorer without it. Set between commas, it makes the reader wait, as the father is waiting, for the turn of her head.
Before and after
The same sighting, with and without passengers
The one faultModifiers that change nothing crowd the ones that matter.
The midshipman climbed the tall mainmast in the freezing cold dawn and looked carefully out across the wide, flat, grey sea. A tiny speck showed to the north. He was absolutely certain it was a sail. He shouted loudly down to the deck that it carried a black flag, and the watch below, who had been half asleep, looked suddenly up as one man.
Nine words separate the two versions, and every one is a modifier that failed the test. A mainmast is tall. “Freezing cold” says one thing twice, and so do “tiny speck” and “shouted loudly”. A lookout looks carefully by trade. “Wide, flat, grey” is a stack, and the second version keeps the one adjective that sets a mood. “Absolutely” adds nothing to “certain”, and men who look up as one man have looked up suddenly.
Now look at what both versions keep: freezing, grey, north, black, half asleep. Remove any of those and the scene changes.
The gain is more than nine words. In the first version “black” has to compete with a dozen other modifiers. In the second it has three for company, and the reader sees the flag.
The exception
When to break it
Voice comes first. A gushing narrator, a child, a salesman or a teller of gothic tales may pile up modifiers, and the pile is who they are. Strip it and you have removed the character.
Some books make a pleasure of rich description. The test still holds inside lush prose, since each adjective should bring a new fact. But the right number is a matter of the book you are writing, not of a count.
Rhythm is a fair reason. “A long, slow afternoon” nearly doubles, and the sentence may still want both beats. People double in speech as a matter of course: a tiny little thing, a great big mess.
A stack earns its place when the thing deserves a pause, such as the first sight of a place the story will live in, and when each adjective comes from a different sense.
And writing with no modifiers at all, as one exercise below asks, is a drill and not a style. It shows you how much nouns and verbs can carry. Afterwards, put back the modifiers that work.
Check yourself
Quick checkabout 1 min
Which modifier is working?
In three of these sentences the modifier could go and the reader would picture the same thing. In which one does it change the meaning?
Key takeaway
Judge each adjective and adverb by taking it out. Cut the ones that repeat their word, state what the reader assumed, turn up the volume or stand in a stack. Keep the ones that pick out, measure, surprise or carry the viewpoint character’s judgement, and give the best of them the stressed position.
